VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index

How we score

Star ratings compress everything worth knowing into one number. VHSCREAM scores every work on six continuous axes instead, against fixed anchor works so the numbers still mean the same thing in six months. Scores are drafted with machine assistance and confirmed by a human against this rubric before they count as settled. This page is the whole method — including how many have actually been confirmed so far, which is currently none.

The six axes

Each axis is anchored by three works pinned at a low, middle and high value. Scoring is placing a work between those anchors, not inventing a number.

PACE OF FEARDREAD 0 → 100 SHOCK

How the fear is delivered — accumulated, or struck. Not how frightening it is.

002Skinamarink
052Halloween
078Re-Animator
THE THREATSUPERNATURAL 0 → 100 HUMAN

What is actually doing the harm. Where a person is the instrument of something else, score by whose will drives it.

010Between Two Fires
040Lake Mungo
096Tender Is the Flesh
VISCERARESTRAINT 0 → 100 EXPLICIT

How much is shown. Implication scores low even when what is implied is horrific.

004Lake Mungo
045Channel Zero: Candle Cove
096Martyrs
ERA BIASANALOG 0 → 100 MODERN

Texture and craft sensibility, not release date. A 2022 film built to feel like degraded video scores low.

004The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
040The Cipher
096Skinamarink
TONEBLEAK 0 → 100 GLEEFUL

Whether the work offers relief. Bleak does not mean serious — it means unrelieved.

003Martyrs
045Books of Blood
092Re-Animator
REALITY ANCHORGROUNDED 0 → 100 SURREAL

How firmly it obeys ordinary rules. A ghost in a consistent world is still fairly grounded.

008Lake Mungo
045Hereditary
095Black One

What we do not claim

Of 320 works in the index, 0 have had their vector explicitly confirmed by a human reviewer against this rubric. The rest are drafts, and every page carrying one says so. We would rather publish the number than round it up.

That date is deliberately here instead of a promised schedule. A cadence we announce is a promise whose breach is silent; a date that stops moving is one you can see from the outside, which is the only kind of commitment this page has any business making.

You can move that number. Every work page now carries a control on each of the six axes: mark the score right, too high, or too low. It takes one click, needs no account, and it is the only way a second human gets into this process. A vote never changes a published score — scores change when a person re-scores the work against the rubric above. Votes decide which work that person picks up next, which is a job the two of us cannot do alone across 320 titles.

Scores drift, so the policy is that a fixed control set of twenty titles gets re-scored every quarter without reference to the previous numbers; drift over ten points on any axis means that axis is ambiguously defined and gets rewritten.

Who is doing the scoring, and what machine-assisted drafting does and does not mean here, is set out on the about page. It matters for reading the rest of this one: a rubric is only as good as the consistency of the eye applying it.

What the era axis turned out to be

The rubric above says era bias measures texture and craft sensibility rather than release date. Checked against the index, it does not behave that way. Correlated against release year the axis sits at r = +0.948 across the 236 films we have scored, +0.979 for television and +0.958 for records — close enough to a straight line that in those three media the score is very nearly the release date wearing a different name. Only books come apart from it, at +0.761, which is the one place the axis is measuring something the calendar does not already tell you.

Two explanations fit that and we cannot yet separate them. Either the catalogue holds almost nothing whose texture diverges from its period — only 19 of the 236 films sit more than fifteen points from where their year predicts — or the axis has been scored from the date rather than from the grain, which would make it the weakest of the six and the one doing the least independent work. We do not know which, and saying so is cheaper than defending a claim we have not tested.

What we changed because of it. Every work page prints the axis that work is furthest from the middle on, and era bias was winning on 36 of the 320 — the commonest signature on the site. In film, television and records that line was the release year printed twice, four words after the year itself, so the axis is now withheld from it in those three media and from the body-of-work profile on the people pages. Books keep it, because +0.761 is a score that still means something. The number is always in the table; it is the verdict it has stopped being allowed to carry. The build refuses to publish a non-print page that puts era bias back there.

What would settle it. A deliberate run of works whose texture fights their date: contemporary films built to look recovered, and older films shot clean. If the correlation survives twenty of those, the axis is a date proxy and should be renamed or retired rather than quietly kept. The films furthest off the line today are the ones to score against: Late Night with the Devil (2024, scored 066 where the line says 091), Nosferatu (2024, scored 068 where the line says 091), Sinners (2025, scored 072 where the line says 093).

The axes are only useful pointed at something.

Build your tape →

Questions about the scoring

What are the six axes VHSCREAM scores horror on?

Pace of Fear, from dread to shock. The Threat, from inhuman to human. Viscera, from restraint to explicit. Era Bias, from analog to modern. Tone, from bleak to gleeful. Reality Anchor, from grounded to surreal. Each runs 0 to 100 as a position between those two named ends, and every one of the 320 works in the index carries all six.

Is a higher VHSCREAM score better?

No, and the axes are built so that reading cannot be had. They are descriptive dimensions rather than verdicts: 008 on tone means a work is bleak, not that it is bad, and low is not worse anywhere on any axis. That is why the numbers are published as measurements with their scale declared and never as a rating out of ten.

Who decides the scores, and can a score be wrong?

One scoring eye against this rubric, which is the only reason 030 on one page means the same as 030 on another. It is also the honest weakness: one person's blind spots are in the data. A score is labelled a draft until a human confirms it, 0 of 320 vectors are confirmed, and every axis carries a control to dispute that number.

Why is era bias left out of comparisons between works?

Because in film, television and records it behaves as a date rather than a texture: the correlation with release year is +0.95 in film. A signature or resemblance claim built on it would be saying two works came out around the same time, so the build refuses to use it there. In books and web series the correlation is genuinely low and the axis stands.

What stops the scales drifting over time?

Anchor works, named on this page, that fix the ends and the middle of each axis. A new score is placed against those rather than against a definition, and what each ten-point band of every axis looks like in practice is listed separately with the works that sit in it, so a number can be argued with against its neighbours.

What each score actually looks like, band by band →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy