Film · 2024
Longlegs
Ten families, ten fathers who did it themselves, and a doll in every house.
68Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceSlow burn30
- ThreatHuman and not58
- GoreShows some of it58
- ToneNo relief at all10
- RealityTilts unreal62
Era bias 74 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The bleakest horror movies ever made →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Longlegs (2024) is most extreme on the tone axis: 10 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 12% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
Longlegs is a 2024 horror film written and directed by Osgood Perkins. An FBI agent with intermittent second sight is put on a decades-old case: families destroyed by the father, no forced entry, and a coded letter left behind each time. We score it 010 on tone and 074 on era bias, which is low for its year and the point of how it was shot. The marketing promised the scariest film in years and the film is quieter and stranger than that.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Longlegs, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.
Tone 010 is near the floor of the index. 40 works score lower. Nine families are destroyed by their own fathers, the one decent character's family is destroyed because he was kind, and the film's last act asks its protagonist to shoot her mother.
Era bias 074 is middling, which is low for 2024 and deliberate. 134 works score higher. Perkins shoots a 1990s setting on film, in squared-off ratios, with a pale grade and no digital gloss anywhere — the image is doing period rather than performing it, and we score the texture a work has.
Viscera 058 is moderate and almost all of it is aftermath. 147 works score higher. Crime-scene photographs, a head, a suicide in custody. The film prefers the room after the event.
The threat at 058 sits just past the midpoint, and the split is the plot. 112 works score higher. Every murder is committed by a father and the thing that makes him do it is not human. Longlegs is a man; the sphere is not; the axis refuses to go to either end.
Pace 030 is dread. 232 works are faster. Long centred compositions held past comfort, a handful of sudden cuts, and no chase at all until the final twenty minutes.
Reality anchor 062 is a shade surreal. Field offices, farmhouses, a basement — all solid — with an object that works by no stated rule.
On jump scares: three or four, and the frightening scenes are the ones with nothing in them.
Who should skip Longlegs
Skip it if the marketing brought you. This is a slow, formal, extremely quiet film for an hour. It was sold as the most frightening thing in years and it is not trying to be that.
Skip it if an explained mechanism will spoil it. The last half hour states how the dolls work and then stages a chase, and the film's power up to that point was in not knowing.
Skip it if a psychic-detective device annoys you. Lee's second sight advances the investigation whenever the plot needs it to, which is the oldest problem with this kind of protagonist.
Content notes: the murder of entire families including children by their fathers, suicide, a coerced parent, child endangerment, crime-scene imagery, and a satanic bargain involving a child.
Watch it if you want the best-photographed horror film of its year, Nicolas Cage rationed properly, and an hour of a procedural that keeps putting the thing you should be looking at at the edge of the frame.
Longlegs on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Longlegs looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Longlegs: the review
A procedural shot like a memory
The first hour is the best thing Perkins has made. The film opens in a pale, squared-off aspect ratio on a farmhouse in the 1970s, and then spends its present-day scenes in long, centred, slightly-too-wide compositions with the top of the frame full of empty wall. It looks like a case file somebody left in the sun. Andrés Arochi's photography and Perkins' blocking do something genuinely unusual: they put the horror in the parts of the frame you were not looking at and then decline to move the camera to help you.
Maika Monroe plays Lee Harker almost entirely in stillness. She is written as somebody with a partial gift she has never discussed with anybody, which Monroe plays as social absence rather than as mystery — she is not being enigmatic, she is elsewhere — and it is a considerably harder performance than it looks.
Cage
The performance everybody argues about, and the film is right to ration it. Longlegs is on screen for a small fraction of the running time, mostly in close-up, mostly in fragments, and Cage plays him as a man wearing a face he had made: high, wheedling, girlish, singing. It should not work beside the restraint of everything else. It works because Perkins keeps him out of focus and off centre until he cannot.
The worst scene in the film is also the best: a man in a shop, in daylight, talking to somebody he has no business talking to, and the editing refusing to give you the reverse angle.
Then it explains
The last half hour is where the arguments start, and I think the complaints are fair. The mechanism is a doll with a sphere inside it, placed in a house, which compels the father. Once that is stated the film stops being about an atmosphere and becomes about an object, and the final sequence resolves into a chase through a basement with a gun in it.
It is not a betrayal — the dolls are seeded from the first scene and the mother's role is properly built — but the film's power was in not knowing, and the film gives that up to deliver a plot.
Where it strains
Beyond the explanation: the second-sight device is used whenever the screenplay needs a jump in the investigation, which is the oldest problem with psychic detectives. Agent Carter is a function. The religious material is gestured at rather than built — there is a Man Downstairs and a bargain and very little theology holding them up. And the score pushes hard in a film that is otherwise confident in silence.
Watch it for the first hour, the photography and ten minutes of Cage. It is not the scariest film in a decade and it is one of the best-looking.
The ending of Longlegs explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: the dolls do it. Longlegs builds a doll in the likeness of a daughter with a metal sphere inside its head, and once it is in the house the father kills his family and himself. The deliveries were made for decades by Ruth Harker, Lee's mother, who struck a bargain to spare her own daughter on Lee's ninth birthday. Longlegs is arrested and kills himself in custody. Ruth then destroys Agent Carter's family and leaves a doll for his daughter Ruby. Lee reaches the house, shoots her mother, and the film ends in that room with the child and the doll rather than with an outcome.
Here is how the film gets there.
How do the dolls work?
Each doll is made in the likeness of a daughter of the family, with a metal sphere concealed in its head. Placed inside the house, it is what turns the father: every killing in the case file is the father's own hand, there is never any forced entry, and the murders cluster around a child's ninth birthday. The film supplies the mechanism and declines to supply a cosmology for it beyond a bargain and a figure called the Man Downstairs.
What is Lee's mother's role?
Ruth Harker is the delivery. She has been placing the dolls for decades, as a nurse with a reason to be in people's houses, under an arrangement made on Lee's ninth birthday — Longlegs came to their farmhouse, and Ruth traded her participation for her daughter's life. The film's first scene is that visit, which is why it is in a different aspect ratio and why Lee does not remember it properly.
Who is Longlegs?
Dale Ferdinand Kobble, a man with a surgically altered face and a glam-rock presentation, who makes the dolls and writes the coded letters. The film gives him no origin and no explanation. He is arrested in the third act and kills himself in custody in front of the agents, which removes the possibility of interrogation and is the correct structural choice.
What happens to Agent Carter?
Ruth gets into his home, kills him and his wife, and leaves a doll for his daughter Ruby. It is the film's cruellest move: Carter is the only character who has been straightforwardly kind to Lee, and his family is destroyed specifically because of her proximity to the case.
How does the film end?
Lee arrives at the Carter house, finds what her mother has done, and shoots her. What is left is a room with a child and a doll in it, and Perkins ends the film there rather than on a resolution — no destruction of the object, no rescue shown, no confirmation that the thing is finished. The withholding is deliberate and it is the last confident decision in a final act that had been explaining itself.
Is the Man Downstairs the devil?
That is the implication and the film will not say it plainly. There is a bargain, a presence beneath the house in the first scene, and a satanic register around Longlegs. Readers who want the theology filled in will not get it, and the thinness there is the most common criticism of the film after the exposition.
If Longlegs is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Longlegs in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
The Killing of a Sacred Deer
Yorgos Lanthimos · 2017 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
89% shared signal
Doctor Sleep
Mike Flanagan · 2019 · Film
Shares slow-burn dread.
88% shared signal
The Wailing
Na Hong-Jin · 2016 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
87% shared signal

