VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

UNDERTHE SKIN F-1302 · 2013 · FILM

Film · 2013

Under the Skin

Jonathan Glazer

A woman drives a van around Glasgow looking for men nobody will miss.

62Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PacePure slow burn10
  • ThreatMostly supernatural34
  • GoreShows some of it48
  • ToneNo relief at all8
  • RealityDream logic74

Era bias 76 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

The bleakest horror movies ever made →

Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Under the Skin (2013) is most extreme on the tone axis: 8 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 7% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Under the Skin is a 2013 horror film directed by Jonathan Glazer, from Michel Faber's novel. A woman drives a van around Glasgow picking up men who will not be missed and leading them somewhere they do not come back from. We score it 010 on pace and 074 on reality anchor: almost nothing here moves more slowly, and very little of it is less willing to explain itself. It frightens by refusing to account for anything it shows.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Under the Skin, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.

Pace 010 is near the floor of the index. 308 works are faster. Long silent takes, a van on a road, a woman watching a shopping precinct. The film has perhaps four events in a hundred and eight minutes.

Reality anchor 074 is a long way toward surreal, and the split is the method. 49 works score higher. Real Glasgow streets with real passers-by, cut against a room with no floor and no stated rules. Neither half explains the other.

Tone 008 is near the floor. 22 works score lower. There is no survivor, no reckoning and no rescue, and the one act of mercy in it achieves nothing at all.

Viscera 048 is moderate and strange. The harvest is explicit without being bloody — a body collapsing into an empty skin is the most graphic image in the film and there is almost nothing in it you would call gore.

The threat at 034 is mostly inhuman, and it changes hands. The predator for ninety minutes is not human. The thing that kills her is a man with a petrol can, which is the whole point of the last act.

Era bias 076 is modern. Flat digital Glasgow, hidden cameras, no stylisation. The film looks like 2013 because it was partly filmed by accident.

On jump scares: none. The score does all of it.

Who should skip Under the Skin

Under the Skin on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Under the Skin looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 10 Pure slow burn
THE THREAT 34 Mostly supernatural
VISCERA 48 Shows some of it
ERA BIAS 76 Modern
TONE 8 No relief at all
REALITY ANCHOR 74 Dream logic

Where that puts it: #3 slow burn · joint #9 bleakest

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Under the Skin: the review

Half of this film is documentary

Glazer shot much of the street material with hidden cameras and real passers-by: men approached in a van by Scarlett Johansson who did not know they were in a film, shoppers in a Glasgow precinct, a nightclub, a bus. The release forms came afterwards. What that produces is unlike anything else in the genre — a predator moving through genuinely unstaged reality, with ordinary people reacting at ordinary volume, and the audience in the position of knowing something nobody on screen does.

Daniel Landin photographs the city flat and grey and wet. There is no horror grammar anywhere in it. Then the film cuts to the black room, which has no floor, no walls, no light source and no physics, and the two kinds of image are left to sit beside each other without a transition that would reconcile them.

Mica Levi's score is doing half the work

The score, which this index holds as a record in its own right, is the element that tells you the film is horror. Levi wrote it on viola with the pitch bent until the instrument sounds like something trying to be a voice and failing, and it is used exactly twice as often as it should be: present in the hunt, absent in the city. A great deal of what people remember as frightening in this film is a sound.

Johansson is doing something very difficult

The performance is almost entirely withheld. She is a surface that watches, mimics and learns, and for the first hour there is nothing behind the eyes that the film will confirm. What makes it a performance rather than a blank is the accumulation of small, specific failures — she eats cake and cannot swallow it, she looks at her own face in a mirror for a long time, she tries to find out what sex is and stops partway because there is no information in it for her.

The turn comes with Adam Pearson, whose character has neurofibromatosis and who is written and played as a man rather than as a lesson. He is the first person she meets who is also outside the ordinary traffic of being looked at, and the scene between them in the van is the best in the film. She lets him go. It does not save him, and it ends her.

Where it strains

It is genuinely difficult and some of the difficulty is unearned. The motorcyclist is a plot function with no interiority at all and the film's logistics — who these creatures are, what the harvest is for, who is in charge — are withheld past the point of productive mystery into something closer to indifference. Faber's novel answers all of it and is a much more conventional object for doing so, and some viewers will reasonably prefer that.

The beach sequence, with a drowning couple and a baby left on the shingle, is the hardest thing in the film and is also the one moment where Glazer's refusal to comment reads as a dare rather than a choice.

Watch it for the hidden-camera material, the score, the black room and the last ten minutes. Do not watch it expecting a plot.

The ending of Under the Skin explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: she abandons the work. After letting one man go she drives out of the city, is taken in by a kind man she meets on a bus, attempts sex with him and stops because there is nothing there for her to do, and walks into a forest. She shelters in a bothy, where a logger who passed her earlier finds her and assaults her; her skin tears, and what stands up out of it is a black figure that picks up her own face and looks at it. The logger comes back with a can of petrol and burns her. The final image is smoke rising into falling snow.

Here is what each piece of that is.

What is the black room?

A harvesting space with no stated physics. Men follow her in, undressing as they walk, and sink through a surface that she walks on. One of them, submerged, finds another man still alive and floating, and then that man's body collapses — everything inside it is drawn away through a red channel and what is left is an empty skin, hanging in the dark. The film never says what the material is for, who collects it, or what she is.

Why does she let the disfigured man go?

Because he is the first person she meets who is outside the economy she has been exploiting. Every man before him gets into the van because a woman who looks like that has spoken to him; this one cannot believe it is happening. The scene is the first in which she is looked at as a person rather than a prospect, and something in her registers it. The motorcyclist recovers him, so the mercy achieves nothing except her own defection.

What is she?

Not a woman, and the film will not say more. The skin is a worn surface — the opening sequence shows one being assembled, and a dead predecessor is undressed and her clothes reused — and what is underneath, seen once at the end, is a black human-shaped form with no features. Faber's novel makes her a surgically altered alien farming men for meat. Glazer cuts all of that and the film is better and colder for it.

What does the ending mean?

That the only thing in this film capable of killing her is an ordinary man. She survives the harvest, the city and her own defection, and she is finished by a logger with a grudge and a petrol can — the same violence she had been performing, done to her, without the room and without the ceremony. Having begun to be a person is what makes her killable.

What is the snow at the end?

Ash and smoke rising into falling snow, which the film holds for a long time without commentary. It is the only moment in the picture when the two visual registers — the documentary city and the featureless void — are the same image.

Is the baby on the beach ever resolved?

No. A couple drown trying to reach each other, she takes the man she came for and walks past their child, and the film cuts away and does not return. It is the clearest statement of what she is at that point in the story and it is deliberately unbearable, which is why it is the scene most people name when they say they could not finish it.

If Under the Skin is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Under the Skin in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

Under the Skin in another form

The index links works across media, so an adaptation sits beside its source and a score beside the film it haunts.

Questions about Under the Skin

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

How does Under the Skin end?

She abandons the hunt, is taken in by a kind man, flees into a forest and is assaulted by a logger. Her skin tears and a featureless black figure stands up out of it, holding her own face. The logger returns with petrol and burns her, and the film ends on smoke rising into falling snow.

What is the black room in Under the Skin?

A harvesting space with no stated physics. Men undress and sink through a surface she walks on; one, still alive underwater, watches another body collapse as everything inside it is drawn away, leaving an empty skin. The film never says what the material is for or who receives it.

What is the woman in Under the Skin?

Not human, and the film declines to say more. The skin is worn — the opening shows one being assembled and a dead predecessor being undressed — and what is underneath is a featureless black form seen once, at the end. The novel makes her a surgically altered alien; the film removes all of that.

Why does she let the man with the disfigured face go?

Because he is the first person who looks at her as a person rather than a prospect, and the first she meets who is also outside the economy she has been using. The motorcyclist recaptures him, so the mercy saves nobody and only marks the point where she stops working.

What does the ending of Under the Skin mean?

That the only thing capable of killing her is an ordinary man. She survives the harvest and her own defection and is finished by a logger with a petrol can — her own violence done back to her without the room or the ceremony. Becoming something like a person is what makes her killable.

Is Under the Skin a horror film or science fiction?

Both, and we score it as horror because of how it works rather than what is in it. 010 on pace, 008 on tone and no jump scares at all: the method is dread, withheld information and a score built to sound like something failing to be a voice. We hold that score separately.

What should I watch after Under the Skin?

Possession for the other great film about a body that is not what it looks like, Skinamarink for the same refusal to explain, and surreal horror for everything here that behaves like this.

These are ranked against Under the Skin, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy