Film · 2019
It Chapter Two
The Losers go home to Derry as adults. The clown remembers them better than they do.
59Strong to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceBuilds, then strikes60
- ThreatSomething not human14
- GoreShows some of it62
- ToneGrim, with air44
- RealityDream logic70
Era bias 90 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The most supernatural horror movies ever made →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, It Chapter Two (2019) is most extreme on the threat axis: 14 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 9% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
It Chapter Two is a 2019 American supernatural horror film directed by Andy Muschietti and written by Gary Dauberman from Stephen King's novel. Twenty-seven years after the first film, the grown Losers Club return to Derry, Maine, to keep a childhood oath and kill It for good. We score it 014 on the threat axis and 070 on reality anchor.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is It Chapter Two, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
The threat at 014 is near the supernatural end — 28 works score lower. It is an ancient shape-shifting creature that returns every twenty-seven years; the human cruelty in the film, from the carnival gang to Henry Bowers, is either It's instrument or a backdrop to it.
Viscera 062 is on the explicit side — 178 works score lower. Adrian Mellon's beating and death, the killing of Victoria under the bleachers, Bowers impaled and Eddie's fatal wound are all shown, though the worst of the creature work is more grotesque than gory.
Tone 044 sits near the middle — 257 works score lower. The film has real losses, including Stanley and Eddie, but Bill Hader is given a running stream of jokes and the ending is warm, even sentimental.
Pace 060 is on the shock side — 193 works score lower. The middle hour is a chain of solo set-pieces built to climax in a lunge or a transformation.
Era bias 090 reads modern — 291 works score lower. Heavy digital creature effects, digitally de-aged child actors and a clean, saturated modern grade.
Reality anchor 070 is on the surreal side — 245 works score lower. Hallucinations, a shape-shifter with a giant spider form, a magical ritual and scars that vanish at the end.
On jump scares: plenty, and many of them are a computer-generated face lunging at the camera.
Who should skip It Chapter Two
Skip it if long running times test you. It is 169 minutes, and the middle hour is a series of solo errands rather than a building story.
Skip it if horror played for laughs annoys you. Jokes run straight through scenes that are meant to be frightening, and not every one lands.
Skip it if a homophobic hate crime is hard to watch. The film opens with a gay couple beaten by teenagers and one of them killed.
Content notes: a homophobic assault and killing, the death of a child, suicide, impalement, spiders and body-horror transformations, and clown imagery throughout.
Watch it if you loved the first film and want to see the Losers through to the end, you like a big-budget creature show, and Bill Hader's performance is reason enough for you.
It Chapter Two on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what It Chapter Two looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Where that puts it: joint #10 modern
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
It Chapter Two: the review
It Chapter Two is a film that has all the money and all the running time it could want, and it spends both on proving that grown-ups are less frightening than children.
That is not quite a complaint. Muschietti's first It worked because it was a coming-of-age film about kids who could not tell anybody what was happening to them. The sequel has to do the half of King's novel that is harder to film: the half where the kids grew up, left, forgot, and are summoned home by a phone call from Mike Hanlon, the only one of them who stayed. It runs 169 minutes. Warner Bros. gave it a budget of $79 million, and it made $473.1 million worldwide. Nobody involved was short of anything, and you can see it in every frame.
The cast is the best thing in it
The adult Losers are cast almost entirely for resemblance to the children, and it pays off. Jessica Chastain's Beverly, James McAvoy's Bill, Isaiah Mustafa's Mike, Jay Ryan's Ben and James Ransone's Eddie all feel like the people Sophia Lillis, Jaeden Martell, Chosen Jacobs, Jeremy Ray Taylor and Jack Dylan Grazer would become. Bill Hader as Richie is the standout, and the film knows it. He is the comic relief for two hours, and then it turns out the comedy was covering something: in an abandoned cinema Pennywise confronts him with the secret he has kept since childhood, his hidden homosexuality, and the final third of the film quietly becomes his.
The film also opens on that theme, and it is the nastiest thing in it. In 2016, a gang of homophobic teenagers assault Adrian Mellon and his boyfriend at a Derry carnival, and It kills Adrian. The scene is brutal in a way the rest of the film is not, because the cruelty in it is entirely human before anything supernatural arrives. It is one of the few moments where the town of Derry, and not the clown, is the monster.
A scavenger hunt in a haunted town
The middle of the film is structured as a series of solo errands. Mike has learned, through a drug-induced vision, of a Native American ritual, the Ritual of Chüd, that requires each Loser to bring an artifact from their childhood. So each of them wanders Derry alone, finds the object, and is attacked by a set-piece built around their particular fear. Bill finds Georgie's paper boat. Bill fails to save a boy called Dean. It kills a girl called Victoria under the bleachers at a baseball game.
This is where the film is most like a ride and least like a story. Each sequence is technically lavish, Bill Skarsgård is still uncanny in the moments he is allowed to be a performer rather than a render, and some of the designs are genuinely strange. But the structure means the Losers spend the middle hour of a film about a group apart, and the scares arrive on a timetable you can feel. Henry Bowers, freed from a mental institution with It's help, turns up to attack Mike in the library and is impaled by Richie, and even that feels like an obligation being discharged.
The ending is about making a monster small
What the climax does well is find a way to kill It that is not a fight. The ritual fails. It takes a vast spider-like form in the cavern under the sewers, and the Losers win by doing something children cannot: they confront their guilt, then they mock It, insult it and belittle it until it shrinks into a crying, baby-like thing that Mike can reach into and take the heart out of. They crush the heart with their bare hands. It is a better idea than any amount of fire, and it is what the whole film has been arguing: that the thing which haunted you as a child has only the size you keep giving it.
The film's most effective device is that it never lets go of the children. The first film's young cast return throughout in flashback, digitally de-aged, and Muschietti cuts between the two generations so often that the adults sometimes seem to be standing inside their own memories. Port Hope, Ontario, stands in for Derry again, and the continuity of place does a lot of quiet work: the same streets, the same Neibolt House, the same storm drain where Bill's brother Georgie was taken. When the film is at its best, it is about the horror of going home and finding that the town has not changed and you have. When it is at its worst, it is about a monster jumping out of a door.
Where it falls down
Length, first and last. A 169-minute horror film needs either an escalating story or a growing dread, and this has neither through its middle hour; it has errands. The computer-generated creatures are expensive and almost never frightening, because nothing in them has weight or texture, and the film leans on them where the first one leaned on Skarsgård's face. The tone also wobbles badly. Hader's jokes are funny, but the film puts gags into scenes that ought to be terrifying, which drains the set-pieces of the menace they are built for. And the ritual subplot, with its borrowed Native American mysticism, is treated as a device rather than anything the film thinks about.
If you liked this, go back to It, which is the stronger half, and to the 1990 miniseries, It, which told both halves of the story on television. For more Stephen King on film, Doctor Sleep arrived the same year and deals with an adult returning to a childhood horror in a much quieter key.
The ending of It Chapter Two explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: the Ritual of Chüd fails, and Mike admits he hid that it killed the people who first performed it. It takes a giant spider-like form in its cavern under Neibolt House. Eddie saves a catatonic Richie and is fatally impaled; before he dies, he tells them how he made It feel small. The Losers insult and belittle It until it shrinks into a crying, baby-like creature, Mike pulls out its heart, and they crush it with their bare hands. It dies, the cavern collapses and destroys the Neibolt House, and they have to leave Eddie's body behind. Afterwards the scars on their hands disappear, Ben and Beverly marry, Mike leaves Derry, and a letter from Stanley reveals why he took his own life.
How do the Losers kill Pennywise in It Chapter Two?
By making it small. Eddie realises that when he choked the Leper as a boy, It had shrunk from him, and the others turn that into a method: they confront It about overcoming their fears and insult it, and it becomes smaller with each insult, cycling through its forms until it is a crying, baby-like figure. Mike pulls out its heart and the Losers crush it together. It laughs at its own defeat and dies.
Why did Stanley kill himself in It Chapter Two?
Stanley's letter, read at the end, explains that he was too afraid to face It again, and that he took his own life to strengthen his friends rather than weaken them by coming back. He was also the one who had written the letters the others received. The letter closes with the line "We're Losers, and always will be."
How does Eddie die in It Chapter Two?
In the cavern, Eddie saves Richie, who has been left catatonic, and is impaled by It in the process. He lives long enough to tell the others how he had once made It feel small, which gives them the way to win. He dies of the wound, and when the cavern collapses the Losers have to leave his body behind.
What is Richie's secret in It Chapter Two?
That he is gay and has hidden it since childhood. Pennywise confronts him with it in an abandoned cinema, and it reframes Richie's relationship with Eddie for the rest of the film. In the closing scenes, Richie returns to the kissing bridge in Derry.
What is the Ritual of Chüd?
A Native American ritual that Mike learned of through a drug-induced vision, which uses artifacts from the Losers' past to defeat It. It fails. It then pressures Mike into admitting that the ritual killed the people who originally performed it, something he had withheld from the others.
If It Chapter Two is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to It Chapter Two in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

It
Andy Muschietti · 2017 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
94% shared signal
Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday
Adam Marcus · 1993 · Film
Shares dream logic.
90% shared signal
A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy's Revenge
Jack Sholder · 1985 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
90% shared signal
Alien Resurrection
Jean-Pierre Jeunet · 1997 · Film
89% shared signal
A Nightmare on Elm Street
Wes Craven · 1984 · Film
Shares dream logic.
88% shared signal
A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors
Chuck Russell · 1987 · Film
87% shared signal
Profondo Rosso
Goblin · 1975 · Record
89% shared signal
Suspiria (OST)
Goblin · 1977 · Record
88% shared signal
More lists like these: Movies like It
Questions about It Chapter Two
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
What happens at the end of It Chapter Two?
The ritual fails, Eddie is fatally impaled saving Richie, and the Losers defeat It by insulting it until it shrinks into a crying, baby-like creature. Mike pulls out its heart and they crush it by hand. The cavern collapses, Eddie's body is left behind, their scars fade, and Stanley's letter explains his suicide.
How do they kill Pennywise in It Chapter Two?
They make it small. Following Eddie's discovery that It shrank from him once, the Losers mock and belittle it, and it becomes smaller with each insult until it is a crying, baby-like figure. Mike pulls out its heart and the Losers crush it with their bare hands, and It dies laughing.
Why did Stanley kill himself in It Chapter Two?
His letter says he was too afraid to face It again and took his own life to make his friends stronger, believing he would only weaken them by returning. He had also written the letters the other Losers received. It closes with "We're Losers, and always will be."
Does Eddie die in It Chapter Two?
Yes. Eddie saves Richie from a catatonic state in It's cavern and is impaled. Before he dies he tells the others how he had once made It feel small, which gives them the way to beat it. The Losers have to leave his body behind when the cavern collapses.
How long is It Chapter Two?
It runs 169 minutes, which makes it a long film for the genre. It was released in the United States on September 6, 2019, after a premiere in Los Angeles in August, and it grossed about $473.1 million worldwide on a $79 million budget.
Is It Chapter Two scarier than It (2017)?
We do not think so. The first film's scares are built around a frightened child and Bill Skarsgård's face; the sequel leans on computer-generated creatures and breaks its own tension with jokes. It scores 062 on viscera and 070 on reality anchor, so it is gorier and stranger, but not more frightening.
These are ranked against It Chapter Two, not against you.
Build your own tape →