The Shining
Stephen King · 1977 · Book
Shares slow-burn dread.
90% shared signal

Mexican Gothic
Silvia Moreno-Garcia · 2020 · Book
89% shared signal

The Ballad of Black Tom
Victor LaValle · 2016 · Book
89% shared signal

Midnight Mass
Mike Flanagan · 2021 · Television
88% shared signal
The Walten Files
Martin Walls · 2020 · Web series
88% shared signal
More lists like these: Books like Mexican Gothic · Shows like Midnight Mass
Questions about Longlegs
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
How does Longlegs end?
Ruth Harker destroys Agent Carter's family and leaves a doll for his daughter. Lee arrives, finds it and shoots her mother. The film ends in that room with the child and the doll, with no rescue shown and no confirmation that the thing is over — Perkins withholds the outcome deliberately.
How do the dolls in Longlegs work?
Each is made in the likeness of a daughter of the family, with a metal sphere hidden in its head. Once it is inside the house the father kills his family and himself, which is why there is never any forced entry and why the murders cluster around a ninth birthday.
What did Lee's mother do in Longlegs?
Ruth Harker delivered the dolls for decades, using her work as a nurse to get into houses. She made the arrangement on Lee's ninth birthday, when Longlegs came to their farmhouse, and traded her participation for her daughter's life. The film's first scene is that visit.
Who is Longlegs?
Dale Ferdinand Kobble, a man with a surgically altered face who makes the dolls and writes the coded letters. The film gives him no origin at all, and he kills himself in custody in the third act, which removes any possibility of him explaining himself.
Is Longlegs actually scary?
Quietly, and not in the way it was sold. We score it 030 on pace and 058 on viscera: the method is a long centred composition with something at the edge of it, not a sequence of shocks. Viewers who arrive expecting the scariest film in years generally report being let down.
What is the Man Downstairs?
The presence behind the bargain, implied to be the devil and never named as such. There is a figure beneath the farmhouse in the first scene and a satanic register around Longlegs, and the film declines to build any theology on top of it — the thinness there is the other complaint this film reliably attracts.
What should I watch after Longlegs?
The Monkey for the other side of Perkins, Sinister for the same case-file structure played for shocks, and occult horror for everything here with a bargain in it.
These are ranked against Longlegs, not against you.
Build your own tape →