Film · 2024
Maxxxine
1985, the Night Stalker on every front page, and somebody from her old life has found her.
66Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceBuilds, then strikes50
- ThreatPeople, entirely94
- GoreExplicit70
- ToneBleak30
- RealityGrounded20
Era bias 74 · Modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
Horror movies where the monster is a person →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Maxxxine (2024) is most extreme on the threat axis: 94 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 93% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
MaXXXine is a 2024 horror film by Ti West, closing the trilogy that began with X and Pearl. Maxine is in 1985 Los Angeles, trying to cross from adult film into a studio picture, and somebody from her old life has found her. We score it 094 on the threat axis, the same as both predecessors, and 070 on viscera, the lowest of the three. It is the weakest of them and the only one that lets its protagonist win.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Maxxxine, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.
The threat at 094 is human, and all three films in the trilogy score exactly that. 16 works score higher. Not one of them reaches for anything supernatural. The antagonist here is a father with a television ministry and a van.
Tone 030 is level with Pearl and two points under X. 194 works score lower. All three sit well below the midpoint; this is the only one of them in which the protagonist gets what she was after.
Viscera 070 is high and the lowest of the three. 98 works score higher. A head wound in close-up, a crushing, several bodies and a staged crucifixion — against 082 for X and 076 for Pearl.
Pace 050 sits on the midpoint. An hour of Hollywood procedural and then a chase through a backlot. The two halves are different films.
Reality anchor 020 is grounded. 29 works score lower. 1985 Los Angeles, a studio lot, a motel, a police investigation. Nothing in it breaks a physical rule.
Era bias 074 is modern with an eighties grade on it. Glossy digital pastiche — neon, synth, Steadicam — rather than period texture, which is why it scores above both of its predecessors despite being set latest.
On jump scares: a handful, and the film is not really trying to frighten you.
Who should skip Maxxxine
Skip it if you have not seen the other two. The reveal depends on Texas and the ending depends on Pearl. It is the only film in the trilogy that does not work alone.
Skip it if the Night Stalker material will sit badly. Real murders from 1985 are used as background texture so that a fictional killer's work goes unnoticed, and the film has nothing to say about them.
Skip it if you want the trilogy's register. This is a thriller with a comic private detective and a monologuing villain, not the slasher X was or the tragedy Pearl was.
Content notes: murder of sex workers, a parent's religiously motivated violence against their child, a staged crucifixion, sexual coercion in the adult film industry, and the use of a real serial murder case as plot furniture.
Watch it if you have seen X and Pearl and want the arc closed, Mia Goth playing the same appetite a third way, and Kevin Bacon enjoying himself more than anybody else in the film.
Maxxxine on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Maxxxine looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Where that puts it: joint #14 human monsters
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Maxxxine: the review
A pastiche that is having a very good time
West's method across this trilogy has been to make each film in the idiom of the era it depicts, and here that means mid-eighties Hollywood: neon, video stores, Steadicam through studio backlots, a synth score, a private detective in a white suit. Eliot Rockett shoots it glossier than either predecessor, and the film is openly in conversation with Body Double and the giallo end of De Palma.
It is enormous fun for about an hour. The audition scenes are sharp about what the industry was and is, the Hollywood Boulevard material has real texture, and Elizabeth Debicki's director — a woman making a sequel to a film nobody respected and insisting on her own seriousness — is the best-written character in the picture.
Mia Goth is still the reason
Maxine in 1985 is a different performance from Maxine in 1979, and Goth plays the change precisely: the ambition has hardened into something colder and considerably more frightening. The line about not accepting a life she does not deserve has been her thesis across three films, and by this one she means it in a way that has stopped being sympathetic.
Kevin Bacon's John Labat is the other pleasure — a sweating Louisiana private detective working an angle, played at exactly the pitch the film is written in. Their scenes together are the best in it.
Where it strains, which is most of the back half
The reveal is the problem. The first two films built their horror out of a single, perfectly chosen idea — that the thing Maxine is running toward is what made Pearl — and this one replaces that with a plot. Once the killer's identity is stated the film becomes a chase through a backlot, and the trilogy's argument stops being about desire and becomes about a specific man's motive.
The Night Stalker is a structural device and it does not earn its presence. Real murders from 1985 are used as background texture to make a fictional killer's work less conspicuous, and the film takes nothing from it and gives it nothing. It is the one choice here that is genuinely in poor taste rather than knowingly tasteless.
There is also a tonal mismatch the pastiche cannot absorb. X was a slasher that meant it and Pearl was a tragedy; this is a thriller with a comic private detective and a villain who monologues, and the trilogy's accumulated weight does not fit inside it.
Watch it if you have seen the other two. Do not start here.
The ending of Maxxxine explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: the killer is Maxine's father, Ernest Miller, a televangelist who has been looking for her since she ran away, and who has murdered her friends to clear a path to her. He abducts her to a set dressed as the Bates house on the studio backlot, intending to film her repentance and televise it. She shoots him in the head. The police clear her, the news carries the Night Stalker's arrest, and the film ends with Maxine watching her name on the screen at her first studio premiere. She is the only person in the trilogy who gets what she wanted.
Here is how it resolves.
Who is the killer in MaXXXine?
Ernest Miller, her father, a preacher with a television ministry. He has been tracking her for six years, and the murders of Tabby, Leon and the others were committed to isolate her and to build the case that she is damned and in need of saving. His motive is not sexual and not financial; he wants a confession, on camera, as the centrepiece of his own ministry.
What is the Night Stalker doing in this film?
Providing cover. Los Angeles in 1985 had a serial murderer on every front page, which means a second killer's work is attributed to the first and nobody looks closely. That is the structural function and it is the whole of it — the film never engages with the real case and the real victims are wallpaper. It is the trilogy's worst decision.
How does the trilogy connect?
Pearl wanted to be looked at and was not allowed to be, and killed everybody who stood between her and that; X is Maxine arriving at Pearl's farmhouse sixty years later with exactly the same want and surviving the collision; MaXXXine is Maxine getting the thing both women wanted. Goth plays Pearl and Maxine, which is the trilogy's central claim: they are the same appetite in two bodies, and only one of them was born in a decade that would pay for it.
What does the ending mean for Maxine?
She wins and the film does not flinch from what that cost. Everybody who helped her is dead, she killed her own father, and the last shot is her face lit by her own name on a cinema screen. The trilogy ends on an ambition fulfilled, which after two films about the punishment of wanting things is a genuinely strange note and the most interesting thing this film does.
Is there anything after the credits?
No. The trilogy closes here, and West has been clear that the arc is finished. The film ends on the premiere.
Do you need to see X and Pearl first?
Yes. The reveal lands only if you know what Maxine survived in Texas, and the ending means nothing without Pearl. This is the one film in the three that does not stand alone, which is its biggest structural weakness.
If Maxxxine is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Maxxxine in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
Pearl
Ti West · 2022 · Film
Shares human monsters.
95% shared signal
Sleepaway Camp
Robert Hiltzik · 1983 · Film
Shares grounded realism.
94% shared signal
Halloween Ends
David Gordon Green · 2022 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
93% shared signal
Friday the 13th
Sean S. Cunningham · 1980 · Film
Shares human monsters.
92% shared signal
X
Ti West · 2022 · Film
Shares explicit viscera.
92% shared signal
Friday the 13th: A New Beginning
Danny Steinmann · 1985 · Film
Shares grounded realism.
91% shared signal
Friday the 13th Part 2
Steve Miner · 1981 · Film
Shares a bleak, unforgiving tone.
90% shared signal
Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter
Joseph Zito · 1984 · Film
Shares explicit viscera.
89% shared signal
Questions about Maxxxine
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
Who is the killer in MaXXXine?
Maxine's father, Ernest Miller, a televangelist who has been looking for her since she ran away from home. He murdered her friends to isolate her, and he abducts her to a set dressed as the Bates house intending to film her repentance for his ministry. She shoots him.
How does MaXXXine end?
She kills her father on the studio backlot, the police clear her, and the news carries the Night Stalker's arrest. The last scene is Maxine at her first studio premiere, watching her own name on the screen — the only person in the trilogy who gets what she wanted.
Why is the Night Stalker in MaXXXine?
As cover. With a serial murderer on every front page in Los Angeles in 1985, a second killer's work is attributed to the first and nobody looks closely. That is its entire function; the film never engages with the real case, which is its worst decision.
How does the X trilogy connect?
Pearl wanted to be looked at and killed everyone in the way; X is Maxine arriving at Pearl's farmhouse sixty years later with the same want and surviving it; MaXXXine is her getting it. Mia Goth plays both women, which is the trilogy's claim — one appetite, two bodies, different decades.
Do I need to watch X and Pearl before MaXXXine?
Yes. The reveal only lands if you know what happened in Texas and the ending is meaningless without Pearl. The other two stand alone and this one does not, which is its main structural problem.
Is MaXXXine the weakest of the trilogy?
In my view yes, and not because of the scores — they put it between its predecessors on pace and lowest of the three on viscera. It is the only one that replaces its horror with a plot: a villain with a stated motive where the first two had an idea.
What should I watch after MaXXXine?
X and Pearl if you somehow have not, everything else Ti West has made here, and slasher horror for the form X was working in.
These are ranked against Maxxxine, not against you.
Build your own tape →