Film · 2021
Spiral: From the Book of Saw
A copycat with a pig puppet goes after crooked cops. A detective thriller in a pig mask.
76Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceBuilds, then strikes62
- ThreatPeople, entirely92
- GoreExplicit76
- ToneBleak18
- RealityGrounded24
Era bias 88 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
Horror movies where the monster is a person →
Part of a series: Saw movies in order →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Spiral: From the Book of Saw (2021) is most extreme on the threat axis: 92 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 89% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
Spiral: From the Book of Saw is a 2021 American trap-horror film directed by Darren Lynn Bousman, written by Josh Stolberg and Peter Goldfinger. A copycat killer working in Jigsaw's style starts picking off corrupt police officers, and the outcast detective assigned to the case is drawn into his game. We score it 092 on the threat axis and 088 on era bias.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Spiral: From the Book of Saw, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
The threat at 092 is near the human end — 284 works score lower. A copycat with a grievance, corrupt officers and a trigger-happy SWAT team; nothing supernatural happens.
Viscera 076 is high — 245 works score lower. A man hung by his tongue in front of a train, fingers torn off, a skinned corpse, boiling wax poured onto a face and a man shredded by flying glass.
Tone 018 is bleak — 119 works score lower. Rock's comic energy lifts the early scenes, but the ending kills the hero's father in front of him and lets the killer walk.
Pace 062 is on the shock side, with 206 works slower. A procedural rhythm with sudden, savage set-pieces.
Era bias 088 reads modern — 267 works score lower. Sharp, sunlit digital photography and a contemporary police drama look.
Reality anchor 024 is grounded — 45 works score lower. Corrupt cops, a revenge plot and machines a determined man could build.
On jump scares: a few, mostly in the investigation scenes rather than the traps.
Who should skip Spiral: From the Book of Saw
Skip it if you want a hard-to-solve mystery. The killer's identity is easy to guess, and the film leans heavily on the reveal.
Skip it if you want Jigsaw himself. Tobin Bell does not appear, and the killer is a copycat with a different puppet and voice.
Skip it if police violence is a difficult subject. The film is about corrupt officers, and it ends with a SWAT team killing a hostage.
Content notes: a man hung by his tongue and hit by a train, fingers torn off, a skinned body, boiling wax poured over a woman's face, a trap demanding a woman cut her own spinal cord, a man killed by flying glass, a man drained of blood, police corruption and murder, and a fatal police shooting.
Watch it if you like detective thrillers, you want a Saw film with a new target and a different voice, and you are curious to see Chris Rock play it straight.
Spiral: From the Book of Saw on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Spiral: From the Book of Saw looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Spiral: From the Book of Saw: the review
Spiral is a cop thriller wearing a pig mask, and it is more interesting as the first than as the second.
It began with Chris Rock. He met Lionsgate's vice chairman at a friend's wedding in Brazil, wanted to try horror as a new direction for his career, and pitched the studio a way to extend the franchise. Lionsgate took it. Rock polished Stolberg and Goldfinger's script, rewrote material on set — including the whole introduction of his own character — and took the lead as Zeke Banks, a detective whose colleagues despise him because, years ago, he turned in a partner who committed a murder. The film is his idea and his vehicle, and it shows in both directions.
A Saw film about the police
The killer here is not testing addicts, frauds or insurance executives. He is going after cops — specifically, cops who lied, covered for each other, or looked away. The opening trap catches a detective chasing a thief into the sewers during a Fourth of July parade and hangs him by his tongue in a subway tunnel with a train coming. The next is the officer who once ignored a backup call from Zeke and nearly got him killed. A package arrives at the precinct with a pig puppet inside and a piece of tattooed skin that seems to belong to Zeke's new partner, the eager rookie William Schenk.
That premise gives Spiral something the later sequels lacked: a real-world target with a real-world grievance. Kramer's victims were usually chosen for private sins. These are public ones. The film is about a precinct closing ranks, and the traps are built to make officers choose between their own bodies and the truth. It is a strong engine, and Bousman, a former series director returning to the franchise, shoots it with a hard, sunlit look closer to a detective thriller than to the green sludge of the old series.
