VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Films / By decade

2000s horror movies, scored on six axes

Every 2000s horror film in this index: 40, each scored from 0 to 100 on six scored axes of fear and carrying a full review. Not a ranking — the table below is the whole decade with all its numbers, so you can choose on the axis you care about.

Our pick: Let the Right One In (2008). A vampire film that is really about two children and is pitiless about both of them. The one we actually press on people from this decade is Lake Mungo, which almost nobody has seen.

Within the decade, the bleakest is Martyrs at 003, the most explicit is Martyrs at 096, the most patient is Lake Mungo at 006.

What the 2000s did to horror

The hard decade. Whatever you think of it, nothing in the index declines to let you out
as consistently as the horror of the 2000s does — its typical film is the bleakest of
any decade we have scored.

Three movements, running in parallel and loathing each other. The American
punishment cycle
: Saw (2004) and the films it spawned, which critics named torture
porn in 2006 and which were, whatever else they were, the first horror films in decades
to be genuinely about bodies being destroyed on purpose rather than incidentally. The
New French Extremity
, named in Artforum in 2004, which did something harder — the
craft was unimpeachable and the content was worse, and Martyrs (2008) is the only
film in this index we would warn somebody about before recommending it. And found
footage
, which Paranormal Activity (2007) turned from a one-off trick into an
industry by discovering that a fixed tripod and a long static shot are more frightening
than a camera that moves.

The decade's best film is probably none of those. Lake Mungo (2008) is a mock
documentary about grief that hides its worst image in plain sight, almost nobody has
seen it, and it is the most frightening thing we have scored.

Every 2000s horror film we have scored

All six axes, in release order. Each runs 0 to 100 and describes what the film is rather than how good it is: Pace dread to shock · Threat inhuman to human · Viscera restraint to explicit · Era analog to modern · Tone bleak to gleeful · Reality grounded to surreal.

TitleYearByPaceThreatVisceraEraToneReality
Final Destination2000James Wong074030076068048044
Ginger Snaps2000John Fawcett044048066042036034
Scream 32000Wes Craven066096044032074020
Session 92001Brad Anderson016074026036012040
The Others2001Alejandro Amenábar018038008044010044
28 Days Later2002Danny Boyle076072066054018020
Dog Soldiers2002Neil Marshall072024078044056036
Halloween: Resurrection2002Rick Rosenthal066080052066048022
Jason X2002James Isaac074024074066072080
The Ring2002Gore Verbinski032020032048014060
A Tale of Two Sisters2003Kim Jee-Woon018048042058010058
Final Destination 22003David R. Ellis078030084070058044
Freddy vs. Jason2003Ronny Yu072018074062066076
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre2003Marcus Nispel072094074062010016
Saw2004James Wan068092082074018028
Seed of Chucky2004Don Mancini062050072060086070
Shaun of the Dead2004Edgar Wright058020064052080030
The Grudge2004Takashi Shimizu056008022066012066
Hostel2005Eli Roth060094092070012014
Saw II2005Darren Lynn Bousman070090082072016030
The Descent2005Neil Marshall074032074052014024
The Devil's Rejects2005Rob Zombie066096086048028012
Saw III2006Darren Lynn Bousman062092090072010028
Slither2006James Gunn068015084058076050
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning2006Jonathan Liebesman070096086066006014
14082007Mikael Hafstrom062010042070020068
28 Weeks Later2007Juan Carlos Fresnadillo082066074070010022
Halloween2007Rob Zombie062090076058010014
Paranormal Activity2007Oren Peli046014010062020034
Saw IV2007Darren Lynn Bousman070090086074014032
The Mist2007Frank Darabont060056076072006048
Lake Mungo2008Joel Anderson006040004070012008
Let the Right One In2008Tomas Alfredson016028044058012034
Martyrs2008Pascal Laugier062078096072003025
Saw V2008David Hackl064092084074016028
The Strangers2008Bryan Bertino046096044062008010
Drag Me to Hell2009Sam Raimi066008062066066072
Friday the 13th2009Marcus Nispel070084072076024014
Halloween II2009Rob Zombie058072084054006046
Saw VI2009Kevin Greutert068090088076024028

What each one is

The one-line reason each is in the index, which is the shortest honest answer to “is it worth my evening”.

Final Destination (2000) — Death as a Rube Goldberg machine. Cheerfully, elaborately explicit.

Ginger Snaps (2000) — Two sisters obsessed with death, and then one of them is bitten the same week her body changes.

Scream 3 (2000) — Ghostface goes to Hollywood. A backstage farce with Sidney's past buried under it.

Session 9 (2001) — An asbestos crew in an empty asylum. The building wins on patience.

The Others (2001) — A woman keeps every curtain drawn because her children are allergic to light.

28 Days Later (2002) — Shot on video, running flat out. The soldiers are the third act.

Dog Soldiers (2002) — Six soldiers on a training exercise in Scotland, one farmhouse, and the thing outside has a family.

Halloween: Resurrection (2002) — Six students, head cameras and a live webcast from inside the Myers house.

Jason X (2002) — Four hundred years on ice, then a spaceship full of students. Same machete.

The Ring (2002) — The American one, and better than it is given credit for.

A Tale of Two Sisters (2003) — Two sisters, a stepmother and a house where the chronology is the thing that is wrong.

Final Destination 2 (2003) — One log truck, eight strangers, and Death working down its list in reverse.

Freddy vs. Jason (2003) — A forgotten dream demon hires the help, and the help will not stop.

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) — The best-looking version of the story, and the one that understands it least.

Saw (2004) — A bathroom, two men and a hacksaw. The franchise it spawned shows everything.

Seed of Chucky (2004) — Killer dolls, a lost child and Jennifer Tilly playing herself. Pure camp.

Shaun of the Dead (2004) — A man fails to notice the apocalypse. The best-built comedy in the genre.

The Grudge (2004) — A Tokyo house where a murder became a curse, and everyone who walks in is next.

Hostel (2005) — Backpackers chasing a good time find out they were the product all along.

Saw II (2005) — Eight people, one house, two hours of nerve gas. The sequel that made Saw a series.

The Descent (2005) — Claustrophobia first, creatures second. The cave was already enough.

The Devil's Rejects (2005) — A killer family on the run and a sheriff worse than they are. Horror as outlaw western.

Saw III (2006) — A dying man, a collared doctor and a father told to forgive. Nobody is forgiven.

Slither (2006) — Small-town body horror played for laughs, and the laughs do not soften it.

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006) — An origin story that explains nothing and spares no one.

1408 (2007) — A man who debunks haunted hotels for a living takes the one room that is not a fraud.

28 Weeks Later (2007) — London is declared safe. One kiss in a quarantine room says otherwise.

Halloween (2007) — Michael Myers gets a childhood, a motive and Rob Zombie's grime. The mystery does not.

Paranormal Activity (2007) — A fixed camera and a bedroom door. Shows less than almost anything in the index.

Saw IV (2007) — Jigsaw is on the autopsy table and the games keep coming. Watch the clock, not the cops.

The Mist (2007) — A supermarket, a white wall outside it, and a woman who knows exactly who to blame.

Lake Mungo (2008) — A mock-documentary about grief that hides its worst image in plain sight.

Let the Right One In (2008) — A vampire film about being twelve and alone in the snow.

Martyrs (2008) — New French Extremity at its most punishing. There is no relief anywhere in it.

Saw V (2008) — Five strangers, four rooms, one lesson learned too late. Hoffman takes the chair.

The Strangers (2008) — Three people in masks, no motive, and the worst answer in horror: because you were home.

Drag Me to Hell (2009) — A curse, a loan officer and a great deal of fluid. Raimi back on form.

Friday the 13th (2009) — A brother searching Crystal Lake for his sister finds a man who never left.

Halloween II (2009) — A year on, Laurie is coming apart and Michael is following his mother's ghost home.

Saw VI (2009) — An insurance man denies one claim too many. The series finds something to be angry at.

What the numbers say about the 2000s

The other decades

70s horror movies · 80s horror movies · 90s horror movies · 2020s horror movies · all eight decades, compared

Questions about 2000s horror movies

What are the best 2000s horror movies?

Our pick is Let the Right One In. A vampire film that is really about two children and is pitiless about both of them. The one we actually press on people from this decade is Lake Mungo, which almost nobody has seen. The table above is every 2000s film in this index with all six of its scores, so you can pick on what you actually want rather than on a ranking — and the best horror movies, grouped by what frightens you does the same across every decade.

How many 2000s horror movies have you scored?

40, every one carrying six measured axes of fear and a full review with its ending explained. That is a deliberately small number: we score what we have been through in full against a published rubric rather than listing everything released.

What makes 2000s horror different from other decades?

Reality anchor 036 against 047 across all 236 films, 11 points below — leaning toward grounded realism. The 2000s profile is measured against the average of all 236 films in the index, not against a critical consensus.

Which 2000s horror movie is the scariest?

On the one axis where a more extreme score genuinely means harder to endure — the bleak end of tone — it is Martyrs at 003. Every other axis measures a kind of fear rather than an amount, which is why we have a whole page on why there is no single scariest.

Horror by decade → · The best horror movies, grouped → · All 236 films →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy