VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films

BARBARIAN F-1003 · 2022 · FILM

Film · 2022

Barbarian

Zach Cregger

A double-booked rental in Detroit, a door behind a door, and three men who each made it worse.

70Hard going to sit through, out of 100 — mostly how bleak it is

  • PaceBuilds, then strikes60
  • ThreatMostly people68
  • GoreExplicit78
  • ToneBleak30
  • RealityGrounded30

Era bias 90 · Thoroughly modern. Texture rather than fear, so it is not part of the grade. All six scores →

The goriest horror movies ever made →

CREATUREHUMAN MONSTERBLACK COMEDYTRAP
Start your fear profile from these scores — everything below re-sorts by how close it is.

On VHSCREAM’s six-axis scale, Barbarian (2022) is most extreme on the viscera axis: 78 out of 100, where 0 is restraint over gore and 100 is explicit viscera. 80% of the 320 horror works we have scored come in lower on that axis. How we score →

Barbarian is a 2022 horror film written and directed by Zach Cregger. A woman arrives at a short-let rental in a derelict Detroit street to find it double-booked, and there is a door in the basement that should not be there. We score it 078 on viscera and 068 on the threat axis, and the second number is the film's actual argument.

Scored and reviewed by VHSCREAM on · how we score

How scary is Barbarian, actually?

Scored against the published rubric, here is what the numbers mean for a viewer.

The threat at 068 leans human, which is the film's argument rather than a technicality. 96 works score higher. There is a creature in it and the creature is a consequence: every harm in the film traces to Frank, who built the rooms, and AJ, who owned them without looking. The axis measures where the danger originates, and here it originates with two men.

Viscera 078 is high. 54 works score higher. A head on a railing, a fall, a bite, forced breastfeeding, and a skull crushed by hand — most of it quick and none of it coy.

Era bias 090 is modern. 291 works score lower. Clean 2022 digital photography, a short-let app, a phone that works, and a sound design with real sub-bass in it.

Pace 060 is on the shock side. 193 works are slower. Three structural handovers and a set piece every eight or nine minutes once the basement opens.

Tone 030 is bleak with laughs in it. 104 works score higher. The AJ material is genuinely funny and the film's subject is the industrial-scale abuse of women in a hole under a street, which it never plays for comedy.

Reality anchor 030 is grounded. A house, a street, a basement, a water tower. Nothing in the film is impossible, including the creature.

On jump scares: a handful, and the most effective moment is a woman standing at the end of a corridor doing nothing.

Who should skip Barbarian

Barbarian on six axes of fear

Every work in the index is scored on six continuous axes of fear. This is what Barbarian looks like as a vector — and what each ten-point band looks like across everything else we hold.

PACE OF FEAR 60 Builds, then strikes
THE THREAT 68 Mostly people
VISCERA 78 Explicit
ERA BIAS 90 Thoroughly modern
TONE 30 Bleak
REALITY ANCHOR 30 Grounded

Where that puts it: joint #10 modern

Draft score — awaiting human review. About these scores

Disagree with a number? Say so on the axis itself. Nobody has confirmed this vector yet, and a score you challenge goes to the top of the queue to be re-scored by a human. Votes do not move the numbers — they decide what gets looked at first. How the scoring works →

Scored against the published rubric. This vector is a draft awaiting review — the method is public so you can argue with it.

Where to find it

Find where to stream it ↗Physical copies on eBay ↗

We earn nothing from these links.

Barbarian: the review

The structure is the trick, and it works

Barbarian is built as three films stacked on top of each other and its best joke is making you spend twenty minutes braced for the wrong one. The opening is a two-hander about a woman alone in a house with a strange man, played with such precision — Georgina Campbell doing the arithmetic every woman in that situation does, Bill Skarsgård being either considerate or rehearsed — that the audience spends the whole sequence sure it knows what kind of film this is.

It is not that film. Then it hands you over to AJ, a man flying in to deal with his property, whose section is a comedy about a career; and then it goes under the house. Each handover costs the audience its footing, which is a structural effect no amount of staging buys you.

What it is actually about

The creature is the product of a man. Frank bought a house in a nice street in the sixties, abducted women, kept them in the rooms he dug out underneath, and the Mother is what generations of that produced. She is feral, enormously strong, and the only thing she wants is to mother somebody — which she pursues with a violence that the film is careful never to make funny.

So the threat score sits well into the human end of the axis despite the film having a monster in it. Everything the Mother does was set in motion by two men: one who built the rooms and one who bought the house without looking at them. Cregger's cleverest move is making AJ — not a predator, just a man who has done something bad and will not say the word — the one who keeps making it worse, right up to the last thirty seconds.

The neighbourhood

The one thing in the film that goes beyond mechanics. The street is empty because the city emptied, and Frank's house stands in it intact while everything around it has gone, which means the horror was there the whole time and the surrounding decay is what made it visible. Andre, the only other person out there, is written with more dignity than this kind of film usually manages and gets the film's one piece of real exposition.

Where it strains

The Mother is at her best in silhouette and at her weakest in full light, where the design is just a tall woman. The tunnels go on slightly too long and the film starts explaining its own layout. Frank's flashback is the most conventional stretch in it. And the final sequence asks AJ to do something so monstrous that the film tips, for about a minute, from argument into punchline.

Still the best-engineered mainstream horror film of its year, and the first half hour is a masterclass.

The ending of Barbarian explained

The ending, in full. Open it when you have seen it.

The short answer: Tess and AJ get out of the tunnels and climb the water tower with the Mother coming after them. At the top, AJ throws Tess off to save himself. She survives the fall, badly broken, and the Mother leaps down and curls around her protectively. AJ climbs down, picks up a gun, and shoots at the Mother — hitting Tess instead. The Mother then kills AJ by crushing his head. Tess takes the gun and shoots the Mother dead. The film ends with Tess alone on the ground, alive.

Here is how the film gets there.

Who is the Mother?

The product of decades of captivity and incest in the rooms under the house. She is not supernatural: she is a human being raised entirely underground by a man who abducted women and bred them. Her enormous strength, her inability to speak and her single compulsion — to mother somebody, by force — are all consequences rather than powers.

Who is Frank?

The man who bought the house in the 1960s, dug out the rooms beneath the street, and abducted and raped women in them for years. The film shows him in flashback stalking a pregnant woman and buying baby supplies, which is how the Mother came to exist. When AJ finds him in the present he is very old, and he shoots himself rather than explain anything.

What is AJ's role?

He owns the house, having bought it as an investment without ever going into the basement, and he arrives in Detroit because his acting career has collapsed under a sexual assault allegation he will not describe accurately. He is not the monster and he is the reason almost everything gets worse: he measures the tunnels to add square footage to the listing, he will not accept what he is being told, and on the tower he throws Tess off to buy himself a few seconds.

Who is Andre?

The only other person living on the street, in a derelict house, who warns Tess about the property and tells her what he knows about what is underneath it. He is the film's one source of real information and the only character whose behaviour is uncomplicatedly decent.

What happens to Keith?

He is killed in the tunnels in the first act, which is the film's first structural reversal: the man the opening has spent twenty minutes inviting you to suspect is the first person to die trying to help.

Is the Mother a villain?

The film is deliberate about refusing that. She kills several people, she is terrifying, and she is also the only person in the story who was never given a choice about anything. Tess kills her at the end because there is no other available outcome, not because the film has made a case that she deserved it.

If Barbarian is your kind of fear

The eight works closest to Barbarian in the index on the five axes that describe fear, the same medium first — not by genre label, and not by what other people watched.

More lists like these: Movies like 28 Years Later · Movies like Dawn of the Dead

Questions about Barbarian

The things people actually ask about this film, answered — including how it ends.

How does Barbarian end?

On the water tower AJ throws Tess off to save himself. She survives and the Mother leaps down and shields her. AJ shoots at the Mother and hits Tess; the Mother then crushes his head. Tess takes the gun and kills the Mother, and the film ends with her alone on the ground, alive.

Who is the Mother in Barbarian?

Not a supernatural creature — the product of decades of captivity and incest in the rooms Frank dug under the street. Her strength, her silence and her single compulsion to mother somebody by force are all consequences of how she was raised, which is why the film keeps refusing to let her be the villain.

What did Frank do in Barbarian?

He bought the house in the 1960s, excavated rooms beneath it, and abducted and raped women there for years. The flashback showing him stalking a pregnant woman and buying baby supplies is how the Mother came to exist. He shoots himself when AJ finds him.

Is AJ the villain of Barbarian?

Not the monster, and the reason almost everything gets worse. He owns the house without having looked at it, measures the tunnels to raise the listing price, will not describe what he is accused of, and throws Tess off a water tower. Cregger uses him to make the film's point about who causes this.

Why does Barbarian change main characters?

Because each handover takes the audience's footing away. The opening is a two-hander about a woman and a strange man; the second act is a comedy about a career; the third is underground. No amount of staging buys the effect that structure does.

Is Barbarian scary or funny?

Both, deliberately, and it never crosses the two. We score it 030 on tone, so the register is bleak — the AJ material is funny and the subject is what was done to women in a hole under a street, and the film does not make jokes about the second thing.

What should I watch after Barbarian?

Us for another horror film whose monster is a policy decision, The Descent for the best underground sequence anybody has shot, and the creature tag for everything here built around a thing rather than a person.

These are ranked against Barbarian, not against you.

Build your own tape →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy