Film · 2017
The Endless
J. Benson & A. Moorhead
Two brothers go back to the camp they escaped, where the same day keeps being available.
41Strong to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceSlow burn20
- ThreatSomething not human10
- GoreShows almost nothing14
- ToneBleak34
- RealityPure nightmare logic86
Era bias 86 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The most supernatural horror movies ever made →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, The Endless (2017) is most extreme on the threat axis: 10 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 2% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
The Endless is a 2017 American film directed by Justin Benson and Aaron Moorhead, in which two brothers go back to the UFO commune they escaped as teenagers and find that nobody there has aged. We score it 086 on reality anchor — only 18 works in an index of 320 go further — and 010 on the threat axis, near the inhuman floor of the index.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is The Endless, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
Reality anchor 086 is far into the surreal half — only 18 works go further and 7 tie it. Time is the thing that is broken and the film is strict about never explaining it.
Threat 010 sits near the inhuman floor of the index, with only 8 works lower and 11 tied. The entity is never embodied, never speaks and never wants anything you could refuse.
Viscera 014 is deep in the restrained half — 16 works are gentler. There is one hanging and almost nothing else.
Tone 034 is on the bleak side of the midpoint, with 222 works lower. Two people get out, and the film does not pretend that settles anything.
Pace 020 is firmly dread — 43 works are slower. It is nearly two hours of men working out a rule set.
On jump scares: one. The film's method is an object arriving where it should not be.
Who should skip The Endless
Skip it if you want the entity shown. It never is, and that is not a budget constraint, it is the design.
Skip it if amateur line readings break the spell for you. Several of them will.
Skip it if suicide depicted on a loop is too near. The shortest ring in the film is exactly that.
Watch it for a mechanism revealed entirely through composition, for the drive, and for one of the best pieces of low-budget cosmic horror on this shelf. It belongs with the rest of the cosmic horror shelf; At the Mountains of Madness is the ancestor and Annihilation the closest match for a zone with its own rules and no interest in yours.
The Endless on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what The Endless looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Where that puts it: joint #7 supernatural · joint #9 without gore · joint #10 surreal
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
The Endless: the review
A film made for almost no money by two men who also star in it, and one of the most completely realised pieces of cosmic horror anyone has shot.
Justin and Aaron Smith left Camp Arcadia ten years ago. Justin has spent the decade telling anybody who will listen that it was a death cult; Aaron, who was younger, remembers good food and people who were kind to him. They are cleaning houses, eating ramen, going to a support group for cult survivors. Aaron wants to visit. Justin agrees to one day.
Arcadia is a few acres up a dirt road with a brewery, a vegetable garden and about a dozen people. Hal is gracious. Anna is charming. Everybody is exactly as old as they were a decade ago, and nobody mentions it. There is a thing the camp calls the ascension, and a date for it, and the brothers' argument about whether to stay plays out while the film quietly establishes that the ground rules of the place are not social.
It is a structural film and it is patient about it
What Arcadia sits inside is a set of nested time loops of different lengths, administered by something the film shows you only as absence — a shadow with no object, a photograph taken by nobody, a tether snapping. One loop is a few seconds long and contains a man in a cabin. One is hours and contains three men at a lake with a magic trick. One is ten years and contains the camp.
Benson and Moorhead build the whole mechanism out of composition and sound. Objects come back. A ball thrown into the dark is returned. The sky has a second moon in it and nobody looks up. The rules are never explained by anybody who understands them, and every character who does understand them has decided to live inside their loop rather than against it.
It is also the sequel to the directors' first film, Resolution, and a long sequence overlaps that film's cabin directly. You do not need to have seen it. If you have, the overlap reframes both.
Where it frustrates
The brothers' relationship is the weakest material. The arguments are repetitive by design and repetitive in effect, and neither man is written with quite enough specificity to carry the long middle.
The performances are uneven. The directors are fine and a couple of the camp members are very good; two or three line readings are visibly amateur, and in a film that depends this heavily on unease the wrong line lands with a bump.
The ending of The Endless explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
What happens at the end of The Endless?
The brothers work out the shape of the thing: Arcadia's loop is about to close, everybody inside it will reset to the moment they arrived, and the camp is content with that because resetting is the ascension they have been waiting for.
They also work out that the loop has an edge, and that the thing administering it enforces the edge by tether rather than by wall — it pulls you back. So they drive. The sequence is the film's best: a road, a camera, the specific horror of a landscape repeating in the mirror, and a tether that stretches and holds and then does not.
They get out. Justin and Aaron drive away down a real road with a single moon in the sky. Arcadia goes back round.
What is the thing in the sky in The Endless?
The film never shows it and never names it, and the restraint is the point. What you get is evidence: a shadow cast with nothing to cast it, an object that comes back when thrown, photographs that arrive developed, a second moon, and a line of force that can be felt but not seen.
Its only observable interest is in keeping things. It does not kill, convert, speak or demand worship. It takes a stretch of time, closes it into a ring, and keeps whatever is inside the ring — and the people who have been inside one long enough start calling that an act of grace.
How do the loops work in The Endless?
They are nested and they vary enormously in length. The shortest the film shows is a few seconds: a man in a cabin who hangs himself, resets, and does it again, forever, having chosen that over the alternative. There is one of several hours at a lake, where three campers drink and perform the same magic trick and will not be persuaded they have done it before.
Arcadia's is about ten years. When a loop closes, everything inside returns to its start, with no memory carried over except what somebody has written down or photographed — which is why the camp keeps records and why the records are the first thing the brothers find alarming.
Crucially, the loops have edges in space as well as time. You can walk out of a short one and into a longer one, which is how the brothers map the place.
Is The Endless connected to Resolution?
Yes, directly. Resolution (2012) is Benson and Moorhead's first feature, about two friends in a cabin being shown recordings by something that wants a better ending to their story. The Endless visits that cabin and those characters mid-film, and the entity in both is the same.
The relationship is unusual: this film does not require the earlier one, but it does answer it. Watching them the other way round turns Resolution from an ambiguity into a report from inside one of the shorter rings.
Why does the camp want to stay in the loop?
Because they have read the alternative correctly. Everybody at Arcadia is somebody who was unhappy and is now safe, fed, liked, and about to return to the day they got here with none of the intervening disappointment. The film declines to call that stupid.
That is what makes it cosmic horror rather than cult horror. The entity does not need to recruit, deceive or threaten. It offers a loop, and the loop is genuinely preferable to a number of lives, and the two brothers who leave are not shown as wiser — only as the two who wanted the real road.
If The Endless is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to The Endless in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

Ringu
Hideo Nakata · 1998 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
81% shared signal

The Hollow Places
T. Kingfisher · 2020 · Book
Shares dream logic.
88% shared signal
The Backrooms
Kane Pixels · 2022 · Web series
Shares restraint over gore.
87% shared signal
Ben Drowned
Alexander Hall · 2010 · Web series
Shares restraint over gore.
84% shared signal

House of Leaves
Mark Z. Danielewski · 2000 · Book
Shares slow-burn dread.
84% shared signal
The King in Yellow
Robert W. Chambers · 1895 · Book
Shares dream logic.
84% shared signal

At the Mountains of Madness
H. P. Lovecraft · 1936 · Book
Shares a threat that is not human.
82% shared signal
Marble Hornets
Troy Wagner & Joseph Delage · 2009 · Web series
Shares slow-burn dread.
81% shared signal
More lists like these: Books like House of Leaves
Questions about The Endless
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
What is the thing in the sky in The Endless?
Never shown and never named. You get evidence instead: a shadow with nothing casting it, thrown objects returned, photographs that arrive developed, and a second moon. Its only observable interest is in keeping things — it closes stretches of time into rings and keeps what is inside.
How do the loops work in The Endless?
They are nested and vary in length, from a few seconds to about ten years. When a loop closes, everything inside returns to its start with no memory carried over except written records and photographs. The loops have spatial edges too, which is how the brothers map the place.
What happens at the end of The Endless?
The brothers realise Arcadia's ten-year loop is about to close and that the entity enforces the loop's edge with a tether rather than a wall. They drive for the boundary, the tether stretches and gives, and they get out. The camp resets without them.
Is The Endless a sequel to Resolution?
Yes, directly. Resolution (2012) is the same directors' first feature, and The Endless visits its cabin and its characters mid-film — the entity is the same one. You do not need to have seen it, but this film answers it.
Why do the Arcadia members want to stay?
Because the loop is genuinely better than their alternative. They are fed, liked and safe, and about to return to the day they arrived without the intervening disappointment. The film refuses to call that a mistake, which is what makes it cosmic horror rather than cult horror.
Is The Endless gory or scary?
Barely gory — we score it 014 on viscera, deep in the restrained half, with one hanging and little else. The fear is conceptual: we score it 020 on pace and it has a single jump scare, working instead by putting objects where they cannot be.
These are ranked against The Endless, not against you.
Build your own tape →