The traps are built around confession
The devices in Spiral are less elaborate than the original run's and more pointed. Each one is designed around an officer's specific failure. Detective Fitch, who ignored Zeke's call for backup, stands in a filling water basin with his fingers in a machine and must let it rip them off or be electrocuted. Captain Garza is trapped in the precinct's cold storage under a pipe of boiling wax and can only stop it by driving her own spine onto a blade. Dunleavy, the partner Zeke once exposed for murder, is chained in front of a glass-crushing machine modified to hurl shrapnel, and Zeke is given the choice to free him or leave him; he tries and is too late.
The writers say the character grew out of Rock wondering what he would do in Dr Gordon's place in the original bathroom, with a foot to cut off, and you can see that idea in the warehouse scene where Zeke wakes handcuffed to a pipe with a hacksaw beside him. He considers it, and then gets free with a bobby pin. It is a neat little joke at the franchise's expense, and a statement of who this film thinks its hero is.
The production was modest by modern standards — a $20 million budget and a Toronto shoot from July to late August 2019 — and an early draft that would have made Zeke a relative of Detective Tapp from the first film was dropped because, in the writers' words, it did not pass the smell test.
Rock is the best and worst thing in it
Rock is genuinely good when Zeke is angry or alone. The early scenes, where he plays the precinct's pariah, have a bitter comic energy that is unlike anything else in the franchise — Rock had said from the start that he planned to include some comedy, and his first scenes play almost like stand-up. But the film cannot quite decide whether he is a comedian in a horror film or a dramatic lead, and when the material turns grief-stricken, he does not always carry it.
Samuel L. Jackson, as his father Marcus, a retired police chief, has less to do than his billing suggests, but he gets the most memorable image: suspended from wires like a marionette, which Jackson said was part of why he took the role. Max Minghella is quietly effective as Schenk, and Marisol Nichols, as Captain Garza, gets one of the nastier traps in the series, in the precinct's own cold storage.
Where it falls down
The mystery is easy. The film's only real suspect is introduced, removed from the board in a way the genre has trained everyone to distrust, and then revealed. Most viewers will have it long before Zeke does.
The killer's voice is a misjudgement. Tobin Bell did not return, and the filmmakers decided reusing his voice would raise questions about how the killers were connected, so they replaced Billy the Puppet with a new pig puppet and struggled to find a new voice. The result sounds less threatening than silly; one critic compared it to Kermit the Frog.
And for all its ideas, the film is more procedural than horror for long stretches. Bousman said it was rated NC-17 eleven times before enough was cut for an R, and you can feel the gaps.
It was delayed a year by the pandemic, opened at number one with the franchise's lowest opening weekend, and finished as its lowest-grossing entry, at $40.6 million on a $20 million budget. It deserves a little better. Place it in the Saw movies in order, and if you want Kramer's own story told with real conviction, Saw X is the better spin-off. For a purely human threat played with far more dread, The Strangers.
The ending of Spiral: From the Book of Saw explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: the copycat is Detective William Schenk. The skinned body identified as him was actually the thief who lured the first victim into the tunnels; Schenk faked his own death. His real surname is Emmerson. His father, Charlie Emmerson, was killed by Zeke's former partner Peter Dunleavy because he had agreed to testify against a dirty cop, and Schenk has learned that Zeke's father Marcus, as chief, deliberately protected corrupt officers to clean up the streets faster. Believing Zeke might be an ally, Schenk sets him a final test. Marcus hangs suspended above the floor, slowly being drained of blood. Schenk calls 911, claims to be a civilian being chased by a shooter, and hands Zeke a revolver with one bullet: shoot a target that will save Marcus and let Schenk escape, or shoot Schenk and let Marcus bleed out. Zeke saves his father, and Marcus is lowered to the ground. But when the SWAT team arrives, they trip a wire that yanks Marcus back up, revealing a gun fixed to his arm. The officers take him for the shooter and kill him, and Schenk escapes while Zeke screams.
Who is the killer in Spiral?
William Schenk, Zeke's rookie partner, played by Max Minghella. He is not the original Jigsaw or one of Kramer's apprentices but a copycat. He fakes his death using the skinned corpse of the thief from the opening, and he is the son of Charlie Emmerson, a man murdered by a corrupt officer before he could testify.
Why is Schenk killing police officers?
Revenge, and a cause. His father was murdered by Peter Dunleavy to stop him testifying against a dirty cop. Schenk targets officers who lied, covered for one another or protected corruption, and he blames Zeke's father Marcus for shielding corrupt officers during his time as chief. He thinks Zeke, who once exposed a crooked partner, might join him.
How does Marcus Banks die in Spiral?
The SWAT team kills him. Zeke uses the single bullet to save his father, who is lowered toward the floor, but the arriving officers trip a wire that hoists Marcus back up and reveals a gun attached to his arm. Schenk has already called in a report of an armed shooter, so the SWAT team takes Marcus for the gunman and shoots him.
Is Spiral connected to Jigsaw?
Only by method. The killer is a copycat inspired by the dead Jigsaw Killer, and Zeke recognises the traps as Jigsaw's modus operandi. Tobin Bell does not appear, and the filmmakers replaced Billy with a new puppet so the killer would not be taken for one of Kramer's apprentices.
If Spiral: From the Book of Saw is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Spiral: From the Book of Saw in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
Leatherface
Julien Maury and Alexandre Bustillo · 2017 · Film
Shares human monsters.
95% shared signal
Jigsaw
The Spierig Brothers · 2017 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
95% shared signal
Saw V
David Hackl · 2008 · Film
Shares explicit viscera.
94% shared signal

Saw
James Wan · 2004 · Film
Shares grounded realism.
94% shared signal
Saw II
Darren Lynn Bousman · 2005 · Film
Shares human monsters.
93% shared signal
Halloween
Rob Zombie · 2007 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
93% shared signal
Sleepaway Camp
Robert Hiltzik · 1983 · Film
Shares grounded realism.
92% shared signal
Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III
Jeff Burr · 1990 · Film
Shares explicit viscera.
92% shared signal
More lists like these: Movies like Saw
Questions about Spiral: From the Book of Saw
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
What happens at the end of Spiral?
Schenk, the rookie believed dead, is revealed as the copycat killer. He gives Zeke one bullet to save his father Marcus or kill him. Zeke saves Marcus, but arriving SWAT officers trip a wire that hoists Marcus up and reveals a gun on his arm, and they shoot him. Schenk escapes as Zeke screams.
Who is the Spiral killer?
Detective William Schenk, played by Max Minghella, Zeke's new partner. He faked his death using the skinned body of a thief. His real surname is Emmerson; his father Charlie was killed by a corrupt officer to stop him testifying, and Schenk targets police corruption in revenge.
Is Tobin Bell in Spiral?
No. Bell did not return as John Kramer. The filmmakers wanted the new killer to be a copycat and feared that using Bell's voice would raise questions about how the killers were connected, so they replaced Billy the Puppet with a new pig puppet and gave the killer a new voice.
Is Spiral part of the Saw series?
Yes. It is the ninth instalment of the Saw franchise, a spin-off following Jigsaw (2017), with a copycat killer rather than John Kramer or his apprentices. Series creators James Wan and Leigh Whannell were executive producers, and it was followed by Saw X in 2023.
How gory is Spiral?
Quite gory, though less than the original run. We score it 076 on viscera. The traps include a man hung by his tongue, fingers ripped off, hot wax poured onto a face and a glass-shredding machine. Bousman said it was rated NC-17 eleven times before cuts earned an R.
These are ranked against Spiral: From the Book of Saw, not against you.
Build your own tape →