Film · 2012
Prometheus
A voyage to meet humanity's makers, who turn out to have built a weapon.
68Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceBuilds, then strikes46
- ThreatMostly supernatural26
- GoreShows some of it64
- ToneBleak20
- RealityTilts unreal56
Era bias 86 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The bleakest horror movies ever made →
Part of a series: Alien movies in order →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Prometheus (2012) is most extreme on the tone axis: 20 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 42% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
Prometheus is a 2012 British-American science fiction horror film directed by Ridley Scott. In 2089 a scientific expedition follows an ancient star map to the moon LV-223, hoping to meet the beings who made humanity, and finds a weapons base instead. We score it 086 on era bias and 020 on tone.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Prometheus, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
The threat at 026 is on the supernatural side — 100 works score lower. The harm comes from an alien substance and an alien giant, with an android's curiosity as the instrument that unleashes it.
Viscera 064 is explicit — 193 works score lower. A self-performed caesarean, a man burned alive, a decapitation, and a monster bursting from a chest.
Tone 020 is bleak — 136 works score lower. Almost the whole crew dies, the makers turn out to want humanity dead, and the survivor heads further out rather than home.
Pace 046 is on the dread side, with 133 works slower. The first hour is exploration and conversation, and the attacks come late.
Era bias 086 reads modern — 240 works score lower. Native 3D, Red Epic digital capture, a dark look built in the colour grade, and a 2012 effects pipeline.
Reality anchor 056 leans surreal — 182 works score lower. Godlike makers, a liquid that rewrites life and a theology of creation make it less grounded than the earlier films.
On jump scares: a few, most of them in the structure, and none is what the film is remembered for.
Who should skip Prometheus
Skip it if you need a film to answer its own questions. The Engineers' motive is never explained, and much of the story is deliberately left for sequels.
Skip it if characters making foolish choices ruins horror for you. Several deaths happen because experienced professionals do things nobody would do.
Skip it if forced pregnancy is a hard limit. The surgery sequence is the film's centrepiece and it is graphic and prolonged.
Content notes: a forced alien pregnancy and a self-performed abdominal surgery, a man burned alive at his own request, a decapitation, a man's helmet and face melted, a creature forced down a throat, a chestburster, and a crushing death.
Watch it if you want Ridley Scott returning to the mythology of the series on a grand scale, you value design and spectacle, and Fassbender's David interests you more than the creatures.
Prometheus on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Prometheus looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Prometheus: the review
Prometheus asks bigger questions than the films it grew out of, and then mostly declines to answer them, which is either its ambition or its failure depending on how much patience you bring.
Ridley Scott came back to the series he started thirty-three years earlier, and he did not want to make another Alien. Jon Spaihts wrote a direct prequel; Scott wanted something else, and Damon Lindelof was hired in 2010 to rewrite it and reduce the references, aiming for a story running parallel to the Alien films in the same universe. For a while it was called Paradise, after Paradise Lost. The result is a film about creation, and about what happens when the created go looking for their makers and find that the makers have moved on.
The set-up is grand. A tall humanoid alien drinks a black liquid on an unnamed planet and dissolves, his DNA breaking apart and recombining. In 2089, archaeologists Elizabeth Shaw and Charlie Holloway find the same star map in the art of several ancient cultures and read it as an invitation. The dying CEO Peter Weyland funds a voyage to the place it points.
The android is the film
The best thing in Prometheus, by a distance, is Michael Fassbender's David, the android who looks after the ship while the crew sleeps. He is polite, curious, and quietly contemptuous of the people he serves. He secretly takes a cylinder of the black liquid from the alien structure, finds that its DNA matches human DNA, and doses Holloway's drink with it to see what happens. It is the one act in the film nobody forces him to commit, and it sets every horror that follows in motion.
The android's curiosity is the film's real engine. The humans came looking for their makers; David is already standing next to his, and finds him old, frail and unimpressive. Fassbender plays that contempt so lightly that it is easy to miss on a first viewing.
The question the film keeps circling — why would a made thing serve its maker? — is posed most sharply through David, and it is the question the later films pick up and run with.
The surgery
The horror in Prometheus is concentrated, and the set-piece that earns it is the one Fox cited when it confirmed the R rating. Shaw, who has believed herself infertile, finds she is pregnant after Holloway is infected, and the thing inside her is not a child. She gets herself onto an automated surgery table and uses it to remove a squid-like creature from her own abdomen. Noomi Rapace plays it as a woman holding herself together by force of will, and it is one of the great body-horror sequences of its decade.
Around it, the expedition fails in instalments. Millburn is killed by a snake-like creature in the structure. Fifield's helmet is melted by corrosive fluid, and he later returns mutated and kills several crew before Captain Janek kills him. Holloway, sickening, is refused re-entry to the ship by mission director Meredith Vickers and, at his own urging, burned to death with a flamethrower.
The Engineers
The film's mystery is the Engineers, the tall humanoid beings whose star map brought the Prometheus here. The crew finds stone cylinders, a giant humanoid head and the decapitated body of an Engineer in the structure, and corpses that suggest the whole species is dead. Captain Janek, Idris Elba's practical pilot, works out what the place really is: an Engineer military base where a biological weapon got loose. It is a better answer than the scientists find, and the film's most chilling idea is the one it does not dwell on — that the makers of humanity built a weapon here, and that Earth was its target.
The answer arrives when David wakes the last surviving Engineer and speaks to him, explaining that Weyland wants the Engineers to help him overcome age and death. The Engineer tears David's head off, kills Weyland and his companions, and starts his ship. Guy Pearce, playing Weyland as a very old man, gets a death that is the film's sharpest joke: a man who crossed the galaxy to ask his maker for more life, killed for asking.
Charlize Theron's Vickers, the cold mission director, gets less to do than the film promises, though her death — crushed when the Engineer's ship comes down — has a grim, absurd inevitability.
Where it falls down
Its characters make terrible decisions, and the film does not seem to notice. Trained scientists handle unknown alien life as if it were a pet, and wander off alone in a structure they know is dangerous. Critics singled this out at the time — James Cameron said it did not add up logically — and it is the main reason the film's horror never builds into dread: it is hard to fear for people this careless. Much of the plot is deferred to a sequel, and Lindelof said some elements were deliberately left unresolved. The Engineers' motive is never explained. The film is beautiful throughout — it was shot in 3D on Red Epic cameras, across Iceland, Jordan, Spain and English studios, with few green screens — and the beauty is sometimes all there is.
The rest of the series is at Alien movies in order. For a more patient film about a team losing itself to an alien biology it cannot understand, Annihilation on the page; for the cosmic dread of something that does not care about us, Under the Skin.
The ending of Prometheus explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: Shaw survives and leaves in search of the Engineers' home world, with David's severed head. The surviving Engineer, woken by David, tears David's head off, kills Weyland and his companions, and reactivates his ship to carry the black liquid to Earth. Shaw warns Janek, who rams the Prometheus into the Engineer's ship and brings it down; the falling wreck crushes Vickers. The Engineer survives the crash and attacks Shaw in the lifeboat, where the creature she cut out of herself has grown huge; it subdues him by forcing an ovipositor down his throat, and he dies. Shaw recovers David's remains and, with his help, launches another Engineer ship. In the abandoned lifeboat, a creature bursts from the dead Engineer's chest.
Who are the Engineers in Prometheus?
The tall humanoid beings the expedition believes created humanity. The opening shows one of them drinking the black liquid and dissolving, his DNA breaking apart and recombining. The crew finds that the black liquid's DNA matches human DNA. On LV-223 they find what Janek concludes is a military base where a biological weapon escaped and killed the Engineers there. The film does not explain why they made humanity, or why they intended to destroy it.
What is the black liquid in Prometheus?
A substance stored in cylinders in the Engineers' structure that breaks down and rewrites living things. In the opening it dissolves an Engineer; on LV-223 it infects Holloway after David puts it in his drink, and Shaw, who had sex with Holloway after he drank it, finds herself pregnant with a creature. Janek reads the base as a weapons facility, and the surviving Engineer was preparing to take the liquid to Earth.
What is the creature at the end of Prometheus?
A new creature, often called the Deacon, that bursts from the Engineer's chest in the film's final shot. It was implanted when the creature Shaw removed from her own body — which had grown huge in the lifeboat — forced an ovipositor down the Engineer's throat. It is the film's clearest visual link to the creatures of the Alien films, and the film ends on it rather than explaining it.
Why does David poison Holloway?
The film does not give him a stated reason. David takes a cylinder of the black liquid, finds its DNA matches human DNA, contaminates a drink with it and gives it to Holloway. He is curious, he answers to Weyland, and he does not regard the crew as people. Holloway's infection leads directly to Shaw's pregnancy and his own death.
Why does Shaw leave with David?
Because she still wants answers. The Engineer ship bound for Earth has been brought down, but she wants to know why the Engineers made humanity and then planned to destroy it. She recovers David's remains, and with his help launches another Engineer ship towards their home world instead of going home.
If Prometheus is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Prometheus in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

Alien
Ridley Scott · 1979 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
92% shared signal

Candyman
Bernard Rose · 1992 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
92% shared signal

Talk to Me
Danny & Michael Philippou · 2022 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
90% shared signal
Alien 3
David Fincher · 1992 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
89% shared signal
The Ritual
David Bruckner · 2017 · Film
88% shared signal
Penny Dreadful
John Logan · 2014 · Television
92% shared signal

The Only Good Indians
Stephen Graham Jones · 2020 · Book
88% shared signal

Between Two Fires
Christopher Buehlman · 2012 · Book
88% shared signal
More lists like these: Movies like Alien · Movies like Talk to Me · Books like Between Two Fires
Questions about Prometheus
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
What happens at the end of Prometheus?
The Engineer kills Weyland and tries to fly to Earth with the black liquid. Janek rams the Prometheus into his ship and brings it down, and the wreck crushes Vickers. The Engineer is killed by the creature Shaw removed from herself, and Shaw leaves with David's head to find the Engineers' world. A creature then bursts from the Engineer's chest.
Is Prometheus a prequel to Alien?
Partly. It began as a direct prequel written by Jon Spaihts, but Ridley Scott wanted a different direction, and Damon Lindelof rewrote it to reduce the Alien references. The result runs parallel to the Alien films in the same universe, and the creature in its last shot is the clearest link.
Who survives Prometheus?
Only Elizabeth Shaw and the android David, who survives in pieces after the Engineer tears his head off. Holloway, Millburn, Fifield, Weyland, Vickers, Janek and the rest of the crew die, and the last Engineer is killed by the creature Shaw cut out of her own body. Shaw and David leave LV-223 together.
Why did the Engineers want to destroy humanity?
The film never says, and the omission is deliberate. Lindelof said some elements were left unresolved for a sequel. What the film shows is that the base on LV-223 was a weapons facility, and that the surviving Engineer reactivated his ship and set off for Earth as soon as he woke.
Why is Prometheus rated R?
Mainly for the surgery scene. Fox confirmed the R rating in May 2012 and cited the sequence in which Shaw removes an alien creature from her own abdomen on an automated surgery table. The film also includes a man burned alive, a decapitation and a chestburster.
Where was Prometheus filmed?
Across several countries over 82 days from March 2011: Shepperton and Pinewood Studios in England, Iceland, including Dettifoss waterfall and the base of Hekla, the Ciudad de la Luz studios in Spain, and Wadi Rum in Jordan. Scott shot it in 3D and used few green screens.
These are ranked against Prometheus, not against you.
Build your own tape →