VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

DOCTORSLEEP F-1904 · 2019 · FILM

Film · 2019

Doctor Sleep

Mike Flanagan

Danny Torrance grown up, sober, and needed back at the hotel.

63Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PaceSlow burn32
  • ThreatHuman and not60
  • GoreExplicit66
  • ToneBleak26
  • RealityDream logic70

Era bias 88 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

The bleakest horror movies ever made →

Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Doctor Sleep (2019) is most extreme on the tone axis: 26 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 54% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Doctor Sleep is a 2019 American film directed by Mike Flanagan, in which Danny Torrance, forty years sober-adjacent and working hospice, is pulled back to the Overlook by a girl with more shine than he ever had. We score it 070 on reality anchor — 64 works in an index of 320 go further — and 066 on viscera, which is higher than people remember.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Doctor Sleep, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.

Reality anchor 070 is well into the surreal half — 64 works go further. Ghosts, astral travel, mind-reading, and a hotel with intentions.

Viscera 066 is above the midpoint, with 111 works more explicit. The Baseball Boy sequence alone puts it here and it is the film's hardest watch.

Threat 060 sits a little past the midpoint. The Knot are people-shaped and were once people; the hotel is not and never was.

Tone 026 is on the bleak side, with 172 works lower. Dan dies, Abra inherits it, and the film treats that as the good outcome.

Pace 032 is on the dread side — 88 works are slower. Two and a half hours of accumulation and one sustained climax.

On jump scares: five. Flanagan prefers a held shot and a thing already in it.

Who should skip Doctor Sleep

Doctor Sleep on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Doctor Sleep looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 32 Slow burn
THE THREAT 60 Human and not
VISCERA 66 Explicit
ERA BIAS 88 Thoroughly modern
TONE 26 Bleak
REALITY ANCHOR 70 Dream logic
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Doctor Sleep: the review

The film with the least promising job in modern horror — sequel to a Kubrick adaptation its own author disowned — and it does the job far better than it had any right to.

Dan Torrance is an alcoholic in his forties who has spent his life sitting on the thing that happened to him. He gets off a bus in New Hampshire with nothing, is given a job and a room by a man who does not ask questions, goes to meetings, and finds work in a hospice easing people through the last hour. The patients call him Doctor Sleep. A cat picks the room.

Meanwhile the True Knot travel the interstates in RVs. They are not vampires in any form they would recognise, but they live by inhaling what Rose the Hat calls steam — the essence that comes off a shining child being tortured to death. They are old, polite, efficient, and running short, because the steam supply has been thinning for decades.

Abra Stone is eleven and can read a mind in Iowa from New Hampshire. When the Knot kill a boy in a field, she watches it happen, and Rose feels her watching.

Flanagan's reconciliation act

The film's real problem is that it must satisfy King's novel and Kubrick's film, which disagree about nearly everything including what the hotel is. Flanagan's solution is to treat the novel as the plot and the film as the geography, and then stage the last act inside a frame-for-frame reconstruction of the Overlook.

It should be a disaster and it is the best section in the picture. The recreations are exact, the actors playing Jack, Wendy, Lloyd and Grady are doing impressions and the film knows it, and the uncanniness of a near-match is used as a horror effect rather than hidden.

Ewan McGregor plays Dan as deliberately low-wattage, which is correct — this is a man managing himself. Rebecca Ferguson's Rose is the film's engine: charming, in a hat, entirely without cruelty as a motive and entirely without limit as a practice. Kyliegh Curran is excellent.

Where it frustrates

It is two and a half hours and feels it. The middle hour services a large cast of Knot members who exist to be killed in a sequence each.

The Baseball Boy scene is the most effective thing in the film and sits oddly inside it — a sustained, unsparing child murder in a film that is otherwise rather gentle about its violence. It is the right scene for establishing the stakes and it recalibrates what you think you are watching, not entirely to the film's benefit.

The ending of Doctor Sleep explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

What happens at the end of Doctor Sleep?

Abra offers herself as bait, and Dan brings Rose to the one place he has spent his life avoiding. They drive to the Overlook, which has been shut and rotting for decades, and Dan walks it room by room turning the lights and the boiler back on — which is to say, waking it up.

Rose arrives. The fight is uneven until the hotel's own dead join in: the ghosts the Overlook has accumulated, starved for forty years, take Rose apart. She dies on the lobby floor having been fed on by the thing she came to feed at.

Then the hotel turns to Dan. It offers him his father's face and a drink, takes him over, and sends him after Abra with an axe. Abra reaches the part of him that is still there, he gets control back for long enough to tell her to run, and he lets the overstoked boiler do what it has been building toward all along. The Overlook burns with him in it.

Afterwards, Abra sees Dan's ghost, who tells her she has the shine and the responsibility. One of the Overlook's dead follows her home; she finds it in her bathroom, and puts it in a lockbox in her head the way Dick Hallorann taught Dan to.

How is Rose the Hat defeated?

By being brought somewhere with more appetite than she has. Rose is unbeatable on the terms she sets — she can enter a mind, she can travel without a body, and she has decades of steam in her. What she cannot do is be hungrier than a building that has been eating people since before she was born.

Dan does not kill her. He opens a door, turns on the lights, and lets the Overlook recognise a meal. It is the first thing in either film that uses the hotel as a weapon rather than as a trap.

Why does Dan die at the end of Doctor Sleep?

Because the hotel gets him, and because the only reliable way to close it is from the inside.

The Overlook possesses him — the film gives him Jack's phrasing and Jack's walk — and he is not strong enough to simply shrug it off. What he can do is hold the boiler decision as his own: he has been building its pressure since he arrived, and letting it go is the one act the hotel cannot stop him completing. He burns the building down with himself inside it, which is also the ending King wrote for the Overlook in the novel of The Shining and which Kubrick replaced with a hedge maze.

Is Doctor Sleep a sequel to the book or the film?

Both, deliberately. The plot is King's novel almost beat for beat — the Knot, the steam, Abra, the hospice, the baseball boy. The world is Kubrick's: the Overlook as Kubrick built it, the blood lift, Room 237, the twins, the bathroom.

Flanagan also gives King the ending Kubrick took away, which is the film's neatest act of diplomacy. The Shining and the novel are both on this shelf and they are not the same work; this film is the only thing that treats that as a feature.

What is the shine in Doctor Sleep?

The novel's term for the psychic faculty Dick Hallorann names in The Shining — telepathy, precognition, remote viewing, the ability to see the dead and to be seen by them. It is a spectrum, it runs in families, and it is strongest in children, which is exactly why the Knot hunt them.

The film is clear that it is not a power so much as an exposure. Dan drank for twenty years to turn it down. Abra has more of it than he ever did and no idea yet what it will cost her.

If Doctor Sleep is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Doctor Sleep in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

More lists like these: Movies like Midsommar · Books like Mexican Gothic

Questions about Doctor Sleep

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

What happens at the end of Doctor Sleep?

Dan lures Rose the Hat to the Overlook and wakes the hotel. Its starved ghosts destroy her. The hotel then possesses Dan, who regains control long enough to send Abra away and let the overstoked boiler explode, burning the Overlook down with himself inside it.

How is Rose the Hat defeated in Doctor Sleep?

By being taken somewhere hungrier than she is. Dan cannot beat her on her terms, so he opens the Overlook, turns the lights on and lets the building recognise a meal. Its accumulated dead, starved for forty years, take her apart on the lobby floor.

Why does Dan Torrance die in Doctor Sleep?

The hotel possesses him and he is not strong enough to throw it off. What he can still do is release the boiler pressure he has been building since he arrived, which destroys the Overlook from inside. It is the ending King wrote for the hotel and Kubrick replaced with the hedge maze.

Is Doctor Sleep a sequel to the book or the Kubrick film?

Both at once. The plot follows King's novel closely — the True Knot, steam, Abra, the hospice — while the world is Kubrick's, right down to a frame-accurate Overlook. It also restores the burning ending Kubrick dropped, which is its neatest piece of diplomacy.

What is the shine in Doctor Sleep?

The psychic faculty Dick Hallorann names in The Shining: telepathy, precognition, remote viewing and seeing the dead. It runs in families, it is strongest in children, and it is why the True Knot hunt them. The film treats it as an exposure rather than a power.

How gory is Doctor Sleep?

More than its reputation suggests. We score it 066 on viscera, above the midpoint of the index, almost entirely on the strength of one prolonged sequence in which the True Knot kill a child in a field.

These are ranked against Doctor Sleep, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy