VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

THEMENU F-1804 · 2022 · FILM

Film · 2022

The Menu

Mark Mylod

A tasting menu on a private island, served by a man who has planned every course including the last.

48Strong to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PaceBuilds, then strikes46
  • ThreatPeople, entirely94
  • GoreShows some of it50
  • ToneGrim, with air52
  • RealityGrounded16

Era bias 93 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

Horror movies where the monster is a person →

BLACK COMEDYSIEGESATIRE
Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, The Menu (2022) is most extreme on the threat axis: 94 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 93% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

The Menu is a 2022 American film directed by Mark Mylod, in which twelve guests travel to a private island for a tasting menu that is designed to kill all of them. We score it 094 on the threat axis — only 16 works in an index of 320 score higher — and 016 on reality anchor, because every death in it is catering.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is The Menu, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.

Threat 094 is far toward the human end — 16 works score higher and 6 tie it. Every death is planned, catered and staffed.

Reality anchor 016 is near the grounded end, with 298 works above it. Nothing happens that a sufficiently funded kitchen could not do.

Tone 052 is just past the midpoint into gleeful — 40 works score higher. The film is very funny and the jokes do not blunt the deaths.

Pace 046 sits a little short of the midpoint. The course structure paces it for you, and the shocks arrive on schedule rather than in ambush.

Viscera 050 is at the middle. A severed finger, a self-inflicted gunshot and a burning room, none of it dwelt on.

On jump scares: one, the sous chef. The rest of the violence is announced before it arrives.

Who should skip The Menu

The Menu on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what The Menu looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 46 Builds, then strikes
THE THREAT 94 People, entirely
VISCERA 50 Shows some of it
ERA BIAS 93 Thoroughly modern
TONE 52 Grim, with air
REALITY ANCHOR 16 Grounded

Where that puts it: #4 modern · joint #14 human monsters · joint #15 grounded

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

The Menu: the review

A siege film in which the siege is a prix fixe, and the only person who gets out is the one who asks what she is actually being served.

Hawthorne occupies an island owned by its investors and run by Chef Julian Slowik, who has twelve guests, a brigade who answer him in unison, and a menu that is going to end with everybody dead. The guests are a tech trio whose company funds the place, a fading film star and his assistant, a married couple who have eaten here eleven times without remembering a single course, a food critic and her editor, and Tyler — a devotee who has brought a date.

The date is Margot, and she is the film's engine because she is the only person on the island who was not invited.

Fiennes is the reason it works

Ralph Fiennes plays Slowik as a man whose contempt has become a management style. He claps once and the room stops. He introduces each course with a paragraph that is half artist's statement and half indictment, and the film's best running joke is that the guests keep hearing the indictment as the statement.

The courses are the structure and the escalation. A breadless bread plate, served with the explanation that bread is the food of the poor and these are not poor people. An "accompaniment" of tortillas laser-printed with the guests' own documented crimes. A dish served after the sous chef shoots himself at the station, which the room attempts to treat as performance.

Mylod shoots all of it like television food coverage — clean overheads of plating, white-on-black title cards announcing each course — so that the register never breaks even as the body count starts. It is funny in the way Ready or Not is funny: the comedy is in the characters' refusal to update, and the violence is not softened by it.

Anya Taylor-Joy gives Margot the one thing the script needs and nothing else in the film has: an exit. Nicholas Hoult's Tyler is the cruellest piece of writing here, a man who knew everyone would die, came anyway, and brought a stranger so the numbers would work.

Where it frustrates

The satire is wide. The tech bros are tech bros, the critic is a critic, and the film rarely finds a target that is not already on the floor.

The middle hour leans on the premise doing the work. Once you have understood that each course is a thesis, several of the courses are only a thesis, and the film's energy dips until Margot is sent to the cottage.

The ending of The Menu explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

What happens at the end of The Menu?

Slowik gives Margot a choice: she can die with the guests, or she can be staff. She asks him what he would have cooked before any of this — and he says a cheeseburger.

So she orders one. He makes it on a flat-top with real attention, the first thing in the film he appears to enjoy, and she eats a bite, says it is exactly what she wanted, and asks for the rest to go. He boxes it. She pays $9.95, takes the bag, and walks down to the dock.

Everybody else is served dessert. The brigade and the guests are dressed in marshmallow, chocolate and graham, the dining room is set alight, and the restaurant burns with its staff and its customers inside it. Margot watches from the boat and eats the burger.

Why does Margot survive The Menu?

Because she is the only person on the island who works for a living, and Slowik's entire grievance is with people who consume without cost.

The film establishes it carefully. Margot is an escort; Tyler paid for her. Slowik recognises her almost immediately as not belonging to the guest list, and the recognition is a problem for him, because his menu requires a clean division between those who gave and those who took. She does not fit either column.

What finally earns her the boat is not pity. It is that she asks him a question nobody else has asked — what did he cook before the island — and the answer reminds him of the one period of his career when the work was simply feeding people. He cannot kill the one guest who wants his food rather than his reputation.

What does the cheeseburger mean?

It is the film's whole argument on a plate. Everything on Hawthorne's menu is a statement about the people eating it. The cheeseburger is food.

Slowik has spent years making work that can only be received as a credential, for an audience that cannot taste it and would not know the difference. Cooking one burger for one hungry person is the thing he stopped being able to do, and the reason Margot asks for it to go is that the request has to leave the island to mean anything.

Is The Menu a horror film or a comedy?

Both, and it keeps the horror load-bearing. Twelve people die on screen, one sous chef shoots himself at his station, Tyler hangs himself in the walk-in after being made to cook, and the dessert course is a mass immolation. None of it is undercut in the moment.

That is the same arrangement as Braindead — a horror film with jokes in it, rather than a comedy that has borrowed a knife. What it satirises is class and taste, in the way Get Out satirises liberal self-regard, and like that film it does its satire with the genre's real machinery.

What does Tyler know in The Menu?

Everything. Tyler had been in correspondence with Slowik, knew the menu's final course, knew the guests were going to die, and still paid for a seat and brought a woman with him.

When Slowik makes him put on a jacket and cook — "Tyler's Bullshit", plated and labelled — the humiliation is the only act of criticism in the film that actually lands on its target. He goes into the walk-in afterward and does not come out.

If The Menu is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to The Menu in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

More lists like these: Movies like Get Out

Questions about The Menu

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

Why does Margot survive in The Menu?

Because she works for a living and Slowik's grievance is with people who consume without cost. She was not on the guest list, she asks him what he cooked before the island, and she wants his food rather than his reputation. He cannot fit her into either column of his menu.

What does the cheeseburger mean in The Menu?

It is the film's argument on a plate. Every other course is a statement about the people eating it; the burger is simply food. It is the thing Slowik cooked before his work became a credential, and Margot asks for it to go so the request leaves the island.

What happens at the end of The Menu?

Margot chooses to be staff rather than a guest, orders a cheeseburger, pays $9.95 and takes it to go. The remaining guests and the entire brigade are dressed as s'mores and the dining room is set alight. She watches Hawthorne burn from the boat.

Did Tyler know everyone would die in The Menu?

Yes. He had corresponded with Slowik, knew the final course and knew the guests were not leaving, and he bought a seat anyway and brought Margot to fill a place. Slowik makes him cook, humiliates him publicly, and Tyler hangs himself in the walk-in.

Is The Menu a horror movie?

It is a horror comedy, and the horror carries the weight. Twelve guests and the whole kitchen die, there are two suicides on screen, and none of it is softened by the jokes. We score it 094 on the threat axis and 052 on tone.

How scary is The Menu?

Not very, by this index's measure — we score it 046 on pace, short of the midpoint, with one real jump scare. The dread is structural: you know from the second course that nobody is leaving, and the film makes you wait through nine more.

These are ranked against The Menu, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy