Film · 2022
Men
Alex Garland
Every man in the village wears the same face, and the last reel explains why.
71Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceSlow burn22
- ThreatHuman and not48
- GoreExplicit78
- ToneNo relief at all14
- RealityDream logic78
Era bias 92 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The bleakest horror movies ever made →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Men (2022) is most extreme on the tone axis: 14 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 26% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
Men is a 2022 British film written and directed by Alex Garland, in which a widow takes a fortnight in a Cotswolds manor house and finds that every man in the village has the same face. We score it 078 on viscera — 256 works in an index of 320 score lower — and 078 on reality anchor, which is unusually far toward surreal for a film that begins as a grief drama.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Men, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
Viscera 078 is high and almost all of it is in one sequence — 256 works score lower. The body horror of the final act is prosthetic, sustained and explicitly obstetric.
Reality anchor 078 is well toward surreal, with 274 works more grounded. The film starts in a rental cottage and ends somewhere that cannot be mapped.
Threat 048 sits almost exactly at the midpoint. This is deliberate on our part: the antagonist has a human face, several of them, and a provenance that is not human at all.
Tone 014 is bleak — 84 works score lower. There is a survivor, and no relief.
Pace 022 is deep in dread, with 48 works slower. Long walks, long takes, a tunnel.
On jump scares: very few. One figure-in-the-dark reveal and otherwise an accumulation.
Who should skip Men
Skip it if literal-minded climaxes irritate you. The last reel explains itself at length and in flesh, and no amount of goodwill makes it subtle.
Skip it if graphic birth imagery is a problem. It is extended and it is the point.
Watch it for Buckley and Kinnear, for the tunnel sequence, and for an hour of English pastoral horror as good as anything on this shelf. If the folk apparatus is what you want and you would rather it be pointed at a community, The Wicker Man remains the measure; The Witch is the better film about a woman and a landscape that wants something.
Men on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Men looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Where that puts it: joint #5 modern
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Men: the review
A film that works beautifully for an hour and then makes a decision, and what you think of the decision is what you think of the film.
Harper Marlowe rents Cotson, a red-brick manor with a Sheela na gig over the door and a landlord who cannot stop telling her things. Her husband James is dead. The circumstances arrive in fragments: a divorce she asked for, a threat he made about what he would do if she left, and a fall past a window with his eyes meeting hers on the way down. Whether it was suicide staged to punish her or a slip after a threat is a question the film refuses, correctly, to settle.
The first hour is the best work Garland has done with an actor. Jessie Buckley plays grief as exhausted practicality — she wants a nice fortnight, an apple from the garden, a walk. Rory Kinnear plays everyone else: the landlord, a vicar, a policeman, a boy in a mask, a man in a pub, and a naked figure who walks out of a railway tunnel and starts following her home.
The device is the argument
Casting one actor as every man in the village is a blunt instrument and the film knows it. What saves it from being a slogan is that Kinnear plays each one as a genuinely distinct person, so the effect is not "all men are the same man" but something more precise and more uncomfortable: the same demand arriving in a different costume each time, and Harper having to be polite to it on each occasion.
The vicar's scene is where this lands hardest. He is the one who listens, and then asks whether she gave her husband the chance to apologise, and suggests the fall might be something she did.
Formally the film is in good order too. The tunnel echo sequence is a near-perfect horror set piece built out of a woman singing to herself, and Rob Hardy's photography makes the English countryside look fecund in a way that gets unpleasant well before anything happens.
Where it frustrates
The last twenty minutes replace argument with imagery, and the imagery is literal. The film has been working by suggestion and then spends its climax spelling the thesis out in a sequence that cannot be read any other way.
Harper is also written thinly on purpose, which is defensible and still costs the film: she is a person things are done to, and the film's interest in her stops at what she survives.
The ending of Men explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
What happens at the end of Men?
The green man breaks into the house and Harper fights him off, injuring his arm and hand. He then gives birth — to the boy, who gives birth to the vicar, who gives birth to Geoffrey the landlord, who gives birth to James, her husband, each one carrying the same wound through the chain. Harper sits with him and asks what he wants. He says he wants her love. In the morning, her friend Riley arrives at the house, visibly pregnant, and finds Harper sitting in the garden, unharmed and holding an axe.
What does the birth sequence mean?
It makes the film's thesis literal: these are not separate men but one demand reproducing itself in new bodies, generation after generation, each arriving injured by the last and asking for the same thing.
It also answers the question of lineage the film has been raising since the church. The Green Man and the Sheela na gig carved there are a pair of very old English images — male foliate head, female figure displaying herself — and the film has been pointing at them as the origin of the chain it finally shows being made.
Harper's reaction matters as much as the event. She is not screaming. She watches, waits, and asks the last one a direct question.
What does James mean when he says he wants her love?
It is the film's last turn of the screw and it is deliberately pathetic. After a night of pursuit, exposure, breaking and entering and a monstrous genealogy, the demand underneath is small and domestic. He does not want her dead. He wants to be owed something.
That is why the question Harper asks is the right one, and why the film's violence ends at the moment it is answered.
Why is Riley pregnant at the end?
The film does not explain it and the most useful reading is the simplest: the cycle it has just shown you is not confined to Cotson, and Harper's ordeal does not end it. Riley arriving pregnant into a garden full of what Harper survived is the film restating the chain one more time with a different woman at the start of it.
A more generous reading is that Riley's arrival is simply rescue, and the pregnancy is incidental. The film is not interested in helping you choose.
Is Men a folk horror film?
Partly. It uses the apparatus — the village, the church carvings, the green man, the outsider in an unfamiliar landscape — but it points them at a domestic subject rather than at a community's secret. There is no cult here and no ritual. The old English imagery is being used to date the behaviour rather than to explain it.
If Men is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Men in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
The Wailing
Na Hong-Jin · 2016 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
88% shared signal
In the Tall Grass
Vincenzo Natali · 2019 · Film
Shares dream logic.
87% shared signal
Doctor Sleep
Mike Flanagan · 2019 · Film
Shares slow-burn dread.
86% shared signal
Longlegs
Osgood Perkins · 2024 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
83% shared signal

The Cipher
Kathe Koja · 1991 · Book
Shares explicit viscera.
92% shared signal

The Croning
Laird Barron · 2012 · Book
Shares dream logic.
85% shared signal
Khanate
Khanate · 2001 · Record
Shares slow-burn dread.
85% shared signal

The Hellbound Heart
Clive Barker · 1986 · Book
Shares explicit viscera.
83% shared signal
Questions about Men
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
Why does one actor play every man in Men?
Rory Kinnear plays the landlord, vicar, policeman, boy and the green man as distinct people with one face. The effect is not that all men are identical but that the same demand keeps arriving in a new costume, and Harper has to be civil to it every time.
What happens at the end of Men?
The green man gives birth to the boy, who births the vicar, who births the landlord, who births James, Harper's dead husband — each carrying the same wound. Harper asks what he wants and he says her love. Her friend Riley arrives the next morning, pregnant.
What does the birth sequence in Men mean?
It literalises the film's argument: these are not separate men but one demand reproducing itself down a line. It also pays off the church carvings — the Green Man and the Sheela na gig — which the film has been using to date the behaviour rather than explain it.
Did James kill himself in Men?
The film declines to say. He threatened suicide if Harper left, she asked for a divorce anyway, and he fell past her window with his eyes on hers. Whether he jumped or slipped after climbing is left open, and Harper's guilt does not depend on the answer.
Why is Riley pregnant at the end of Men?
The film offers no explanation. The straightforward reading is that the cycle Harper has just witnessed is not local to that house and does not end with her. A more generous reading treats Riley's arrival as rescue and the pregnancy as incidental.
Is Men a folk horror film?
It borrows the apparatus — village, church carvings, green man, outsider in a strange landscape — but points it at a domestic subject. There is no cult and no ritual. We score it 078 on reality anchor, well toward surreal, which is unusual for the folk shelf.
These are ranked against Men, not against you.
Build your own tape →