Film · 2019
Annabelle Comes Home
Gary Dauberman
The Warrens go out for the night. Somebody opens the case. Everything else wakes up.
43Strong to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is
- PaceBuilds, then strikes60
- ThreatSomething not human10
- GoreShows almost nothing14
- ToneGrim, with air46
- RealityTilts unreal58
Era bias 86 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →
The most supernatural horror movies ever made →
Part of a series: The Conjuring universe movies in order →
On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Annabelle Comes Home (2019) is most extreme on the threat axis: 10 out of 100, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. 2% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →
Annabelle Comes Home is a 2019 American supernatural horror film directed by Gary Dauberman. While Ed and Lorraine Warren are away overnight, their daughter Judy's babysitter's friend breaks into the locked room of cursed objects and lets the doll out of its case. We score it 010 on the threat axis and 046 on tone.
Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score
How scary is Annabelle Comes Home, actually?
Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean.
The threat at 010 is near the supernatural end — 8 works score lower. A demonic doll and a room's worth of cursed objects; no person harms anyone.
Viscera 014 is restrained — 16 works score lower. Nobody dies and almost no blood is shown; the violence is chases, grabbing hands and a dog attack.
Tone 046 is on the lighter side — 263 works score lower. A night of terror that ends in a birthday party, with real jokes along the way.
Pace 060 is on the shock side, with 193 works slower. A ghost-train structure, moving from one set-piece to the next.
Era bias 086 reads modern — 240 works score lower. A period suburban house with a 2019 digital finish and creature work.
Reality anchor 058 leans unreal — 190 works score lower. Many entities with different rules share one house in one night.
On jump scares: many. It is built on them, and most come from the objects in the room.
Who should skip Annabelle Comes Home
Skip it if you want the Warrens. They are in the first and last scenes and away for everything between.
Skip it if you want real menace. Nobody dies, and the ending is deliberately comforting.
Skip it if a film that is mostly set-pieces annoys you. It is a night of haunted objects taking turns.
Content notes: possession of a teenage girl, a child and teenagers chased and terrorised, a dog attack, grief and guilt over a parent's death, and frequent loud jump scares.
Watch it if you want one of the lightest, most fun entries in the Conjuring universe, you like Mckenna Grace, and you have always wanted to see what is in the rest of the artefacts room.
Annabelle Comes Home on six axes of fear
Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Annabelle Comes Home looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.
Where that puts it: joint #7 supernatural · joint #9 without gore
Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores
Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →
Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.
Annabelle Comes Home: the review
Annabelle Comes Home is the Conjuring universe's sleepover film, and a film that openly admits it is having fun.
The premise is one the franchise had been building towards since the first film opened on a glass case: what if somebody opened it? Gary Dauberman, who wrote Annabelle: Creation and here directs for the first time, sets it almost entirely inside the Warrens' house over one night. Ed and Lorraine leave their daughter Judy with a babysitter, Mary Ellen. Mary Ellen's friend Daniela, who wants to contact her dead father and apologise for the car accident that killed him, lets herself into the artefacts room, handles everything in it, and opens Annabelle's case. The doll then wakes everything else in the room.
A haunted house in which every room is a different film
That is the whole structure, and it is a good one. The artefacts room was always one of the series' best ideas, a museum of other people's cases, and here it empties out into the house. There is the Ferryman, who stalks Mary Ellen because she resembles one of his earlier victims. There is the Bride, a spirit that will end up possessing Daniela. There is a Feeley Meeley board game with hands inside it, and the Black Shuck, a hellhound that goes after Mary Ellen's would-be boyfriend Bob. Each one gets its own set-piece in its own corner of the house, and the film moves between them like a ghost train.
What keeps it from being merely a ride is Judy. Mckenna Grace, taking over the role from Sterling Jerins, plays her as a lonely child who seems to share her mother's sight and has certainly inherited her parents' reputation; her classmates turn down her birthday invitation because of what her parents do, and she has been seeing a ghostly priest following her. She is the one who understands the rules: Annabelle has to go back in the case before the rest of the room will rest. Grace makes a sad, steady centre for a film that otherwise runs on adrenaline.
One of the gentlest films in the Conjuring line
It is worth being clear what kind of film this is. Nobody dies. The Warrens are in the first and last scenes and absent in between. The threat is a night of terror for three teenagers and a child, ending with a birthday party and a message of forgiveness. Its scares are loud but its stakes are small, and it has a sense of humour about Bob, about babysitting and about the ludicrous number of haunted things one couple chose to keep in their house. Rotten Tomatoes' consensus called it fun for fans but less frightening than its predecessors, and that is a fair reading. It is the entry to show someone who is not sure about horror.
Babysitters, rules and a locked door
The film's structure owes as much to the babysitter thriller as to the haunted house. There is a responsible older girl, a reckless friend, a boy who turns up uninvited, a lonely child and a room the parents have told everyone to stay out of. Dauberman lays those pieces down patiently in the first act, and the patience pays off: by the time Daniela opens the case, the audience knows exactly where every object is and exactly what should not be touched. Madison Iseman makes Mary Ellen a likeable, sensible lead, and Katie Sarife gives Daniela's grief real weight. Her reason for breaking in, a father who died in a car crash she feels responsible for, is the film's emotional spine, and the ending pays it off with more care than a film of this kind needs to.
Michael Burgess's photography keeps the Warren house dim and warm, a family home rather than a gothic pile, and Joseph Bishara's score is the series' familiar mix of strings and dissonance. The film was announced as an untitled Conjuring Universe entry before it was revealed as an Annabelle film, and Wan and Safran said at Comic-Con in 2018 that its story would focus on the doll in the Warrens' museum, which is exactly what it does. You need nothing but the premise to follow it, which makes it an easy entry point for anyone who has not seen the earlier films, and Mckenna Grace's Judy is a better guide to the Warrens' world than most of the adults the franchise has given us.
Where it falls down
Its strengths are also the problem. With so many entities sharing one night, none of them is developed, and several, especially the Feeley Meeley game, are ideas rather than threats. The Black Shuck is just a big dog. Annabelle herself, the supposed lead, mostly gets moved around by other things, which leaves the title character as a prop in her own film. And the film's ending is so warm, with the classmates turning up after all and Lorraine passing on a message from Daniela's father, that it drains any lingering unease.
None of those flaws are fatal, because the film never claims to be more than a night of escalating trouble in a house full of bad objects, and on those terms it delivers. It is dedicated to Lorraine Warren, who died in April 2019, two months before it opened. It grossed about $231 million worldwide and had the lowest opening weekend of any Conjuring film.
For the doll's origin, Annabelle; for the film that introduced the Warrens, The Conjuring; and for the whole series in watching order, the Conjuring movies in order.
The ending of Annabelle Comes Home explained
The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.
The short answer: Judy works out that the other spirits will only rest when Annabelle is back in her blessed case. With the ghostly priest's help, the girls learn that the Ferryman has hidden the doll in a locked closet, and the key is inside the Feeley Meeley game, whose hands grab at them as they take it. Daniela, by now possessed by the Bride, is stopped when Judy projects Ed's film of the Bride's exorcism onto her. The girls put Annabelle in the case, the demon holds the door open with its mind, and Daniela helps force it closed and lock it. The haunting stops at once. In the morning the Warrens come home, Judy's classmates come to her party after all, and Lorraine takes Daniela into the artefacts room to pass on a reassuring message from her father, so that Daniela can forgive herself.
What happens at the end of Annabelle Comes Home?
Annabelle is locked back in her blessed case after the girls retrieve her from a closet where the Ferryman hid her. Daniela, freed from the Bride's possession, helps them force the door shut against the demon. Everything in the house falls quiet. The next day Judy has her party, and Lorraine gives Daniela a message from her dead father.
What did Daniela do in Annabelle Comes Home?
She sneaked into the Warrens' artefacts room hoping to contact her father, who had died in a car accident she felt responsible for. She touched the haunted objects and opened Annabelle's case, which released the demon and woke the rest of the room. She spends the night trapped, tormented and then possessed, and ends it helping to lock the doll away.
What objects come alive in Annabelle Comes Home?
Annabelle wakes several of the room's spirits: the Ferryman, who pursues Mary Ellen; the Bride, a spirit that possesses Daniela; a Feeley Meeley board game with grasping hands; and the Black Shuck, a hellhound that attacks Bob. A ghostly priest who follows Judy turns out to be on her side.
Does anyone die in Annabelle Comes Home?
No. Bob is attacked by the Black Shuck, Daniela is possessed by the Bride, and Mary Ellen and Judy are chased through the house, but everyone survives the night. A single night that ends with a party is a large part of why it plays so much lighter than its siblings.
If Annabelle Comes Home is your kind of fear
The eight works closest to Annabelle Comes Home in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.
Insidious: The Red Door
Patrick Wilson · 2023 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
90% shared signal
Insidious: Chapter 3
Leigh Whannell · 2015 · Film
Shares restraint over gore.
88% shared signal

The Nun
Corin Hardy · 2018 · Film
Shares a threat that is not human.
87% shared signal
Insidious: Chapter 2
James Wan · 2013 · Film
Shares restraint over gore.
87% shared signal
The Conjuring 2
James Wan · 2016 · Film
86% shared signal

Insidious
James Wan · 2010 · Film
86% shared signal

Annabelle
John R. Leonetti · 2014 · Film
86% shared signal
It
Tommy Lee Wallace · 1990 · Television
89% shared signal
More lists like these: Movies like The Nun · Movies like Insidious
Questions about Annabelle Comes Home
The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.
What happens at the end of Annabelle Comes Home?
Judy, Mary Ellen and Daniela recover Annabelle from a closet where the Ferryman hid her and lock her back in her blessed case, which quiets every spirit in the house. The Warrens return in the morning, Judy's classmates come to her party, and Lorraine passes Daniela a message from her dead father.
Who opens Annabelle's case in Annabelle Comes Home?
Daniela Rios, the babysitter Mary Ellen's friend, played by Katie Sarife. She sneaks into the Warrens' artefacts room hoping to contact her father, who died in a car accident she blamed herself for. She handles the cursed objects and opens the case, releasing the demon and waking the rest of the room.
Is Annabelle Comes Home scary?
It is jumpy rather than disturbing. We score it 014 on viscera and 046 on tone, which makes it one of the lighter entries in its franchise. Nobody dies, the scares come in a run of set-pieces, and the night ends with a birthday party.
Where does Annabelle Comes Home fit in the Conjuring timeline?
Director Gary Dauberman said it takes place shortly after the first Conjuring, with the opening showing the Warrens bringing the doll home from the two nurses. Mckenna Grace took over the role from Sterling Jerins.
Who directed Annabelle Comes Home?
Gary Dauberman, in his directorial debut. He wrote the screenplay from a story he developed with James Wan, and had written Annabelle: Creation. Wan and Peter Safran produced. The film is dedicated to Lorraine Warren, who died in April 2019.
These are ranked against Annabelle Comes Home, not against you.
Build your own tape →