Film · 2024
Late Night with the Devil
C. & C. Cairnes
Halloween 1977, a talk show losing to Carson, and a host who will put anything on live television.
77Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceBuilds, then strikes58
- ThreatHuman and not48
- GoreExplicit74
- ToneNo relief at all14
- RealityTilts unreal58
Era bias 66 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The bleakest horror movies ever made →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Late Night with the Devil (2024) is most extreme on the tone axis: 14 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 26% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
Late Night with the Devil is a 2024 horror film written and directed by Colin and Cameron Cairnes. It presents itself as the recovered master tape of a live Halloween 1977 talk show, plus the black-and-white footage shot between segments. We score it 066 on era bias, low for its year and the reason the film works, and 074 on viscera. It is the best thing anybody has done with the broadcast-horror idea since Ghostwatch.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Late Night with the Devil, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.
Era bias 066 is low for 2024 and it is the film's whole method. 165 works score higher. 4:3, interlaced video, period lenses, a studio band, black-and-white 16mm between segments. The image is doing 1977 rather than quoting it, and we score the texture a work actually has.
Viscera 074 is high. 75 works score higher. Black vomit, a death on air, an audience clawing at itself, a staking, and a final sequence of sustained bodily wrongness.
Tone 014 is bleak. 84 works score lower. The host's wife was the price, the one responsible person in the room is killed for a ratings decision, and the tape ends without anybody being told what happened.
The threat at 048 sits almost exactly on the midpoint, which is the design. There is a demon in this film and it is not the reason anything happens. The author of every event on the tape is a man who wanted better numbers.
Pace 058 is past the midpoint. 127 works are faster. A live broadcast has a clock and the film uses it: segments, breaks, and an escalation that cannot pause because the show is on.
Reality anchor 058 is a shade surreal. A completely convincing 1977 studio, and then an entity and a last act that leaves the building entirely.
On jump scares: a few, and the frightening thing is an audience reacting to something the camera has not cut to yet.
Who should skip Late Night with the Devil
Skip it if the format switch will spoil it. The last five minutes leave the broadcast conceit behind for a surreal sequence, and a viewer who came for the discipline will feel it go.
Skip it if generated imagery is a dealbreaker. The interstitial art between segments was machine-made and it is a visible blemish on a film otherwise built from period craft.
Skip it if possession of a child is a line. Lilly is a minor and the film's central spectacle is what is inside her being put on television by adults for ratings.
Content notes: the exploitation of a child on live television, a death by supernatural cause on air, suicide referenced, mass self-harm under hypnosis, a spouse's death traded for career advancement, and terminal illness.
Watch it if you want the best broadcast-horror film since Ghostwatch, a lead performance built out of professional hunger, and ninety minutes that understand what a live television grammar can do to a scare.
Late Night with the Devil on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Late Night with the Devil looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Late Night with the Devil: the review
The format is the whole achievement
The conceit is exact. 4:3, interlaced video, a studio band, a desk, a guest couch, an audience with an applause sign, and commercial breaks that cut to black-and-white 16mm of what happened while the tape was off. The Cairnes brothers do not use the format as a gimmick and then abandon it; every scare in the film has to arrive through a 1977 television grammar, which means no close-ups the cameras of that era would not have got, no coverage from angles that did not exist, and no sound design a live mix could not produce.
That constraint does something a conventional film could not. When something goes wrong on this show, it goes wrong on television, with a director cutting between three cameras and finding the wrong one, and an audience in the room reacting audibly. The scares are communal in a way almost nothing in modern horror manages.
David Dastmalchian is remarkable
Jack Delroy is a man doing a job he is losing. Dastmalchian plays the whole film in two registers at once: the on-air voice — warm, professional, slightly too hungry — and the thing underneath it, which is visible only in the black-and-white segments and in the half-second before a camera cuts to him. The performance is built on the specific awfulness of a host who must keep the show moving through events that would stop any sane person.
The best choice he makes is that Jack is not a sceptic and not a believer. He is a man who needs the numbers, and the film's horror follows directly from that: everything that happens is something he allowed on air because it would rate.
The supporting cast understands the assignment
Ian Bliss's Carmichael Haig is a professional debunker written with real teeth — he is right about almost everything and insufferable about all of it, and his hypnosis set piece is the best-staged sequence in the film. Laura Gordon's parapsychologist is the only person in the studio behaving responsibly and is steadily overruled. Ingrid Torelli's Lilly is extraordinary and the direction is the reason: she is kept mostly in wide shots, mostly smiling at the wrong camera, and the film lets the audience notice her rather than pointing.
Where it strains
The last five minutes abandon the format, and whether that is a flaw or the point is the central argument about this film. Having spent eighty minutes inside a 1977 broadcast, the climax moves into a surreal register with imagery no camera in the studio could have captured, and the discipline that made everything before it work is simply dropped.
My own view: it is a real cost and the film survives it, because the material it moves into is the only way to show what Jack actually did. But a viewer who came for the format will feel the switch, and the complaint is legitimate rather than a failure to keep up.
The other strain is the generated interstitial art, which is a small amount of screen time and a genuine blemish on a film otherwise built out of period craft.
Watch it for the format, for Dastmalchian, and for the hypnosis sequence.
The ending of Late Night with the Devil explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: Jack provokes a live demonstration and loses control of the studio. Lilly manifests the entity, June is killed, the audience comes apart, and Jack ends the broadcast holding a stake, having been walked through a vision of the Grove — the men's retreat where he offered his wife Madeleine in exchange for success. In the final sequence he stabs what he believes is the entity and finds he has killed Madeleine, on live television, while Lilly watches. The tape ends there. What the film is saying is that nothing in the studio that night was the cause of anything: the bill came due, and Jack had signed it years earlier.
Here is how the pieces fit.
What did Jack do at the Grove?
The Grove is a secretive men's club meeting in the redwoods, which Jack joined on his way up, and the black-and-white footage establishes that he participated in a ritual there. The film does not stage the bargain as a scene with terms read aloud. What it shows is a man who wanted the chair badly, a ceremony he took part in, and a wife who died of cancer shortly before his ratings peaked. The ending states the exchange plainly enough: he was given the career and Madeleine was the price.
Who or what is Mr Wriggles?
The entity attached to Lilly, surviving from Abraxas, the church June wrote her book about. The film gives it a child's name because Lilly named it, which is a good deal more unpleasant than a formal demonology would have been. It is never explained, never bargained with on screen, and its only interest in the broadcast is the audience.
What happens to June?
She is the one person in the studio trying to stop the demonstration, and she is overruled by Jack and goaded by Haig until it happens anyway. She does not survive the manifestation. The film is pointed about it: the responsible adult is killed by a decision two men made for ratings.
Was Haig's hypnosis real?
The film leaves it open and the ambiguity is deliberate. Haig puts the studio audience under and tells them they are full of worms, and what the cameras record is a room of people clawing at themselves. Either he genuinely did it, in which case his scepticism is a performance over a real ability, or the entity used the suggestion. Nothing in the tape settles it, which is the correct answer for a film about what television can make a room believe.
Why does the ending leave the format?
Because what has to be shown is not in the studio. The last sequence is Jack's accounting — the Grove, Madeleine, the trade — and none of it happened in front of a camera in 1977. The film chooses to show it rather than let the broadcast end on confusion. It costs the conceit and buys the only ending that explains the film.
Did Jack kill his wife?
At the end, yes, in the literal sense, and the film's argument is that he killed her twice. The stake is the second time. The first was a ritual he took part in because he wanted a career, and the whole broadcast is the story of a man who has spent years converting that into light entertainment.
If Late Night with the Devil is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Late Night with the Devil in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
The Mist
Frank Darabont · 2007 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
91% shared signal
Alien: Covenant
Ridley Scott · 2017 · Film
Shares explicit viscera.
90% shared signal
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers
Joe Chappelle · 1995 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
90% shared signal
Hellraiser
David Bruckner · 2022 · Film
Shares explicit viscera.
88% shared signal
A Nightmare on Elm Street
Samuel Bayer · 2010 · Film
85% shared signal

The Only Good Indians
Stephen Graham Jones · 2020 · Book
89% shared signal
The Walten Files
Martin Walls · 2020 · Web series
86% shared signal
Penny Dreadful
John Logan · 2014 · Television
86% shared signal
Questions about Late Night with the Devil
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
How does Late Night with the Devil end?
Jack provokes a live manifestation, the studio comes apart and June is killed. He is walked through a vision of the Grove, where he traded his wife Madeleine for his career, and in the final sequence he stabs what he thinks is the entity and finds he has killed Madeleine on air. The tape ends there.
What is the Grove in Late Night with the Devil?
A secretive men's club meeting in the redwoods that Jack joined on his way up. The black-and-white footage shows him taking part in a ritual there. The film never reads the terms aloud; it shows a man who wanted the chair, a ceremony, and a wife who died shortly before his ratings peaked.
Who is Mr Wriggles?
The entity attached to Lilly, surviving from Abraxas, the church June wrote about. It has a child's name because Lilly named it, which is considerably worse than a formal demonology. The film never explains it and its only apparent interest in the broadcast is the audience.
Was the hypnosis scene real in Late Night with the Devil?
The film will not say. Haig tells the audience they are full of worms and the cameras record a room clawing at itself. Either his scepticism covers a real ability or the entity used his suggestion. Nothing on the tape settles it, which suits a film about what television can make a room believe.
Is Late Night with the Devil found footage?
In form, yes — it is presented as a recovered broadcast master plus the 16mm shot during commercial breaks. It is closer to Ghostwatch than to a camcorder film: the horror arrives through a 1977 television grammar, with a director cutting between three cameras and finding the wrong one.
Why is the AI art in Late Night with the Devil controversial?
Three interstitial images between segments were machine-generated, which the filmmakers confirmed after release. It is a small amount of screen time on a film built almost entirely from period craft, and it remains the most common objection to it.
What should I watch after Late Night with the Devil?
Ghostwatch for the broadcast that did it to a real audience, The Mandela Catalogue for the same idea on the internet, and found footage horror for the format.
These are ranked against Late Night with the Devil, not against you.
Build your own tape →