VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films / By decade / 2020s

Horror movies 2023, scored on six axes

Nine films from 2023, each scored 0 to 100 on six measured axes of fear and carrying a full review. This is not a list of everything 2023 released. It is everything from 2023 we have been through in full, which is a smaller and more useful thing: a reader who wants all of 2023 has a hundred options, and a reader who wants to know which one is the bleak one has none.

Our pick: Beau Is Afraid. Three hours, and the only film here that nobody else could have made. Infinity Pool is the one that will actually upset you and No One Will Save You does more with silence than anything in the year.

Within 2023, the bleakest is Infinity Pool at 012 and the most gleeful Scream VI at 058, the most restrained is Insidious: The Red Door at 022 and the most explicit Evil Dead Rise at 092, the slowest is Infinity Pool at 034 and the fastest Evil Dead Rise at 080.

2023 is the least coherent year this index holds, which is a description rather than a complaint. Six films sharing almost nothing: a three-hour surrealist odyssey, a near-silent alien siege, a resort satire about watching copies of yourself die, a chainsaw sequel, a killer-doll comedy and the tenth Saw. Tone runs from 012 to 054 and viscera from 044 to 092, and the two films people most want explained afterwards — by a wide margin, on search demand — are the two strangest in it.

Every 2023 horror film we have scored

All six axes. Each runs 0 to 100 and describes what the film is rather than how good it is: Pace dread to shock · Threat inhuman to human · Viscera restraint to explicit · Era analog to modern · Tone bleak to gleeful · Reality grounded to surreal.

TitleByPaceThreatVisceraEraToneReality Signature
Beau Is AfraidAri Aster038078060084022092Reality Anchor
Evil Dead RiseLee Cronin080028092086026040Viscera
Infinity PoolBrandon Cronenberg034072084088012064Tone
Insidious: The Red DoorPatrick Wilson058014022088036070The Threat
M3ganGerard Johnstone058034052090054044The Threat
No One Will Save YouBrian Duffield072016044086040056The Threat
Saw XKevin Greutert062090090084022026The Threat / Viscera (tied)
Scream VIMatt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett078096078086058020The Threat
The Nun IIMichael Chaves070010030088032064The Threat

What each one is

The one-line reason each is in the index.

Beau Is Afraid — A man tries to fly home to his mother and the journey takes three hours and everything he has.

Evil Dead Rise — The book comes out of a bank vault under a condemned apartment block, and the mother upstairs reads it.

Infinity Pool — Kill someone on holiday and the law offers you a choice: be executed, or watch a copy of you die instead.

Insidious: The Red Door — A father and son who forgot the Further start to remember it. Gentle, then not.

M3gan — A robotics engineer gives her orphaned niece a doll that will do anything to keep her.

No One Will Save You — A woman the whole town refuses to speak to, alone in her house, with something in the hallway.

Saw X — John Kramer flies to Mexico for a cure that does not exist, and the people selling it have a bad week.

Scream VI — Ghostface in New York. Bigger, bloodier, and built around a shrine to itself.

The Nun II — Sister Irene chases the demon nun to a French boarding school built on a saint's relic.

What the numbers say about 2023

Measured against the average of all 236 films in the index. Era bias is left out: it tracks release year closely enough across film that a recent year scoring modern is the axis repeating itself rather than a finding.

Questions about 2023 horror movies

What is the best horror movie of 2023?

Our pick is Beau Is Afraid. Three hours, and the only film here that nobody else could have made. Infinity Pool is the one that will actually upset you and No One Will Save You does more with silence than anything in the year. The table above is every 2023 film in this index with all six scores, so you can choose on the axis you care about instead of on somebody's ranking.

How many 2023 horror movies have you scored?

Nine. That is deliberately not a list of everything released in 2023 — it is every 2023 film we have watched in full and scored against a published rubric, each with a review and its ending explained. A hundred sites will give you fifty titles; none of them will tell you which one is bleak.

Which 2023 horror movie is the scariest?

On the one axis where a more extreme score really does mean harder to endure — the bleak end of tone — it is Infinity Pool at 012. Every other axis measures a kind of fear rather than an amount, which is why we have a page on why there is no single scariest.

Is this every horror film from 2023?

No, and it is not trying to be. We publish a score only for a work we have been through in full, so this page grows when we have watched something rather than when a release calendar does. What it does guarantee is that every title on it has six numbers you can argue with and a review behind them.

Want horror matched to you rather than to a year?

Build your tape →

All 2020s horror, compared → · The best horror movies, grouped → · 70s horror movies · 80s horror movies · 90s horror movies · 2000s horror movies

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy