VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Television

PENNYDREADFUL T-0406 · 2014 · TV

Television · 2014

Penny Dreadful

John Logan

Frankenstein, Dorian Gray and Dracula written as though each owned the only book.

67Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PaceBuilds, then strikes40
  • ThreatHuman and not38
  • GoreExplicit68
  • ToneBleak22
  • RealityTilts unreal58

Era bias 82 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

The bleakest horror television ever made →

Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Penny Dreadful (2014) is most extreme on the tone axis: 22 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 47% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Penny Dreadful is a television series that ran for three seasons from 2014, created by John Logan. Victorian London, and the characters from its horror fiction treated as people who happen to live there: Frankenstein and his creature, Dorian Gray, Dracula, and at the centre a woman called Vanessa Ives whom something has wanted since she was a girl. We score it 068 on viscera and 022 on tone.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Penny Dreadful, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.

Tone 022 is the signature. 149 works score lower. Nearly everybody is damaged beyond repair, the protagonist is killed by the man who loves her at her own request, and the series' recurring position is that being extraordinary is a wound.

Viscera 068 is higher than its literary reputation suggests. 209 works score lower. Showtime in 2014: dismemberment, a flaying, surgery, childbirth, vampire feeding in detail and one scene in a theatre involving a pelt.

Threat 038 leans supernatural. 163 works score higher. Witches, vampires, a creature, the devil — and the series' most distressing hour is an asylum run by human beings.

Era bias 082 is modern. 102 works score higher. This is a 2014 prestige production photographing 1891, and nothing about the image pretends otherwise.

Pace 040 is just on the dread side. 201 works are faster. Long séances, longer monologues, and violence that arrives suddenly and rarely.

Reality anchor 058 is a shade surreal. Most of the series is solid Victorian London, with episodes — the doll's house, the possession, the desert — that leave it entirely.

On jump scares: few. The series prefers a long scene of somebody's face changing.

Who should skip Penny Dreadful

Penny Dreadful on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Penny Dreadful looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 40 Builds, then strikes
THE THREAT 38 Human and not
VISCERA 68 Explicit
ERA BIAS 82 Modern
TONE 22 Bleak
REALITY ANCHOR 58 Tilts unreal

Where that puts it: #4 goriest · joint #5 surreal

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Penny Dreadful: the review

A crossover that takes its sources seriously

The premise invites disaster. Put Victor Frankenstein, Dorian Gray, Mina Harker and Dr Jekyll in one city and you have a trailer, not a series. What saves it is that Logan writes each of them as though their own novel were the only one that mattered: Frankenstein is a vain, frightened young man who cannot clean up after himself; the creature is a literate, wounded, genuinely frightening presence who wants to be loved and will do harm about it; Dorian is bored in the specific way of someone who has had two hundred years to become bored.

And the series is a period piece that means it. Gaslight, séances, a theatre in Grand Guignol, the Explorers' Club, consumption, laudanum, and an attitude to women's bodies that the writing treats as the actual horror — Vanessa's time in an asylum is the series' most upsetting material and has no monster in it at all.

Eva Green

The series is hers and it would be nothing without her. Vanessa Ives is written as a woman under siege by something theological and played as somebody who is frequently furious about it, which is a much better choice than victimhood. Green does things with her face in the possession scenes that nobody else on television was attempting, and she carries two episodes almost alone — the séance in the first season and "The Nightcomers" in the second — that are the high points of the whole run.

Timothy Dalton is magnificent as a Victorian explorer whose courage is indistinguishable from his selfishness, and Rory Kinnear's creature is the best screen Frankenstein's monster since Karloff.

The shape of it

Season one is a haunted-house story in the form of a search for a missing woman. Season two is the best of the three: a witch coven, a wax museum, a doll's house, and Helen McCrory giving the series its finest villain. Season three loses its nerve — it splits the cast across two continents, introduces an American western subplot nobody wanted, brings in Dracula as a zoologist, and then ends abruptly because Logan decided it should.

Where it strains

The third season is a real problem, not a soft landing: strands are abandoned, Dorian's whole arc evaporates, and the finale is less a conclusion than a decision. The dialogue is florid throughout and some of the monologues are indulgent even by the standards of a show built on them. And a series this committed to Victorian pastiche inevitably spends time on things that have been done better by the books it is quoting.

What it earned is a register nothing else has managed: genuinely literate gothic television that is also frequently disgusting.

The ending of Penny Dreadful explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: Vanessa gives in to Dracula, accepting the darkness she has fought for three seasons, and London falls under a permanent fog and plague. Ethan reaches her, and at her request — she is lucid, and she asks him — he shoots her. Her death breaks Dracula's hold, the fog lifts, and the series ends at her graveside with the surviving characters scattered. There is no fourth season and this was always intended as the end.

Here is how the series gets there.

What is Vanessa Ives?

The chosen vessel of a conflict older than the series explains. Both Lucifer and Dracula — presented as brothers — want her, the first for her soul and the second for her body, and her life has been a sequence of attempts to claim her. The series is deliberately inconsistent about the cosmology and consistent about her refusal.

What happens in season three?

Vanessa, abandoned by her friends, is drawn to Dr Sweet, a zoologist at the natural history museum who is Dracula. Ethan is taken back to America by his father, which occupies a great deal of the season to little purpose. Frankenstein and Jekyll work on a cure for Lily. Vanessa eventually accepts Dracula, and London is enveloped.

Why does Ethan kill Vanessa?

Because she asks him to, with full understanding of what she is asking. Her acceptance of Dracula has brought the plague and the fog, and her death is the only thing that ends it. The series stages it as a mercy and as a love scene, and Josh Hartnett plays it as a man doing the worst thing he will ever do.

Was the series cancelled?

No. John Logan decided the story was complete and the third season was written as the last, though it was not announced as such until the finale aired. That is why several strands simply stop: he ended the series he was telling and left the rest.

Is season three worth watching?

Yes, with managed expectations. It contains Vanessa's best material and the series' most affecting ending, alongside its worst subplot. Anybody who stops after season two will have seen the best of it and will have missed the point of it.

If Penny Dreadful is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Penny Dreadful in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

Questions about Penny Dreadful

The things people actually ask about this series, answered — including how it ends.

How does Penny Dreadful end?

Vanessa accepts Dracula, which brings a permanent fog and plague over London. Ethan reaches her and, at her clear-headed request, shoots her. Her death breaks Dracula's hold and lifts the fog, and the series closes at her grave with the survivors dispersed.

Was Penny Dreadful cancelled?

No. John Logan wrote the third season as the conclusion and did not announce it until the finale aired, which is why several storylines — Dorian's in particular — simply stop rather than resolve.

What is Vanessa Ives?

The contested vessel in a conflict between Lucifer and Dracula, presented as brothers, one wanting her soul and the other her body. The series is deliberately vague about the theology and entirely clear about her refusal to submit to it.

Is Penny Dreadful gory?

Considerably. We score it 068 on viscera, higher than 209 of the 320 works in this index, with dismemberment, surgery, a flaying and detailed vampire feeding across three seasons.

Do I need to have read the novels?

No, though it rewards it. The series uses Frankenstein, Dracula and Dorian Gray as people rather than as references, and we hold Dracula and Frankenstein with their own scores.

What should I watch after Penny Dreadful?

Interview with the Vampire for the other great literary adaptation on television, Dracula for the source it treats most seriously, and gothic horror for everything in this index in that mode.

These are ranked against Penny Dreadful, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy