VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index

Slow horror follows a rule. Fast horror has none.

We scored 320 horror works — films, television, novels, records and web series — on six continuous axes of fear, by the same rubric, on the same scale. Then we spent two rounds trying to break our own finding, and broke it twice. What survived is narrower than what we started with, and much stranger: in the patient half of horror, how fast the fear arrives predicts how much you will be shown. In the fast half, that rule is gone.

How fast the fear comes vs. how much is shown 320 works · slow half r = +0.52 · fast half r = +0.21
Film, TV & webBooksRecordshover or focus any mark
slow half · r = +0.52 151 works · the line holds fast half · r = +0.21 169 works · the same rule is absent slow-burn dread relentless shock PACE OF FEAR → restraint explicit VISCERA → SkinamarinkMartyrsThe ConjuringTerrifier 2

What happened to the first two versions of this page

Version one looked like a law of the form. The index started as the canon: the films, novels and records that get written about. Scored that way, pace of fear and viscera correlated at r = +0.67 across the 86 works in the index at the time — fast horror shows you things, slow horror withholds — and the fast-but-restrained corner held 2 of them.

It was a law of our sample. The corner was empty because we had not scored a single jump-scare film. The Conjuring, Insidious, Sinister, Lights Out, Annabelle, The Nun — the Conjuring Universe is the only horror franchise ever to pass two billion dollars at the box office, and it is built precisely to frighten you fast while showing you almost nothing. We scored six of those under the same rubric. The corner filled and the correlation fell to +0.50.

Version two died to one word: Saw. Having found one blind spot we went looking for its mirror image and found it immediately. We had scored the multiplex that shows nothing and skipped the multiplex that shows everything: Saw, Final Destination, Evil Dead (2013), It, Terrifier 2 — another franchise past a billion dollars, and four more films that made a great deal of money pointing the camera exactly where the canon will not. So we scored those too, and the correlation went back up — it sits at r = +0.49 today, after every addition described below. Two rounds of work to arrive roughly where we started is the point at which the number stops being the finding.

The shape was never a line. It is two populations. Cut the index at the pace midpoint and the single correlation comes apart:

The confidence intervals do not overlap; the difference between the two correlations is z = 3.19 — about one chance in 705 of turning up by luck. Restricted to film and television only, it is the same story: +0.48 across 94 slow works, +0.26 across 158 fast ones.

Be precise about what that does and does not show. 169 works cannot establish that the relationship in fast horror is exactly zero; the interval reaches +0.35, so a weak version of the rule is still live there. What the interval does do is stop below +0.39 — below where the slow half’s interval begins — so the two cannot be the same number. The finding is the difference, not the absence. Whatever fast horror is doing, it is demonstrably not doing what slow horror does, and the headline is shorthand for that.

The uncomfortable part: it was there from the beginning. Take the version-one index — before the jump-scare films, before the gore, before any of this — and split it the same way, and it gives +0.67 across 68 slow works against +0.04 across 18 fast ones. The two populations were visible in the first 86 works we ever scored. We spent two rounds arguing about a corner because we were looking at a corner. The lesson we are taking from that is about instruments rather than about horror: a single correlation across a whole index is a bad instrument, and we used one for two rounds without asking what it was averaging together.

The obvious objection, and why it doesn’t hold. Splitting on pace narrows pace, and a narrowed predictor mechanically deflates a correlation — so the fast half should look weaker whatever is true. Except that the deflation runs the wrong way here. Cut at the median instead of at 50 and the fast group is the wider of the two in pace (SD 7.1 vs 13.5) and the relationship is still gone: r = +0.25 against r = +0.53 for the slow group. A wider predictor producing a weaker relationship is not range restriction. Something else is going on.

Our guess, offered as a guess. Speed doesn’t make the choice; somebody made it upstream. A film committed to a fright every few minutes still has to build each one out of something, but how much that production is willing to show was settled before pace was — by a rating, a budget, and whatever audience the title already has. A patient film has room to modulate, so its restraint reads as a property of the film itself. A fast film spends whatever it was handed, quickly. That is what an r of +0.21 would look like from the inside.

The tidier version of that guess is wrong, and we checked. The tidy version says speed forces a binary — restraint at speed becomes the jump scare, explicitness at speed becomes the set piece — so fast horror should pile up at both ends of the viscera scale and hollow out in the middle. It doesn’t. 41 of 169 fast works sit in the middle band of viscera (40–60), against 47 of 151 slow ones: 24% against 31%, effectively the same share. Fast horror is not polarised into two camps. It is spread across the whole range and simply does not care how fast it is going. That is a weaker and less quotable claim than the one we wanted, and it is the one the numbers support.

The old works in that corner, after we went and checked. A previous draft of this paragraph said only Halloween (1978) and The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974) sat in the fast-but-restrained corner from before 2000. That was true of the index and false of horror: we had never scored Jaws, Poltergeist, The Omen or Psycho, which is precisely the mistake that killed the last two versions of this page. So we scored them. Jaws and Poltergeist landed in that corner; The Omen and Psycho did not. The corner now holds Psycho (OST) (1960), The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974), Jaws (1975), Jaws (OST) (1975), Halloween (1978), Phantasm (1979), Poltergeist (1982), Gremlins (1984), Beetlejuice (1988), Child's Play (1988), Friday the 13th Part VII: The New Blood (1988), Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988), Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan (1989), Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989), Freddy's Dead: The Final Nightmare (1991), Child's Play 3 (1991), Army of Darkness (1993), The Return of the Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1995), Halloween H20: 20 Years Later (1998) — six works, not two. Restraint at speed is not a modern invention, and 1975 is not a fluke.

Of the 107 fast works we have scored from this century, 28 take that restrained lane and 79 take the explicit one. Studio horror did not choose a new lane. It widened one that was already there.

Horror is still not having fun. Median tone across the index is 22 / 100, where 0 is unrelieved and 100 is gleeful. The genre’s reputation for camp rests on a handful of outliers. Pace and tone correlate at r = +0.52: the fast stuff is the funny stuff.

Where this index actually lives

A byproduct of wiring up availability, and the only figure on this page that is not about fear. Of the 252 films and television series here, 61 are on a subscription service somewhere, and the services are not evenly spread: Philo carries 24, AMC+ carries 16, HBO Max carries 14, fuboTV carries 14. Collapsing the resale duplicates — “Shudder”, “Shudder Amazon Channel” and “Shudder Apple TV channel” are one service — this is disproportionately a Shudder and AMC+ catalogue, which says something about where the kind of horror we score has ended up.

As of the 2026-10-20 availability pass, US region. That date is doing real work: streaming rights move constantly, so this figure rots in a way the fear scores do not. It is computed in the same build, from the same snapshot, as the “where to find it” line on each of the 252 pages — so the total and the pages cannot disagree, and you can check it by tallying them yourself the day it is published.

Check this yourself

Every number on this page comes out of one table, and that table is published as CSV and JSON under CC BY 4.0 — 320 works, 1920 scores, the rubric linked. The correlation above rests on roughly fifty works per group, which is fragile enough that a handful of additions could move it. We would rather you tested it than believed it.

Method, and what would falsify this

Every work is scored 0–100 on each axis against fixed anchor works, so numbers stay comparable across media and months. The rubric is published. The halves use a strict cut at 50 — above 50 is fast, 50 and below is slow. Every figure describing the index as it stands is computed from the table at the bottom, so anyone can reproduce or contradict it; the version-one figures are computed the same way from the archived catalogue, over the 86 real works in it, which is why the history is quoted against 86 and not 320.

One scorer, zero confirmed. All 320 vectors were drafted by a single scorer and none has yet been confirmed by a second human. That matters more here than it did for the last version of the finding, because there is an obvious way to fake this result: if the scorer simply had a firmer mental model for patient horror and was guessing more freely about the fast stuff, the extra noise would flatten the fast half’s relationship and look exactly like what we are claiming.

That one is testable without a second human, so we tested it. Careless scoring is not selective — it would flatten every relationship in the fast half, not just the one we are interested in. It doesn’t. Across the other fourteen pairs of axes, the fast half is the more strongly structured of the two: mean |r| of 0.16 against 0.15 for the slow half, and 7 of 14 pairs stronger in the fast half. Viscera itself is spread wider there, not narrower (22.1 against 23.7). One pair collapses in the fast half and it is the pair the finding is about. That is what structure looks like; noise does not aim.

What that test does not rule out is the narrower version: a scorer whose theory of patient horror links pace and restraint, manufacturing the slow half’s correlation rather than the fast half’s absence. Confirming the slow half’s vectors against the published rubric is what settles that, and it is the specific thing the confirmation pass has to settle.

The sample is still not random — it is the canon, the corners, and now the box office. The ledger, so that a reader adding up the numbers above arrives at 320: 95 entries at version one, minus the 9 merchandise listings we deleted on finding they described products that did not exist, plus 6 jump-scare films, plus 5 from the gory multiplex, plus the 4 older films in the paragraph above. Those 9 are excluded from every figure on this page, the version-one ones included — which is why the history above is quoted against 86 works and not 95 entries. These correlations describe this index, not all of horror, and the index has 169 fast works to the slow half’s 151: the weaker result rests on the smaller pile. We have already been wrong twice here by not looking where we hadn’t looked. If you can name a work that should sit somewhere on this map and doesn’t, that is the most useful thing you can send us — both of the last two gaps of that kind rewrote this page.

Name a work this map is missing

This page has been rewritten twice by exactly this, and both times the person who named the gap was right and we were wrong. No account, no newsletter unless you ask for one.

All 320 works as a table
WorkYearMediumPaceVisceraTone
Evil Dead II1987Film088088088
Dangerous Days2014Record084055060
Army of Darkness1993Film082050094
28 Weeks Later2007Film082074010
Braindead1992Film080098090
Evil Dead Rise2023Film080092026
Texas Chainsaw Massacre2022Film080090028
Re-Animator1985Film078090092
Evil Dead2013Film078092022
Final Destination 22003Film078084058
Scream VI2023Film078078058
28 Days Later2002Film076066018
Smile 22024Film076082010
The Evil Dead1981Film076084030
Saw 3D2010Film076092030
The Descent2005Film074074014
Lights Out2016Film074020028
Final Destination2000Film074076048
Jaws (OST)1975Record074028048
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 21986Film074076072
Texas Chainsaw 3D2013Film074070046
Aliens1986Film074055036
Terrifier 32024Film074097042
Jason X2002Film074074072
Scream2022Film074072052
The Return of the Living Dead1985Film072076082
Scream1996Film072052072
Smile2022Film072052014
The Nun2018Film072026034
The Monkey2025Film072088082
Off Season1980Book072094008
Dog Soldiers2002Film072078056
No One Will Save You2023Film072044040
You're Next2011Film072072062
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre2003Film072074010
Terrifier2016Film072092030
Freddy vs. Jason2003Film072074066
Scream 42011Film072062064
Insidious: Chapter 32015Film072024034
Halloween Kills2021Film072086020
Ready or Not2019Film070074070
The Texas Chain Saw Massacre1974Film070040018
Insidious2010Film070018030
Annabelle2014Film070024030
Terrifier 22022Film070098044
A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master1988Film070058060
Freddy's Dead: The Final Nightmare1991Film070050076
Saw II2005Film070082016
Saw IV2007Film070086014
Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III1990Film070068026
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning2006Film070086006
Alien: Romulus2024Film070070026
The Nun II2023Film070030032
Friday the 13th2009Film070072024
Scream 21997Film070054066
Slither2006Film068084076
The Conjuring2013Film068022026
Saw2004Film068082018
A Nightmare on Elm Street2010Film068062012
Happy Death Day2017Film068026086
Saw VI2009Film068088024
The Return of the Texas Chainsaw Massacre1995Film068040064
Tucker and Dale vs Evil2010Film066078084
Drag Me to Hell2009Film066062066
A Quiet Place2018Film066030024
Companion2025Film066062058
A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors1987Film066064048
The Devil's Rejects2005Film066086028
Child's Play 21990Film066054042
Bride of Chucky1998Film066066080
Child's Play2019Film066074050
Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth1992Film066080050
Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives1986Film066056062
Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday1993Film066076040
Scream 32000Film066044074
Insidious: Chapter 22013Film066020030
Halloween: Resurrection2002Film066052048
The Cabin in the Woods2011Film064080072
Night of the Living Dead1968Film064052022
An American Werewolf in London1981Film064080052
Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones2014Film064030034
The Hills Have Eyes1977Film064056010
Saw V2008Film064084016
Jigsaw2017Film064074024
Child's Play 31991Film064050040
Alien Resurrection1997Film064068046
The Conjuring 22016Film064022028
Annabelle: Creation2017Film064044016
Friday the 13th: A New Beginning1985Film064070036
Friday the 13th Part VII: The New Blood1988Film064050040
Insidious: The Last Key2018Film064030030
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers1995Film064062018
Martyrs2008Film062096003
One Cut of the Dead2017Film062054084
Books of Blood1984Book062092045
Dawn of the Dead1978Film062078058
The Black Phone2021Film062038028
It2017Film062058040
Weapons2025Film062068038
A Nightmare on Elm Street1984Film062066034
The Mandela Catalogue2021Web series062058006
Psycho (OST)1960Record062030018
14082007Film062042020
Saw X2023Film062090022
A Nightmare on Elm Street 5: The Dream Child1989Film062068032
Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension2015Film062030016
Saw III2006Film062090010
Spiral: From the Book of Saw2021Film062076018
Seed of Chucky2004Film062072086
Leatherface2017Film062078012
Friday the 13th Part III1982Film062066038
Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter1984Film062072030
Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan1989Film062048052
Halloween2007Film062076010
Gremlins1984Film060044070
Suspiria (OST)1977Record060060040
Poltergeist1982Film060042048
Barbarian2022Film060078030
The Mist2007Film060076006
It Chapter Two2019Film060062044
Hostel2005Film060092012
Child's Play1988Film060044034
Alien: Covenant2017Film060076012
The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It2021Film060034024
Annabelle Comes Home2019Film060014046
Friday the 13th Part 21981Film060062030
Halloween H20: 20 Years Later1998Film060046036
Shaun of the Dead2004Film058064080
Talk to Me2022Film058064026
Hellraiser1987Film058090040
Sinister2012Film058040012
Jaws1975Film058034046
28 Years Later2025Film058074022
Sleepaway Camp1983Film058072030
Hush2016Film058052026
The Howling1981Film058076040
Late Night with the Devil2024Film058074014
M3gan2023Film058052054
Friday the 13th1980Film058066030
A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy's Revenge1985Film058056036
Phantasm1979Film058046040
Insidious: The Red Door2023Film058022036
Halloween II1981Film058052018
Halloween II2009Film058084006
Beetlejuice1988Film056030082
Incantation2022Film056074008
Profondo Rosso1975Record056058042
X2022Film056082032
Mother!2017Film056086012
Paranormal Activity 32011Film056014018
The Grudge2004Film056022012
Hellbound: Hellraiser II1988Film056092032
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers1988Film056038016
The Thing1982Film055088022
Between Two Fires2012Book055070022
Oculus2013Film054034016
Sinners2025Film054068052
Paranormal Activity 22010Film054012016
Paranormal Activity 42012Film054016014
Halloween2018Film054058022
Halloween1978Film052022030
Bodies Bodies Bodies2022Film052058060
Threnody for the Victims of Hiroshima1960Record052060002
The Troop2014Book052092006
Us2019Film052062026
The Substance2024Film052094034
Day of the Dead1985Film052092020
Cult of Chucky2017Film052064038
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers1989Film052044020
Maxxxine2024Film050070030
Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin2021Film050040014
Halloween (OST)1978Record048020032
Videodrome1983Film048076038
It Follows (OST)2014Record048040022
The Walten Files2020Web series048054012
Curse of Chucky2013Film048058030
Alien 31992Film048062008
Hellraiser2022Film048078018
The Exorcist1973Film046066012
The Menu2022Film046050052
The Only Good Indians2020Book046074020
Paranormal Activity2007Film046010020
The Strangers2008Film046044008
The Fall of the House of Usher2023Television046078030
It1990Television046024044
Wes Craven's New Nightmare1994Film046052026
Prometheus2012Film046064020
Suspiria1977Film045070035
Get Out2017Film044042044
The Fly1986Film044092020
The Omen1976Film044062008
Together2025Film044086040
Bird Box2014Book044034012
Nope2022Film044052040
The Hellbound Heart1986Book044092022
Pearl2022Film044076030
Ginger Snaps2000Film044066036
Halloween Ends2022Film044066030
Alien1979Film042062020
Kill List2011Film042080016
The Autopsy of Jane Doe2016Film042080015
Housebound2014Film040048074
Possession1981Film040060006
The Ritual2017Film040052018
Candyman1992Film040060018
Psycho1960Film040018022
The Ruins2006Book040088006
The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (OST)1974Record040062008
Penny Dreadful2014Television040068022
Halloween III: Season of the Witch1982Film040042026
Audition1999Film038088016
The Platform2019Film038086010
Carrie1976Film038054026
'salem's Lot1975Book038048012
Ben Drowned2010Web series038008018
Beau Is Afraid2023Film038060022
The Ballad of Black Tom2016Book036050024
The Wolf Man1941Film036010022
The Fog1980Film036024028
What We Do in the Shadows2014Film034042086
The Lighthouse2019Film034044042
In the Tall Grass2019Film034062012
The Girl Next Door1989Book034094002
Hereditary (OST)2018Record034052006
The Backrooms2022Web series034014018
Yellowjackets2021Television034070026
Infinity Pool2023Film034084012
Doctor Sleep2019Film032066026
The Ring2002Film032032014
The Exorcist1971Book032058014
'salem's Lot1979Television032030018
Goodnight Mommy2014Film032074008
Hereditary2018Film030055008
Tender Is the Flesh2017Book030078004
The Babadook2014Film030026014
Gerald's Game2017Film030082012
The Invitation2015Film030045012
Jacob's Ladder1990Film030052008
Ghostwatch1992Television030020024
The Shining1977Book030044016
The Fog (OST)1980Record030018026
Bring Her Back2025Film030082008
The Hollow Places2020Book030030034
Longlegs2024Film030058010
Interview with the Vampire2022Television030066034
Archive 812022Television030042026
The Cipher1991Book028072010
The Shining1980Film028030018
Mexican Gothic2020Book028052026
It Follows2014Film026030020
Midsommar2019Film026062030
The Dark and the Wicked2020Film026072004
Pet Sematary1983Book026066004
The Croning2012Book026058012
Nosferatu2024Film026062008
Candyman (OST)1992Record026024016
Channel Zero: Candle Cove2016Television025045014
Ringu1998Film024022012
It Comes at Night2017Film024055006
Midnight Mass2021Television024050016
Dracula1897Book024032030
Ghost Story1979Book024044018
Under the Skin (OST)2013Record024030008
Marble Hornets2009Web series024018014
Hannibal2013Television024086020
The Wailing2016Film024072016
The Haunting of Hill House2018Television022025020
Abyss2015Record022030012
Men2022Film022078014
The Terror2018Television022054010
Ring1991Book022030014
The Last House on Needless Street2021Book022044010
The Wicker Man1973Film020018052
The Endless2017Film020014034
Twin Peaks: The Return2017Television020048032
The Elementals1981Book020034030
The Shining (OST)1980Record020018014
Deathconsciousness2008Record018025005
The Blair Witch Project1999Film018006014
The Witch2015Film018038008
A Tale of Two Sisters2003Film018042010
Frankenstein1818Book018030014
Presence2025Film018014024
Annihilation2014Book018038012
The Woman in Black1983Book018016012
Gemini Home Entertainment2019Web series018046008
The Haunting of Bly Manor2020Television018016024
The Others2001Film018008010
Don't Look Now1973Film016032010
Let the Right One In2008Film016044012
Session 92001Film016026012
Rebecca1938Book016010022
Local 582015Web series016022010
House of Leaves2000Book015020016
Rosemary's Baby1968Film014010026
A Dark Song2016Film014034010
The Killing of a Sacred Deer2017Film014050008
The King in Yellow1895Book014020016
Our Wives Under the Sea2022Book014044010
The Thing (OST)1982Record014022010
Cure1997Film014054006
I Saw the TV Glow2024Film014028012
The Fisherman2016Book012040014
The Blackcoat's Daughter2015Film012055008
Les Revenants2012Television012018014
We Have Always Lived in the Castle1962Book012016044
Petscop2017Web series012010006
Rosemary's Baby (OST)1968Record012010030
The Haunting of Hill House1959Book010008018
At the Mountains of Madness1936Book010028010
Under the Skin2013Film010048008
The Turn of the Screw1898Book008006020
Lake Mungo2008Film006004012
Everywhere at the End of Time2016Record006014004
Selected Ambient Works Volume II1994Record006008016
Black One2005Record004055006
Heresy1990Record004020006
Khanate2001Record004072004
Skinamarink2022Film002006010
Time Machines1998Record002010008

The axes are only interesting pointed at you.

Build your tape →

Questions about the pace-of-fear finding

Does slow horror follow a rule that fast horror does not?

In this index, yes. Across 151 works in the patient half of the pace axis, how fast the fear arrives correlates with how much is shown at r = +0.52. Across the 169 works in the fast half the same relationship is effectively absent, at r = +0.21. One rule, and it only holds on one side.

What does pace of fear measure?

Where a work sits between dread and shock, 0 to 100 — not how frightening it is. A work at the bottom builds and gives you time to understand what is coming; one at the top arrives without warning. It is scored against a published rubric, independently of every other axis, which is what makes correlating it with viscera meaningful.

How many horror works is this measured across?

320 — films, television, novels, records and web series, all scored on the same six axes by the same rubric on the same scale. Mixing media is deliberate: a finding that only holds for films is a finding about films, and this one is tested on everything the index holds.

What would falsify this finding?

A larger, less canonical sample where the two halves behave the same way. The first two versions of this page were broken exactly that way — by our own re-testing, twice — and what survived is narrower than what we started with. The full table and the dataset are published so the check can be run against us.

Is this a claim about horror or about this index?

About this index, and the distinction matters. We chose the 320 works, so the sample is not random and the result cannot be generalised to the genre. What it is, is a measured relationship in a published dataset with the method and the counts stated, which is more than an opinion and less than a law.

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy