Who makes VHSCREAM, and what that means for the scores
VHSCREAM scores horror on six continuous axes of fear — 320 works and 1920 scores so far. Every number is scored against a written rubric, drafted with machine assistance and labelled a draft until a human confirms it. Not an average of votes, not derived from any third-party rating, and published as a dataset so you can check it.
Who writes this
Everything here is currently published under the VHSCREAM name rather than a personal byline. That is a real limitation and worth stating plainly rather than dressing up: criticism is a person-branded field, and a reader deciding whether to trust a score is entitled to know whose eye it is. The byline goes on when there is a person willing to put their name against every number, not before.
What one scoring eye costs you
A single scorer is the only reason the numbers mean anything: a consistent eye produces a scale where 030 on one page is the same 030 on another, which is exactly what an aggregate of strangers cannot give you. It is also the honest weakness of the whole project. One person's blind spots are in the data, and the map documents two of them being found and corrected — a missing corner of mainstream jump-scare horror, and its mirror image in the multiplex splatter the index had skipped.
Two rules follow from that, and they are enforced by the build rather than promised. No vector, no page — nothing publishes without a full six-axis score. And a score is labelled a draft on its own page until a human has confirmed it against the rubric, with the date shown.
What we do not do
No star ratings, ours or anyone else's. No third-party rating appears anywhere on this site and the build fails if one does. The axes are measurements and not verdicts: 008 on tone means a work is bleak, not that it is bad, and low is not worse anywhere on any axis.
Cover art, trailers and streaming availability come from TMDB, Open Library and MusicBrainz. The scores are ours.
How to argue with a number
Every axis on every work page has a control to challenge the score. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what a human looks at first. A score that people keep disputing goes to the top of the re-scoring queue, which is the only sensible thing to do with a disagreement about a judgment.
The rubric → · The dataset → · The map →
Questions about who makes this
Who writes VHSCREAM?
Everything is published under the VHSCREAM name rather than a personal byline today. That is a real limitation rather than a style choice, and it is stated on this page: a reader deciding whether to trust a score is entitled to know whose eye it is. The byline goes on when a person is willing to put their name against every number.
Are the VHSCREAM scores AI-generated?
They are drafted with machine assistance and then confirmed by a human against the rubric. Until that confirmation happens a score is labelled a draft on its own page, with the date shown, so you can see which numbers have had a second look: 0 of 320 vectors are human-confirmed so far.
Does VHSCREAM use IMDb or Rotten Tomatoes ratings?
No, and the build fails if one appears. No third-party rating is displayed, averaged in or used as an input anywhere on the site. The six axes are measurements against a published rubric, which is why they ship as declared scales rather than as a star rating that would tell every consumer higher is better.
How do I challenge a score I disagree with?
Every axis on every work page carries a control to dispute that one number. The votes do not move the score, and they are not meant to: they decide what a human re-scores first. A number people keep disputing goes to the top of the queue, which is the only sensible thing to do with a disagreement about a judgment.
Does VHSCREAM cover anything other than horror?
No. Horror is the whole index and the constraint is absolute, including for comedy, which is in only where it is comedy horror. A crime drama or a thriller does not qualify because it is bleak — works have been measured, found to have real search demand, and refused on exactly that ground.