Film · 2017
It Comes at Night
Trey Edward Shults
A plague, a locked red door, and two families deciding how much to believe each other.
68Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceSlow burn24
- ThreatPeople, entirely88
- GoreShows some of it55
- ToneNo relief at all6
- RealityCould happen14
Era bias 86 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The bleakest horror movies ever made →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, It Comes at Night (2017) is most extreme on the tone axis: 6 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 3% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
It Comes at Night is a 2017 American film directed by Trey Edward Shults, in which two families share a boarded-up house during an unnamed plague and destroy each other over a locked door. We score it 088 on the threat axis — only 47 works in an index of 320 score higher — and 006 on tone, with just 9 works bleaker.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is It Comes at Night, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
Threat 088 is far toward the human end — 47 works score higher and 10 tie it. There is no entity. Everyone who dies is killed by a neighbour, a parent or a virus, and the film declines to show you the virus.
Tone 006 sits near the bleak floor of the index, with only 9 works lower and 12 tied. There is no survivor in any sense that matters.
Reality anchor 014 is near the grounded end — 303 works score higher. The dream sequences are framed as dreams; nothing else departs from the possible.
Pace 024 is firmly on the dread side, with 54 works slower. The violence is compressed into the last twelve minutes.
Viscera 055 is just above the midpoint. Bud's face, the pit, the dog and the shooting are all explicit, and none of them is lingered on.
On jump scares: two, both inside dreams. The waking film has none, which is why the dreams land.
Who should skip It Comes at Night
Skip it if you need the monster. There isn't one, the title says otherwise, and the people who hate this film almost all hate it for that reason.
Skip it if a sick child is too near. Andrew's illness and death are the hinge of the last act.
Skip it if ambiguity reads as evasion to you. The central question is never answered and the film is not interested in pretending otherwise.
Watch it for Edgerton, for the sound design, and for one of the most disciplined refusals on this shelf. If you want the same committee collapsing under siege with the cause fully explained, The Mist is the companion; The Thing is the better match for distrust as the actual antagonist.
It Comes at Night on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what It Comes at Night looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Where that puts it: joint #3 bleakest · joint #10 grounded
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
It Comes at Night: the review
A film whose title is a promise it has no intention of keeping, and which is better for the broken promise than it would have been for the kept one.
The opening is the whole film in miniature. Sarah's father, Bud, is in a bed with lesions on his face and blood in his breath. Paul and Travis carry him out in gas masks, put him in a wheelbarrow, shoot him, roll him into a pit and burn him. Nobody explains the disease, how long it has been going, or what the world outside the treeline looks like, and the film never will.
What it gives you instead is a house and a set of rules. One way in and out: a red door, kept locked, never opened at night. Paul recites the rules to his son the way a man recites a prayer he has decided to believe in. Travis is seventeen, sleeps badly, and has nightmares the film shoots in the same register as the waking scenes, so that for most of the runtime you are never sure which you are in.
Then Will breaks in looking for water for his family. Paul knocks him out, chains him to a tree for a day to see whether he is sick, decides he is not, and goes to fetch Will's wife Kim and their small son Andrew. Two families, one house, a shared larder, and a fortnight of something that looks very much like happiness.
The direction is doing something specific
Shults and cinematographer Drew Daniels change aspect ratio for the dream sequences and keep the waking film in a narrow, hemmed-in frame. They light the house almost entirely by lantern, which means the camera carries its own small circle of visibility down corridors that go black two feet past it.
The sound design is the better half. There is no score to speak of in the house scenes, so the film runs on floorboards, breathing, a dog, and the specific noise a door makes when it should not be making any noise at all. It is a method The Thing established and this film applies to a much smaller canvas: a closed room, a finite cast, and the certainty that one of them is a liability.
Joel Edgerton is very good as a man who has decided that love and violence are the same instrument. Kelvin Harrison Jr. carries the film, and the decision to route almost all of it through a teenager who is awake when he should be asleep is what makes the ambiguity load-bearing rather than decorative.
Where it frustrates
The marketing sold a monster and a great many people went in expecting one. That is not the film's fault, but the film does flirt with it — the dream sequences gesture at something stalking the woods, and then the gesture is withdrawn without comment.
Will and Kim are thinner than Paul and Sarah. The film needs them legible enough to be suspected and no more, and in a two-family chamber piece that asymmetry shows.
The ending of It Comes at Night explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
What happens at the end of It Comes at Night?
The red door is found open in the night, and Andrew is found asleep downstairs in the wrong room. Nobody admits to opening it. Shortly afterward the dog, Stanley, which had bolted into the woods barking at nothing days earlier, comes back dying. Then Andrew is sick.
Paul decides the other family has to go. Will refuses to be put out into the dark with a sick child. The argument becomes a fight and the fight becomes a shooting: Sarah kills Will, Paul kills Kim, and Andrew — a small boy, already ill — is shot in the confusion.
The last sequence gives Travis the lesions. Sarah sits with him while he dies. The final shot is the two parents at the kitchen table, blood still on them, looking at each other with nothing left to defend.
What does the ending of It Comes at Night mean?
That the rules were never the thing protecting them, and breaking them was never the thing that killed them. The house held for as long as nobody in it had a reason to act on suspicion, and it failed the first time somebody did.
The title is the film's argument stated as a lie. Nothing comes at night. What the dark does is remove every means of checking a story, so that a locked door found open becomes evidence of whatever the most frightened person in the house already believes.
Who opened the red door?
The film does not say, and that is a decision rather than an oversight. The candidates are all unsatisfying in productive ways. Andrew, sleepwalking, was found near it. Travis sleepwalks and the film has shown you his nightmares in the same visual grammar as its reality. Stanley got out somehow. One of the adults may simply have been careless and then been unable to say so once a child was sick.
Shults has said the unanswered questions are the point. Read the film as a mystery and the ending withholds; read it as a study of what suspicion does to people who cannot verify anything, and the withholding is the mechanism.
Did Travis catch the disease?
The last scenes show him with Bud's symptoms, and the most direct reading is that he caught it — from Stanley, from Andrew, or from the moment he put his hands on a sick man at the start. A minority reading treats the sequence as one more nightmare and the parents' final state as shock at what they have done.
Both readings end in the same place. Whether the plague took the last thing they had or they took it themselves, the house is a kitchen with two people in it and no reason to lock anything.
What is the disease in It Comes at Night?
Unnamed and unexplained. It is transmissible by contact, it produces lesions, blackened sclera and blood in the lungs, and it appears to kill within days. The film gives no origin, no name, no spread figures and no news from outside, and it holds that line for ninety-one minutes.
It belongs with The Mist and 28 Days Later in a tradition where the catastrophe is scenery and the subject is the committee that forms under it.
If It Comes at Night is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to It Comes at Night in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
The Invitation
Karyn Kusama · 2015 · Film
Shares human monsters.
91% shared signal
Goodnight Mommy
V. Franz & S. Fiala · 2014 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
86% shared signal
The Strangers
Bryan Bertino · 2008 · Film
Shares grounded realism.
84% shared signal
Halloween Ends
David Gordon Green · 2022 · Film
Shares human monsters.
80% shared signal
Halloween
David Gordon Green · 2018 · Film
Shares grounded realism.
77% shared signal
Cure
Kiyoshi Kurosawa · 1997 · Film
Shares slow-burn dread.
77% shared signal
Pearl
Ti West · 2022 · Film
77% shared signal

Tender Is the Flesh
Agustina Bazterrica · 2017 · Book
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
84% shared signal
More lists like these: Books like Tender Is the Flesh
Questions about It Comes at Night
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
What happens at the end of It Comes at Night?
The red door is found open, Andrew falls sick, and Paul tries to expel the other family. The fight becomes a shooting in which Sarah kills Will, Paul kills Kim, and Andrew is shot. Travis then shows the same symptoms and dies, leaving the parents alone at the table.
Who opened the red door in It Comes at Night?
The film never says. Andrew was found sleeping nearby, Travis sleepwalks, the dog had already got out once, and an adult may simply have been careless. The ambiguity is deliberate — the dark removes any way of checking, which is the film's actual subject.
What does the title It Comes at Night mean?
It is the film's thesis phrased as a lie. Nothing comes at night. What the dark does is strip away every means of verifying a story, so that one open door becomes proof of whatever the most frightened person in the house has already decided.
Does Travis die in It Comes at Night?
The closing scenes give him the lesions and blackened eyes the grandfather had, and Sarah sits with him as he dies. A minority reading treats it as another nightmare, but either way the family ends with two people and nothing to protect.
What is the sickness in It Comes at Night?
Never named or explained. It spreads by contact, produces lesions, blackened eyes and blood in the lungs, and kills in days. The film gives no origin, no geography and no news from outside, and holds that refusal for its whole runtime.
Is It Comes at Night scary?
Not in the jump-scare sense; we score it 024 on pace, well into the dread half, with its only stingers inside dream sequences. The fear is social and terminal — we score tone 006, near the bleak floor of the index.
These are ranked against It Comes at Night, not against you.
Build your own tape →