VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

YOU'RENEXT F-2099 · 2011 · FILM

Film · 2011

You're Next

Adam Wingard

Masked killers crash a family dinner and pick the wrong guest to corner.

55Strong to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how much it shows

  • PaceJolts you often72
  • ThreatPeople, entirely96
  • GoreExplicit72
  • ToneGrim, with air62
  • RealityCould happen12

Era bias 78 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

Horror movies where the monster is a person →

Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, You're Next (2011) is most extreme on the threat axis: 96 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 95% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

You're Next is a 2011 American home-invasion slasher film directed by Adam Wingard and written by Simon Barrett. A wealthy family's dinner at their remote Missouri holiday home is attacked by killers in animal masks, and one guest turns out to be far better at survival than the people hunting her. We score it 096 on the threat axis and 012 on reality anchor.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is You're Next, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.

The threat at 096 is near the human end — 304 works score lower. Three hired killers and the family members who hired them, for money, with no supernatural element at all.

Viscera 072 is high — 222 works score lower. Crossbow bolts, a garrotte wire, machetes, an axe to the head, screwdrivers, a meat tenderiser and a blender, and the camera does not look away.

Tone 062 is on the gleeful side — 289 works score lower. The family dies horribly, but the film enjoys Erin's counterattacks and plays several kills, and the ending, as dark jokes.

Pace 072 is on the shock side, with 280 works slower. Once the first bolt comes through the window, the film rarely pauses.

Era bias 078 reads modern — 193 works score lower. Digital photography, a jammed mobile signal and emergency texts to 911, shot in a 2010s indie register.

Reality anchor 012 is grounded — 5 works score lower. Nothing in it breaks a physical rule; the killers are men in masks with weapons from a hardware shop.

On jump scares: several, mostly sudden attacks from behind or through windows, and some of them are played as punchlines.

Who should skip You're Next

You're Next on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what You're Next looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 72 Jolts you often
THE THREAT 96 People, entirely
VISCERA 72 Explicit
ERA BIAS 78 Modern
TONE 62 Grim, with air
REALITY ANCHOR 12 Could happen

Where that puts it: joint #1 human monsters · joint #5 grounded

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

You're Next: the review

You're Next is a home-invasion film that swaps the victim for a hunter halfway through, and it is a great deal of fun watching the killers realise it.

Adam Wingard and Simon Barrett set out to make a home-invasion film because, they said, those were the films that still frightened them. Then Barrett wrote one that borrows as much from Agatha Christie and from chamber-mystery comedy as it does from the slasher. It premiered in the Midnight Madness section at Toronto in 2011, Lionsgate bought it four days later, and then sat on it until August 2013. It was made for about a million dollars and shot in four weeks of overnight sessions in a mansion in Columbia, Missouri. Very little of that shows on screen.

A family dinner with crossbows

The setup is a gift. Paul and Aubrey Davison bring their grown children to their isolated holiday home: Crispian with his girlfriend Erin; Drake and his wife Kelly; Felix and his girlfriend Zee; and Aimee with her boyfriend Tariq. Before the main course the siblings are already at each other's throats, and the scene plays like a tense indie family drama, partly because several of the cast are indie filmmakers. Joe Swanberg is Drake, Ti West is Tariq, and Barbara Crampton is Aubrey. Some of the dinner dialogue was improvised from the filmmakers' own family experience, and it sounds like it.

Then a crossbow bolt comes through the window and into Tariq, and the film becomes a siege. Killers in lamb, tiger and fox masks are outside, the phones have been jammed, and Aimee, sprinting for help, runs straight into a garrotte wire that cuts her throat. It is a brutal, quick sequence, and the masks are a great design: blank, pale, slightly comic, like something from a children's party.

Erin

The film's real idea is Erin. Sharni Vinson plays her as calm in a way that slowly unsettles everyone else in the house, including the killers. While the Davisons panic, she is checking exits, fortifying the windows and setting nail traps. She grew up in a survivalist compound, she explains, where she learned to fight and to survive. By the middle of the film, the men in masks are being stalked by the guest they did not plan for, and Wingard plays each of her counterattacks for both shock and a laugh. A meat tenderiser, a screwdriver, a blender: the house becomes her arsenal.

Her fights are the film's set-pieces, and each one is staged as a problem to solve. Tiger attacks her, and she stabs his arm, breaks his kneecap and beats him to death. Lamb, enraged at finding his brother's body, gets a screwdriver in the back and later walks into one of her nail traps. Fox, who cannot be outrun on her injured leg, is lured into the basement. The killers are professionals, and the joke the film keeps telling is that they are less prepared than the girlfriend nobody at the table took seriously.

This is where the tone lands. It is bloody, with crossbows, machetes and an axe to the head, but it is also gleeful about it, because the film's sympathies are entirely with Erin and the film enjoys her competence. Total Film later put Erin at the top of its list of the fifty most bad-ass female horror leads, and it is easy to see why.

A film made by its own cast

There is a pleasing in-joke running under the whole thing. Simon Barrett, who wrote it, plays the tiger-masked killer. Larry Fessenden is Erik, the neighbour killed in the cold open with his girlfriend Talia, which is where the title comes from: "you're next", written in her blood on the window. Barbara Crampton plays the mother whose bedroom becomes the second message. Several of the cast are filmmakers themselves, and the ease between them gives the dinner scene its unforced, prickly realism.

It also explains why the film is so confident about genre. It knows exactly what a home-invasion film is supposed to do, which is make you feel helpless, and it sets that up carefully before taking it away. The killers have been living in the house before the family arrived; Paul finds their sleeping bags, food wrappers and bottles of urine in a closet. That one detail is properly frightening, and it is the moment the film's attention shifts from the masks to the motive.

The critical reception was warm. The film won the Syfy prize at Gérardmer in 2013, and critics praised its mix of gore and dark humour, though several found it unoriginal. Both are fair. What it adds to the formula is the reversal, and the reversal is enough to make it one of the better horror comedies of its decade without ever forgetting to be horror first.

Where it falls down

The twist is guessable for anyone who has watched a few murder mysteries, and the film reveals it at the midpoint anyway, which drains some suspense from the second half. Most of the family are thin sketches who exist to be killed or to be guilty. The music is often too insistent. And the coda, in which a police officer arrives at exactly the wrong moment, is a joke that plays well once and lands less well the more you think about it.

For a home-invasion film played completely straight and much bleaker, The Strangers; for a later film with the same rich-family-hunting-a-bride engine played for even bigger laughs, Ready or Not.

The ending of You're Next explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: the killers were hired by Felix and Zee, who wanted Paul and Aubrey's estate, and Crispian was in on it. Erin kills all three masked killers, then kills Felix with a blender to the head and Zee with a knife driven through the top of her skull. When Felix's phone rings, she answers in silence, and Crispian, thinking he is speaking to his brother, reveals that he planned the attack with them. He returns, says she was never meant to be a target, and offers her money to keep quiet. She stabs him in the neck and eye. A police officer arrives at that moment, sees her kill Crispian, shoots her in the shoulder, and walks through the front door into her axe trap.

Who hired the killers in You're Next?

Felix and his girlfriend Zee, along with his brother Crispian. They hired three assassins to murder the family at the dinner so the surviving brothers could inherit their parents' wealth. Felix and Zee watch impassively as their father is killed, and Felix scolds the fox-masked killer for doing it in front of him. Crispian's part is only revealed in the last minutes.

Was Crispian in on it?

Yes. He leaves the house early, saying he will go for help, and never returns. After Erin kills Felix she answers Felix's ringing phone, and Crispian, believing he is talking to his brother, reveals he is part of the plan. When he comes back he tells Erin she was never meant to be a target and tries to buy her silence. Appalled, she kills him.

Why is Erin so good at surviving?

She grew up in a survivalist compound, where she learned combat and survival skills. She tells Zee about it while setting nail traps around the house, not realising Zee is one of the conspirators. It is why she checks the exits, barricades the house and fights back with whatever is to hand, and why the killers' plan falls apart when she was the one guest they did not account for.

What happens at the very end of You're Next?

A police officer arrives just as Erin stabs Crispian, sees what looks like murder, and shoots her in the shoulder. Erin warns him not to come in, but he enters through the front door and is killed by the axe she rigged above it earlier to catch the fox-masked killer. The film ends on that last, bleakly comic death.

If You're Next is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to You're Next in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

More lists like these: Movies like Scream

Questions about You're Next

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

What happens at the end of You're Next?

Erin kills the three masked killers, then Felix and Zee. Answering Felix's phone, she learns Crispian was in on the plan. When he returns and offers her money, she kills him. A police officer arrives, sees the killing, shoots Erin in the shoulder, and is then killed by the axe trap she rigged above the front door.

Who are the killers in You're Next?

Three assassins in lamb, tiger and fox masks, hired by Felix Davison and his girlfriend Zee, with Crispian also part of the plot. Lamb and Tiger are brothers. The family members arranged the attack so they could inherit their parents' estate.

Why did they want the family dead in You're Next?

For money. Felix, Zee and Crispian planned the attack on the family dinner so the brothers would inherit their wealthy parents' estate. Crispian tells Erin afterwards that she was never supposed to be a target, and tries to bribe her into silence, which is a mistake.

Where was You're Next filmed?

In a mansion in Columbia, Missouri, which stands in for the Davisons' rural Missouri holiday home. Shooting took four weeks and ran mostly overnight, from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. The budget was about a million dollars.

Why was You're Next released two years after it premiered?

It premiered in the Midnight Madness section of the Toronto International Film Festival in 2011, and Lionsgate bought it four days later for $2 million. The theatrical release did not come until 23 August 2013, when it went on to gross about $26.9 million worldwide.

Is You're Next a horror comedy?

It is a home-invasion slasher with a strong vein of dark humour. Critics praised its mix of gore and comedy, and Simon Barrett drew on Agatha Christie mysteries and screwball chamber comedy as well as slashers. We score it 062 on tone, on the gleeful side of the index.

These are ranked against You're Next, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy