VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Subgenres

What analog horror is, and what it is not

Analog horror is internet horror that presents itself as recovered broadcast material — emergency alerts, public information films, station idents, training tapes, dead air — released as a serialised run of short videos. The fiction is not that somebody filmed this. It is that somebody transmitted it, and that a tape of it survived.

We score eight of them, on the same six axes as every film and novel here, which as far as we can establish nobody else has done at all. This page used to say we scored none of it, and it existed because the low end of our own era bias axis is labelled analog and means something completely different. That collision is still real — if you searched for analog horror and landed on our analog-era film list, that was our fault, not yours. What that list holds is films that look recovered because they were shot on film in 1974. What you are looking for is a genre that mostly did not exist before 2015, and it now has a shelf of its own.

eight scored · 320 works in the index · the rubric

Where the term came from

It is usually traced to Local 58, the YouTube series Kris Straub began on 26 October 2015, which carried the slogan analog horror at 476 MHz. That attribution should be held loosely: the sources for it are wikis and fan histories rather than anything citable, and earlier web series were already doing the work — No Through Road dates to January 2009. What is clear is that the name settled on Straub’s series and the conventions did too.

The lineage runs through creepypasta rather than through film. Straub wrote Candle Cove in 2009 as a forum thread in which several adults slowly agree that they remember a children’s programme which, it turns out, was never broadcast. That is the whole genre in one post: not a monster, but a gap in the record where a transmission should be. The Mandela Catalogue (2021) and Gemini Home Entertainment (November 2019) are what turned it from a format into a genre with its own furniture.

Its arrival in 2020 was not an accident of taste. It is made by people with no budget, for a platform that rewards serialisation, about a media era most of its audience is too young to remember — which is exactly the condition under which a texture becomes frightening rather than nostalgic.

The series that define it

Five of the six are now scored and link to a full review; the rest are described. Every one of these is free on YouTube, which is part of what the genre is. Dates are first upload. Tone runs from a bleak, unforgiving tone at 000; pace from slow-burn dread at 000; era bias from analog texture at 000 to modern craft at 100 — and that last column is the finding, which the section below unpacks.

SeriesFromBy TonePaceEra What it does
Local 582015Kris Straub010016086The one the name settled on. A fictional northern-Ohio TV station whose overnight schedule keeps being interrupted by something using the emergency alert system. Contingency is the single most imitated piece of work in the genre: a civil defence film, calmly read, instructing you to do the one thing you must not do.
Gemini Home Entertainment2019Remy Abode008018088VHS educational tapes from a world where the cosmic horror is already settled policy — nature documentaries, home safety films and parenting guides for a planet that has something wrong with it. It took the Local 58 format and proved it could carry a mythology rather than a single joke.
The Walten Files2020Martin Walls012048086The mascot branch. Company introductory tapes and training videos for a defunct family restaurant, descended openly from Five Nights at Freddy’s and aimed at the same audience grown slightly older. Proof that analog horror is a format rather than a subject.
The Mandela Catalogue2021Alex Kister006062090The biggest of them, and the one that moved the fear from the broadcast to the viewer. Its alternates are entities that wear the faces of people you know and appear in your home, and its PSAs are about how to tell. Kister was seventeen when the first short went up on 9 June 2021.
Vita Carnis2022Darian Quilloynot scoredThe biology branch, and the one that tests the definition. It presents as a suppressed documentary about meat that has learned to imitate — lures, mimics, herds — which makes it a recovered film rather than a recovered transmission. It is analog horror by texture and lineage, not by the strict reading this page gives the term.
The Backrooms2022Kane Pixels018034084Adjacent rather than inside. Parsons’ Found Footage shorts put a camcorder operator inside the creepypasta liminal space, which is found footage proper by the distinction above — there is somebody holding the camera and he can be caught. Listed because everybody arrives here looking for it.

Two attributions are held loosely. Gemini Home Entertainment is credited to Remy Abode, which is the name the work itself carries and as far as this page goes no further identification is asserted; an earlier version of this table left the row blank rather than name anybody, which was over-cautious about a credit the series puts on its own tapes. The Vita Carnis spelling varies between sources. This page holds the coinage of the term loosely for the same reason, and it would be strange to be careful about that and careless about these.

Every one we have scored, with the numbers: the analog horror series in this index, which is this table's scored rows on their own page with all six axes rather than the three that matter to the finding below. Every other medium split of a subgenre guide here is linked from both its parent and its medium hub; this one was linked only from the web series shelf, which left it on one inbound link where its siblings have two.

What the genre is actually doing

The voice is calm and should not be. Almost every piece of analog horror is narrated by an institution — a broadcaster, a government department, a company training tape — using the register those bodies use when they want you not to panic. The horror is the gap between that register and the content. Nobody screams. A pleasant voice tells you which of your children to check.

The unit of storytelling is interface, not coverage. A film cuts between shots. Analog horror cuts between a test card, an alert crawl, a slide, a countdown clock, dead air. That inventory is small and everybody is using the same pieces, which is why the genre has a house style so quickly and why a weak entry is obvious immediately: it reaches for a monster because it cannot make the furniture frightening.

Degradation is the narrator. Tracking error, dropout and generation loss decide what you are allowed to see, and they are not neutral — the damage always falls where the information is. This is the oldest trick in horror, the withheld look, rebuilt out of a format instead of out of staging, and it is the reason these work at 480p and stop working if you remaster them.

There is nobody on screen to care about. No protagonist, no face, no survivor. That removes the standard horror contract, where fear is routed through somebody you are following, and replaces it with something closer to dread about a place. It is also why the serialised form matters: the audience assembles the story across uploads, in comments and on wikis, which makes the watching participatory in a way a film cannot be.

It is made by teenagers with no money, and that is not a limitation. The budget constraint produces the aesthetic, the aesthetic is the genre, and the people making it are mostly too young to remember the broadcast era it is nostalgic for. Horror has repeatedly been renewed by whoever had cheap access to a new format — Super 8, VHS, camcorder, now the upload — and this is that, happening now, in public.

Analog horror is not found footage

These get merged constantly and the difference is load-bearing: found footage has an operator and analog horror does not.

In found footage somebody inside the story is holding the camera. Your fear comes from the fact that the frame can miss things and the person holding it can die, and the reassurance a normal film gives you — somebody chose this shot and lived — is withdrawn. Analog horror withdraws something else. There was no camera operator; there was a broadcast, and you are watching a tape of it. So its storytelling units are not shots but interface: a test card, a station ident, an emergency alert crawl, a PSA with a voice that is being careful with you. Nobody is in danger on screen because there is nobody on screen. The threat is in the transmission.

That also makes the two feel different. Found footage is frantic. Analog horror is patient and administrative, and frightens people by being calm about something it should not be calm about. We do score found footage, and it has its own guide.

Why our analog axis is a different thing

Era bias is one of six axes we score every work on. It runs from analog texture at 0 to modern craft at 100, and it is a measurement of how a thing looks and sounds, applied to films, television, novels, records and web series we have watched or read in full. Analog horror is a genre, defined by what its fiction claims about itself. One of those is a number and the other is a kind of story, and they happen to share a word.

We are not in a strong position to be smug about the confusion, either. The film most often compared to analog horror is Skinamarink (2022) — shot to look like someone’s degraded home video of a house at four in the morning — and we score it 096 on era bias, which is the modern ceiling of the whole index. There is a defensible reading behind that (a no-budget digital film made in the analog-horror era is unmistakably of now) and a reading that says we got it wrong. We have said so on the rubric page rather than quietly leaving it, because the axis turning out to track release date more closely than texture is the same problem seen from the other end.

The film and television it came out of

None of these is analog horror and all of them are upstream of it — by descent, by method, or by being the thing people reach for when they try to describe it. The series themselves are in the table further up and on the web shelf. The last column is each work’s signature axis.

TitleYearWhy it is here Signature axisScore
Channel Zero: Candle Cove2016The direct line. Adapted from Kris Straub’s 2009 creepypasta Candle Cove — a forum thread about a children’s programme that may never have been broadcast. Straub went on to make Local 58.Tone014
Ghostwatch1992The real ancestor, more than twenty years early. A fake live BBC investigation broadcast as fact in 1992, which is analog horror’s central trick done on actual television to an audience that had not consented to a fiction.Viscera020
The Blair Witch Project1999Found footage proper, and the reason the two keep getting confused: a degraded recording, no composer, nobody left to edit it.Viscera006
Lake Mungo2008A mock-documentary that works by making you examine an image rather than watch a scene, which is the mechanism analog horror runs on.Viscera004
Skinamarink2022The film most often compared to analog horror, and the one that shows the confusion is ours too — see below.Pace of Fear002

What happened when we scored it

This section used to be headed “why we do not score it”, and the argument was that our method needs a finished work with an end, because a score is placed against fixed anchor works and an unfinished upload has no shape to anchor. The argument was wrong in the same way a rule about novels would be wrong: a serialised work has a shape before it has an ending, and television has been scored here from the start on exactly that basis. What it would have taken to change our minds, the old text said, was a series that was complete. What actually changed them was noticing that we were refusing to measure the thing this page is about.

And the measurement says something nobody else has said. The genre named for analog texture sits at the modern end of our analog axis, and not marginally: the five tape-simulating series here score between 084 and 090 on era bias, against 002 to 028 for the 68 films here that actually were shot in the era it imitates — everything we hold from before 1995. Analog horror is the most modern-feeling horror we hold, because every artefact in it was chosen by somebody at a keyboard after 2015. The texture is a decision, not a residue.

The works on this shelf that are not simulating anything prove the reading rather than breaking it. Marble Hornets (062), Ben Drowned (034), Petscop (040) use genuine period hardware — a console game captured as video, a camcorder somebody owned — and they land far down the axis, where the films are. Same genre, opposite ends, and the difference is exactly whether the grain was earned or authored.

It also settles an argument this page was already having with itself. The paragraph above notes that we score Skinamarink at 096 on era bias, the modern ceiling of the whole index, and conceded there was a reading in which that was a mistake. The entire analog-horror shelf now measures within a few points of it. That was the right call.

Questions about analog horror

What are the best analog horror series?

The six in the table above are the ones the genre is built out of, and if you are starting, start with Local 58 — the episode called Contingency is nine minutes and is the clearest statement of what the form can do. From there The Mandela Catalogue is the most frightening and Gemini Home Entertainment the most inventive. We score eight of these now, so the table above carries their numbers — but this answer is still a recommendation rather than a ranking, because the six axes describe what a work is and not which one is best.

What is the scariest analog horror?

The Mandela Catalogue, for most people, and the reason is structural rather than a matter of taste. Nearly every other series in the genre frightens you about a transmission — something is wrong with the broadcast, out there. Kister's alternates come to your house, wear a face you know, and the PSAs are instructions for telling them apart. It moves the threat from the screen to the other side of your door, which is a different and worse feeling.

What is analog horror?

A form of internet horror that presents itself as recovered material from the broadcast era — emergency alerts, public information films, station idents, training tapes, dead channels — usually released as a serialised series of short videos on YouTube. The fiction is that you are watching something that was transmitted and taped, degraded by the medium it survived on, and that it is telling you something nobody meant to broadcast.

Is analog horror the same as found footage?

No, and the difference is the camera. In found footage somebody inside the story is holding the thing recording — the operator can die and the frame can miss something. Analog horror has no operator: the material was broadcast, and what you are watching is a tape of a transmission. That is why its storytelling units are interface rather than coverage — a test card, a PSA, an emergency alert crawl. We score both: found footage horror has its own guide and the analog horror series are on the web shelf, next to each other rather than merged.

Where did the term analog horror come from?

It is usually traced to Local 58, Kris Straub’s YouTube series, which began on 26 October 2015 and carried the slogan analog horror at 476 MHz. The coinage is not firmly documented — the sources are wikis and fan histories rather than anything citable — so treat 2015 and Straub as where the name settled rather than a first use. The Mandela Catalogue (2021) and Gemini Home Entertainment (November 2019) are the series that turned it into a genre with conventions.

Why does analog horror score at the modern end of your analog axis?

Because the two words collided after we named the axis. Our era bias axis runs from analog texture at 0 to modern craft at 100 and is scored across every film, novel and record in the index — it measures grain, tape hiss and pre-digital craft, not a genre. The most analog-era horror films are the ones that look recovered because they were shot that way, and most of them are from the 1970s. So the genre named for analog texture lands at the opposite end of the axis named for it: the five tape-simulating series we score sit between 084 and 090, against 002 to 028 for the films actually shot before 1995. Every artefact in analog horror was chosen by somebody at a keyboard after 2015, and we score the texture a work has rather than the one it imitates. The exceptions are the works using real period hardware — Ben Drowned at 034, Petscop at 040 — and they sit down with the films.

What is the closest thing in your index to analog horror?

Channel Zero: Candle Cove, by descent — it is adapted from the Kris Straub creepypasta that predates Local 58 by six years, and Straub wrote both. The closest in method is Ghostwatch, which did the central trick on real television in 1992. Those are the film and television ancestors; the genre itself is now on the web shelf, where we score eight series including Local 58 and The Mandela Catalogue.

Found footage horror, scored → · The most analog-era films → · All subgenres →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy