VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

SCREAM4 F-2070 · 2011 · FILM

Film · 2011

Scream 4

Wes Craven

Craven's last film, fifteen years on. A remake satire that saw the internet coming.

51Strong to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how much it shows

  • PaceJolts you often72
  • ThreatPeople, entirely96
  • GoreShows some of it62
  • ToneGrim, with air64
  • RealityGrounded18

Era bias 70 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

Horror movies where the monster is a person →

Part of a series: Scream movies in order →

Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Scream 4 (2011) is most extreme on the threat axis: 96 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 95% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Scream 4 is a 2011 American slasher film directed by Wes Craven and written by Kevin Williamson. Fifteen years after the first murders, Sidney Prescott returns to Woodsboro on a book tour and a new Ghostface starts killing the teenagers around her cousin Jill. We score it 096 on the threat axis and 018 on reality anchor: the killers are kids with knives who have watched every film in the series.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Scream 4, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.

The threat at 096 is on the human end — 304 works score lower. Two teenagers with knives, a costume and a plan. Nothing supernatural happens.

Viscera 062 is explicit for the series — 178 works score lower. Stabbings with blood, a knife to the forehead, and a killer who wounds herself to sell the frame.

Tone 064 leans gleeful — 291 works score lower. The satire is sharp and the deaths are often darkly funny, but the ending's cynicism has teeth.

Pace 072 is on the shock side, with 280 works slower. A string of quick attacks and chases, slowing only for the town's anniversary set-up.

Era bias 070 reads modern — 157 works score lower. Clean 2011 finish, live streaming built into the plot, and the series' first major use of CGI.

Reality anchor 018 is grounded — 22 works score lower. Everything in it is possible, including a self-inflicted wound to fake a survival.

On jump scares: several, mostly from the killer stepping into frame behind someone on the phone, which the film knows is the house style.

Who should skip Scream 4

Scream 4 on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Scream 4 looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 72 Jolts you often
THE THREAT 96 People, entirely
VISCERA 62 Shows some of it
ERA BIAS 70 Modern
TONE 64 Grim, with air
REALITY ANCHOR 18 Grounded

Where that puts it: joint #1 human monsters

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Scream 4: the review

Scream 4 arrived a decade early, and it is a much better film than the box office that greeted it.

It was Wes Craven's last film as a director. Kevin Williamson came back to write it, Ehren Kruger was brought in for rewrites during production, and the actors reportedly were not given the script past page 75 so that nobody could leak the ending. The result is a tightly plotted sequel: the old cast back in the old town, a new generation of teenagers who treat the Woodsboro murders as an anniversary event, and a killer whose motive turned out to describe the next ten years of the internet.

The anniversary is the joke and the threat

Sidney comes home to promote a self-help book, with a publicist, Rebecca, who would quite like another murder for the sales. Evidence turns up in her rental car, so she cannot leave. Dewey is married to Gale now, who has writer's block and wants a story. The local teenagers are throwing a Stab-a-thon in a barn, a marathon of all seven Stab films, and two of them, Charlie and Robbie, are horror obsessives who already know the rules, and Robbie live-streams his life.

Craven plays this as a satire of remakes. The new generation is visibly a reboot of the old one, with a cousin standing where Sidney stood and two cinephiles standing where Randy stood. The film keeps pointing at the structure, and then uses the pointing as misdirection. It is a whodunit that tells you, almost out loud, what kind of whodunit it is, and still gets most people.

The motive is the reason it lasts

Jill Roberts wants to be Sidney. Not to kill her because of what happened in 1996, but to replace her: to become the survivor, the face on the news, the girl the films are made about. She plans to frame her ex-boyfriend, kill her accomplice, wound herself and walk out as the sole survivor of a new massacre. Critics at the time found the film formulaic. Later reappraisals have praised it for foreseeing what social media and the pursuit of internet fame would do, and they are right. Emma Roberts plays the reveal with a glee that is properly frightening, because there is no grief or revenge underneath it: she just wants to be watched.

The deaths have more snap than Scream 3's. Anthony Anderson's Deputy Perkins is stabbed in the forehead and keeps talking and walking before he falls, a scene that was not in the script; Craven took it from a real medical emergency he had seen in a documentary and reportedly did not tell the studio first. It is funny and horrible at once, which is what the series does at its best.

Craven's last film is made with real care

There is a confidence in the staging that the third film lacked. Craven shot it around Ann Arbor, Michigan, using a middle school in Dearborn for Woodsboro High and a bookshop in Northville that he found himself, and the town looks lived in rather than dressed. The early draft gave Gale and Dewey a baby, dropped because it was impractical to shoot, and the original ending was a cliffhanger; the hospital finale was added later, and reshoots in early 2011 added scenes with Aimée Teegarden and Alison Brie. Craven said that in his version of the world there had been no real-life Ghostface murders in the decade between the films, and you can feel that: Woodsboro has had fifteen years to turn its massacre into a memorial and a marketing hook.

The cast is well chosen for that. Hayden Panettiere's Kirby is quick, funny and plainly the person the audience would want to survive. Rory Culkin's Charlie is a fan who has studied every scene and still does not understand what he has signed up to. Mary McDonnell as Jill's mother, Kate, gives the film a grown-up's fear for her daughter that turns grimly ironic once you know the ending. And Courteney Cox's Gale, stuck and frustrated and trying to prove she can still find a story, is the closest the film comes to a portrait of what surviving a horror franchise does to a person.

The film is also funnier than the third one without trying as hard. The comedy comes from people who think they know how this works, which is the series' original joke, and Craven lets it sit right next to real fear rather than replacing it.

Where it falls down

The middle act is crowded and the adults suffer for it. Sidney spends much of it reacting rather than acting until the last twenty minutes, and Dewey and Gale's marriage is set up and then mostly parked. A lot of the teenagers exist to be suspects and then victims, and the film knows it, which does not make them more interesting. The film was the series' first major use of CGI, including a retractable knife blade, and the few digital effects date it more than anything else in it. The ending, in which the press crown the killer a hero, is bleaker than anything in the earlier sequels, and it is the right note to end Craven's career on. It earned about $97 million worldwide on a $40 million budget, the lowest-grossing entry, and the next film did not arrive until 2022.

It deserved better than the reception it got, and the films that followed borrowed more from it than they admit. Start with Scream (1996), and see where this one sits at the Scream movies in order. For the same Gen Z-meets-murder satire done a decade later without masks, Bodies Bodies Bodies.

The ending of Scream 4 explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: there are two killers, and the mastermind is Sidney's cousin, Jill Roberts. At Kirby's after-party, Charlie Walker, who had been posing as tied up, is revealed as one Ghostface and stabs Kirby. Jill is the other. She kills her ex-boyfriend Trevor to frame him, stabs Charlie to death so she will be the sole survivor, stabs Sidney, and injures herself to complete the frame. At the hospital she learns Sidney is alive and goes to finish her. Dewey and Gale work out that Jill is the killer because she mentioned a detail of Gale's attack that was never made public. Jill overpowers Dewey, Gale and Deputy Judy Hicks, but Sidney shocks her with a defibrillator and shoots her through the heart. Outside, the press call Jill a hero.

Who is the killer in Scream 4?

Two people: Jill Roberts, Sidney's cousin, played by Emma Roberts, and Charlie Walker, a horror-obsessed classmate played by Rory Culkin. Jill is the mastermind. Charlie believes he is her partner; she has planned all along to kill him.

What is Jill's motive in Scream 4?

Fame. Jill is jealous of the attention Sidney has had for surviving the earlier killings and wants the same notoriety as a pseudo-victim. Her plan is to stage a new massacre, pin it on Trevor and Charlie, and come out of it as the new survivor everyone talks about.

How does Jill get caught?

By saying too much. In the hospital, Jill refers to a detail of the attack on Gale that was not public knowledge. Dewey and Gale realise she could only know it if she was there, and they race to Sidney's room. Sidney then kills Jill with a defibrillator and a gunshot to the heart.

Does Kirby die in Scream 4?

The film leaves it open. Charlie stabs Kirby at her after-party and leaves her to bleed out, and the film moves on without confirming whether she lives. Scream VI (2023) later brings her back as an FBI agent and a survivor of the 2011 killings, which settles the question.

What does the last line of Scream 4 mean?

As Dewey calls for backup, reporters outside the hospital describe Jill as a hero straight out of the movies. Even dead, she gets what she wanted: the story is told her way, at least until the truth comes out. It is the film's joke about how fame works, delivered over the body of the person who wanted it.

If Scream 4 is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Scream 4 in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

More lists like these: Movies like Scream

Questions about Scream 4

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

What happens at the end of Scream 4?

Jill Roberts, Sidney's cousin, is revealed as the mastermind with Charlie Walker as her partner. She kills Charlie and her ex-boyfriend Trevor, stabs Sidney and herself, and tries to finish Sidney in hospital. Dewey and Gale catch her slip about Gale's attack, and Sidney kills her with a defibrillator and a gunshot to the heart.

Who is Ghostface in Scream 4?

Two people. Jill Roberts, Sidney's cousin, played by Emma Roberts, is the mastermind, and Charlie Walker, a horror-obsessed classmate played by Rory Culkin, is her accomplice. Jill kills Charlie near the end so that she can pose as the sole survivor of the massacre.

Why does Jill kill in Scream 4?

She is jealous of the fame Sidney gained from surviving the earlier killings and wants that notoriety for herself as a pseudo-victim. Her plan is to frame Trevor and Charlie, wound herself, and come out of a new massacre as the next Sidney Prescott.

Was Scream 4 Wes Craven's last film?

Yes. Scream 4 was the final film Wes Craven directed before his death in 2015. Kevin Williamson returned to write it, with rewrites by Ehren Kruger during production. The series continued with a television anthology and then the 2022 film Scream, made by a new directing team.

Does Kirby survive Scream 4?

The film does not say. Charlie stabs her at the after-party and leaves her to bleed out. Scream VI later brings Kirby back as an FBI agent and a survivor of the 2011 killings, so the series treats her as having lived.

How did Scream 4 do at the box office?

Poorly by the series' standards. It earned about $97 million worldwide on a $40 million budget, the lowest gross of the franchise, after a disappointing opening of $19.3 million. Later reappraisals have been kinder, praising how it anticipated social media and internet fame.

These are ranked against Scream 4, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy