VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

SMILE2 F-1501 · 2024 · FILM

Film · 2024

Smile 2

Parker Finn

A pop star on a comeback tour watches a man kill himself, and now it is her turn to pass it on.

85Punishing to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PaceJolts you often76
  • ThreatSomething not human14
  • GoreExplicit82
  • ToneNo relief at all10
  • RealityDream logic66

Era bias 90 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

The bleakest horror movies ever made →

Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Smile 2 (2024) is most extreme on the tone axis: 10 out of 100, where 0 is a bleak, unforgiving tone and 100 is gleeful black comedy. 12% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Smile 2 is a 2024 horror film written and directed by Parker Finn. A pop star on her comeback tour watches a man kill himself in front of her, and the thing that was watching him moves to her. We score it 076 on pace and 082 on viscera, both well above the first film, and the sequel is the better picture. It ends on the darkest note the series could have chosen and it earns it.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Smile 2, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.

Pace 076 is fast. 11 works are faster. The entity arrives in the first ten minutes and the film never gives Skye a quiet scene again. It is one of the most relentless things we hold from its decade.

Viscera 082 is high. 43 works score higher. A death by dumbbell in close-up, a self-inflicted injury in an apartment, and a final sequence of sustained facial body horror in front of an audience.

Tone 010 is near the floor. 40 works score lower. No survivor, no cost to the entity, and a last image designed to multiply the problem.

The threat at 014 is almost entirely inhuman. 28 works score lower. It wears human faces and it is not a person, and nobody in the film can be reasoned with on its behalf.

Reality anchor 066 is a shade surreal. Tour buses, arenas, green rooms and press junkets, all solid, around an entity whose rules the film states and then bends in the last act.

Era bias 090 is modern. 11 works score higher. Glossy digital, saturated stage lighting, long clean Steadicam. Nothing about the look is doing period.

On jump scares: a lot of them, and the best scares are the ones with a crowd standing still.

Who should skip Smile 2

Smile 2 on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Smile 2 looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 76 Jolts you often
THE THREAT 14 Something not human
VISCERA 82 Explicit
ERA BIAS 90 Thoroughly modern
TONE 10 No relief at all
REALITY ANCHOR 66 Dream logic

Where that puts it: joint #10 modern · joint #11 relentless

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Smile 2: the review

A sequel that found the right subject

The first Smile was a good film with a therapist at its centre, which meant the entity spent two hours working on somebody professionally trained to doubt her own perceptions. The sequel puts it inside a global pop tour, and that is a genuinely better idea. Skye Riley cannot be alone, cannot be unobserved, cannot stop working, and has a documented history of addiction and one widely reported car crash — so every symptom she develops has a ready-made explanation that everybody around her reaches for first.

Finn builds the whole film out of that. The horror is not that nobody believes her; it is that the disbelief is reasonable, and that her job requires her to keep performing through it. There is a sequence in a rehearsal studio where she has to complete a dance routine while something is wrong in the mirrors, and it is the best thing in either film.

Naomi Scott is carrying a lot

She has to be plausible as an arena-filling performer, which the film tests directly with full musical numbers, and simultaneously play somebody whose interior is coming apart on a schedule. The performance is at its best in the small administrative moments — being managed, being handled, being told what the schedule is — where you can see a person who has not been allowed to be unobserved in a decade.

The physical work is the rest of it. Finn shoots long unbroken takes that follow her through corridors and green rooms, and Scott plays escalating terror without the register ever tipping into the operatic until the film wants it to.

It is a much nastier film than the first

The viscera jumps twenty-four points and all of it is deliberate. The opening set piece with the dumbbell is the most shocking thing in the series and it arrives in the first ten minutes. The fan sequence in the apartment is the cruellest. And the finale is a sustained piece of body horror staged in front of twenty thousand people, which no studio sequel had any obligation to attempt.

Finn has also sharpened his method. The first film relied heavily on the smile as an image; this one understands that a crowd of smiling people is worse than one, and the corridor sequence with the neighbours is built on exactly that arithmetic.

Where it strains

Length, and one structural cheat. At two hours it has a middle act that circles — there are two separate scenes of Skye being disbelieved by her mother that could be one — and the film pads the tour material with more performance footage than the story needs.

The cheat is the hallucination. A film that spends its whole running time asking whether what Skye sees can be trusted has to be careful about resolving a long sequence as unreal, and Smile 2 does it late and does it big. It works on first viewing because of how it is staged. On a second pass the rules it broke to get there are visible.

Watch it for Scott, for the rehearsal studio, and because it is one of very few horror sequels that is better than the film it follows.

The ending of Smile 2 explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: Skye appears to break the curse. She finds Morris, who survived contact with the entity, is taken to a support group of other survivors, and is told how to sever it — a controlled death and resuscitation. It works, she is free, and she goes on stage at a sold-out arena. None of it happened. There was no group and no cure; she never left her apartment, and the entity built the entire sequence for her because hope is the last thing it needed to take. On stage, in front of twenty thousand people, it takes her body and pulls her face into the smile while the arena watches and films it.

Here is how it works.

How does the entity work?

It passes by witnessing. Someone infected kills themselves in front of a chosen person, and the entity moves to the witness, who has roughly a week. In between it wears the faces of people the host knows and trusts, and it feeds on trauma that is already there rather than inventing new material — which is why Skye's dead boyfriend and her addiction are the levers it uses, and why everyone around her has a non-supernatural explanation ready.

What was the support group?

Nothing. Morris, the other survivors, the room, the method, the resuscitation and the recovery were all constructed. The tell the film plants is that the cure arrives exactly when Skye has run out of options and is offered on terms she wants to accept. The entity's method throughout both films is to use what the host already believes, and by that point what Skye believed was that there had to be a way out.

Why does it take her on stage?

Because that is the most transmission it can buy with one death. The entity needs witnesses, and the finale puts it in front of a full arena with every phone in the room recording. The first film ended with one person watching. This one ends with twenty thousand in the building and an unknown number watching the footage afterwards, which is the series escalating in the only direction that actually means anything.

Is that the bleakest possible ending?

Close to it, and the film does not blink. There is no survivor, no cost imposed on the entity, and no limit established on how far it has now spread. It is also the ending the premise demanded: a curse that travels by being seen, let loose in front of an audience that exists to look.

What happens to Joel?

The first film's surviving detective opens this one. He is trying to pass the entity on deliberately, to a man he has decided deserves it, and the attempt collapses — the prologue is essentially a short film about the one strategy the first movie left available, failing. It closes the previous ending and puts the entity on Skye in a single sequence.

Do you need to have seen the first film?

It helps and it is not required. The rules are restated, the prologue resolves the first film's final scene, and Skye's story is self-contained. The main thing you lose is the sense of how much nastier this one is, which is most of the point.

If Smile 2 is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Smile 2 in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

More lists like these: Movies like Evil Dead · Books like Between Two Fires

Questions about Smile 2

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

How does Smile 2 end?

Skye believes she has been cured by a group of survivors and goes on stage free of it. None of that happened — there was no group, and she never left her apartment. The entity takes her in front of a sold-out arena, pulling her face into the smile while twenty thousand people watch and record it.

Was the support group in Smile 2 real?

No. Morris, the other survivors, the method and the recovery were all constructed by the entity. The tell is that the cure arrives exactly when Skye has run out of options and on terms she badly wants to accept, which is how it has worked on every host in both films.

How does the curse in Smile 2 spread?

By witnessing. An infected person kills themselves in front of a chosen witness, who then has about a week. In between, the entity wears the faces of people the host trusts and uses trauma that is already there rather than inventing any.

Why does the entity kill Skye on stage?

Because witnesses are what it needs, and an arena is the most it can get from one death. The first film ended with a single person watching. This one ends with a full venue and every phone in it recording, which is the only direction the premise could escalate in.

Is Smile 2 scarier than Smile?

Faster and nastier, which is not quite the same thing. We score it 076 on pace and 082 on viscera, both well above the first film, and the ending is far bleaker. Viewers who found the original's jump-scare rhythm tiring will find more of it here.

Do I need to watch Smile before Smile 2?

It helps but it is not required. The rules are restated early, the prologue resolves the first film's last scene, and Skye's story stands alone. What you lose without it is the sense of how much further this one goes.

What should I watch after Smile 2?

Smile for the original, It Follows for the other great film about a thing that is passed on, and cursed horror for everything here that travels.

These are ranked against Smile 2, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy