VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

HOSTEL F-2098 · 2005 · FILM

Film · 2005

Hostel

Eli Roth

Backpackers chasing a good time find out they were the product all along.

84Punishing to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PaceBuilds, then strikes60
  • ThreatPeople, entirely94
  • GoreUnflinching92
  • ToneNo relief at all12
  • RealityCould happen14

Era bias 70 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

Horror movies where the monster is a person →

EXTREMITYHUMAN MONSTERGORE
Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Hostel (2005) is most extreme on the threat axis: 94 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 93% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Hostel is a 2005 American horror film written and directed by Eli Roth. Two American backpackers and an Icelandic friend are lured to a hostel in Slovakia with the promise of easy women, and discover they have been sold to wealthy clients who pay to torture and kill people. We score it 094 on the threat axis and 092 on viscera.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Hostel, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.

The threat at 094 is near the human end — 297 works score lower. There is nothing supernatural in it: a company, its staff and its paying customers do all the harm.

Viscera 092 is high — 302 works score lower. A drill, cut tendons, a chainsaw to the fingers, a severed leg, a face burned with a blowtorch and a suicide by train, mostly shown.

Tone 012 is bleak — 60 works score lower. The opening is a sex comedy, but it exists to set up a trap, and the survivor's last act is another killing.

Pace 060 is on the shock side of the middle, with 193 works slower. A slow, deliberately grating first act, then a sustained run of torture, escape and chase.

Era bias 070 reads modern — 157 works score lower. Mid-2000s digital grading, a sampled club track in the disco and a backpacker world of hostels, spas and night trains.

Reality anchor 014 is grounded — 11 works score lower. Everything in it is presented as possible, which is the point of the premise.

On jump scares: a few. The worst moments are anticipated rather than sprung, and the film usually shows you the tools first.

Who should skip Hostel

Hostel on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Hostel looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 60 Builds, then strikes
THE THREAT 94 People, entirely
VISCERA 92 Unflinching
ERA BIAS 70 Modern
TONE 12 No relief at all
REALITY ANCHOR 14 Could happen

Where that puts it: joint #6 goriest · joint #10 grounded · joint #14 human monsters

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Hostel: the review

Hostel is a nasty, clever little film about the worst kind of tourist, and it is cleverer than the label it was given.

That label came from David Edelstein in New York magazine, who called it "torture porn", and the phrase stuck to a whole cycle of films that followed it and Saw. It is fair as a description of what is on screen. It is less fair as a description of what the film is about, which is money, and specifically what money lets the people who have it do to the people who do not.

Half a sex comedy, by design

For the first forty minutes Hostel is a crass backpacker comedy. Paxton and Josh, two American college students, and Óli, an Icelander they have picked up on the way, are thrown out of an Amsterdam club, meet a man named Alexei who tells them about a hostel near Bratislava full of attractive women, and change their plans. On the train, a Dutch businessman makes an unwanted advance on Josh. At the hostel, two women, Natalya and Svetlana, take them to a spa and a disco and sleep with them. Óli leaves with the desk clerk and does not come back.

The film is deliberately unpleasant in this stretch. The young men are entitled, loud and transactional, and Roth wants the audience to notice. When the hostel turns out to be a shop window, the joke is that they were the merchandise. Roth answered Slovak officials who objected to the film's picture of their country by saying it was about American ignorance of the world, not about Slovakia, and the first act is the evidence for that.

The business model is the monster

What happens to Josh is the film's hinge. He wakes chained to a chair in a basement, surrounded by tools, and the man who has paid for him is the Dutch businessman from the train, who had seemed the one kind adult in the film. He drills Josh, cuts his Achilles tendons, and cuts his throat. Jan Vlasák, a Czech actor known for Shakespeare on stage, plays him with a mild, courteous sadness that is worse than any snarl.

From there the film becomes Paxton's escape, and it reveals the system piece by piece: a derelict factory called the Art Show, rooms of captives, clients from Germany and the United States, and a business card for the Elite Hunting Club, which sells the murder of tourists to people rich enough to pay. The idea came from a conversation Roth had with Harry Knowles about a website said to sell "murder vacations" in Thailand. Roth looked for evidence such services existed, found little, and made a fiction instead, which is the right call: the horror is that it sounds like a product.

The torture chamber scenes were shot in a wing of a Prague hospital abandoned since 1917, and the production design has that institutional grimness. Milan Chadima's photography is cold and flat, and Nathan Barr's score, played by the Prague FILMharmonic, does not try to make anything elegant. Quentin Tarantino, who encouraged Roth to write something original after the success of Cabin Fever, is an executive producer and appears briefly at a hotel window; Takashi Miike, who directed Audition, has a cameo as a client.

A hit, and a fight about it

The film was made for $4.8 million and opened at the top of the American box office in January 2006 with $19.6 million, on its way to around $80 million worldwide. Two sequels followed, in 2007 and 2011. That success is part of why the argument about it became so loud. Critics divided: Owen Gleiberman in Entertainment Weekly praised its picture of exploitative capitalism in the former Soviet bloc, Le Monde's critic named it the best American film of 2006, and Peter Bradshaw in The Guardian called it silly, crass and queasy. Audiences were cooler than the box office suggests, giving it a C-minus CinemaScore.

Both camps have a point. The film is crude, and its first act is calculated to irritate. But it is also built with care. The pivot from the disco to the basement is placed exactly at the moment the audience has grown most impatient with the three friends, which makes the cruelty feel like a punishment the film has tricked you into wishing for. Roth then spends the rest of the running time making you regret it.

Jay Hernandez is the reason the second half works. Roth cast him because he wanted a natural, relatable actor, and he plays Paxton's escape as panic rather than heroics: he fumbles, hides, runs and only fights when there is no alternative. When he finally kills the Dutch businessman in a Vienna restroom, the film plays it calmly, and that calm is what frightens you about him.

Where it falls down

The first act tries too hard to make you dislike its heroes and then expects you to care about one of them. Paxton's escape leans on luck and convenience, including restraints that come loose at the perfect moment and a client who severs his own leg. Kana, the Japanese tourist he rescues, exists to be disfigured and then to die, and the film does not give her a single scene of her own. The portrayal of Slovakia as a lawless, child-gang-ridden wasteland is a cartoon, and Roth's own defence of it only half answers the complaint.

None of that cancels what it does well, which is the moment the kind man on the train walks into the basement. For the franchise that defined the same decade's appetite for bodily punishment, the Saw films in order; for the same premise of torture as a commodity for the powerful, taken somewhere far more serious, Martyrs.

The ending of Hostel explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: Paxton escapes the Art Show after his German client, Johann, falls and severs his own leg; Paxton shoots him, kills a guard, and finds an Elite Hunting Club business card. He rescues Kana from an American client burning her face with a blowtorch, kills the client, and flees in a stolen car, running down Natalya, Svetlana and Alexei. At the station, club guards and corrupt police are waiting. Kana, horrified by her face, throws herself in front of a train, and the distraction lets Paxton board another one. On it he hears the Dutch businessman's voice. In Vienna he follows him into a public restroom, mutilates his fingers, cuts his throat, and returns calmly to his seat.

What is the Elite Hunting Club in Hostel?

A business that sells tourists to wealthy clients who pay to torture and kill them. The hostel, its staff and the women who befriend travellers are the supply chain: they identify foreigners, drug them and deliver them to a derelict factory called the Art Show. Paxton finds the club's business card during his escape. The idea grew from a story Eli Roth heard about a website reportedly selling "murder vacations" in Thailand.

Does Paxton survive Hostel?

Yes. Of the three friends, he is the one who gets out. He escapes the factory, survives a car chase, and boards a train while guards are distracted by Kana's suicide at the station. In Vienna he kills the Dutch businessman who murdered Josh, then sits back down on the train. The theatrical cut ends with him free.

What happens to Josh and Óli in Hostel?

Both are killed by the club. Josh wakes chained in the basement and is murdered by the Dutch businessman from the train, who drills him, cuts his Achilles tendons and slits his throat. Óli disappears after leaving with the hostel's desk clerk, and is later shown already decapitated. Paxton finds Josh's body being stitched together at the Art Show.

What is the alternate ending of Hostel?

In the director's cut, Paxton follows the Dutch businessman into the station restroom, but the businessman is travelling with his young daughter. When he loses track of her in the crowd and searches for her, Paxton is shown on the departing train with the girl, whom he has kidnapped. It replaces revenge by murder with revenge by abduction, and it is a far darker last image.

If Hostel is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Hostel in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

Questions about Hostel

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

What happens at the end of Hostel?

Paxton escapes the torture factory, rescues Kana and runs down Natalya, Svetlana and Alexei. At the station Kana throws herself in front of a train, distracting the guards so Paxton can board another. On it he hears the Dutch businessman who killed Josh, follows him into a restroom in Vienna, mutilates his fingers, cuts his throat and returns calmly to his seat.

Is Hostel based on a true story?

No. Eli Roth developed it from a conversation with Harry Knowles of Ain't It Cool News about a website reportedly selling "murder vacations" in Thailand. Roth considered making a mockumentary but found little credible information that such services existed, so he wrote it as fiction.

Where was Hostel filmed?

In the Czech Republic, not Slovakia. Many scenes were shot in Český Krumlov, and the torture chamber scenes were filmed in a wing of a Prague hospital that had been abandoned since 1917. The film is an American and Czech production.

Who is the Dutch businessman in Hostel?

A former surgeon and client of the Elite Hunting Club, played by the Czech stage actor Jan Vlasák. He meets the friends on the train, later seems to protect Josh from a gang of children, and then turns out to have paid to torture and kill him. Paxton kills him in a Vienna restroom at the end.

How gory is Hostel?

Very. We score it 092 on viscera. A drill, cut Achilles tendons, a chainsaw taken to fingers, a severed leg and a face burned with a blowtorch are all shown on screen. It won a Scream Award for Most Memorable Mutilation and was rated 18 in the UK.

Is Quentin Tarantino in Hostel?

Briefly. Tarantino was an executive producer and appears as a shirtless partygoer at a hotel window. The Japanese director Takashi Miike has a cameo as a club client, and Eli Roth appears uncredited as a tourist in a coffee house.

These are ranked against Hostel, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy