VHSCREAM BUILD YOUR TAPE

Index / Ranked / Books

The most supernatural horror novels ever written

Ranked on VHSCREAM’s threat axis, where 0 is a threat that is not human and 100 is human monsters. These are the 12 lowest-scoring of the 36 horror novels and collections we have scored. Every number is scored against a published rubric, drafted with machine assistance and marked a draft until a human confirms it — never an average of votes.

Print got here first and has never really left. The bottom of the threat axis in our book index is where the ghost story, the curse and the cosmic intrusion live — the forms that horror fiction invented and film borrowed. Ranked by measurement, so a novel with a human villain and a haunted house scores higher than its cover suggests.

The most supernatural horror novels ever written, ranked

#TitleYear ByThe Threat
1The Exorcist1971William Peter Blatty008
2At the Mountains of Madness1936H. P. Lovecraft010
2Between Two Fires2012Christopher Buehlman010
4Bird Box2014Josh Malerman015
4The Fisherman2016John Langan015
4The Hollow Places2020T. Kingfisher015
7'salem's Lot1975Stephen King018
8Annihilation2014Jeff Vandermeer020
8The Woman in Black1983Susan Hill020
10Books of Blood1984Clive Barker025
10Ring1991Koji Suzuki025
10The Elementals1981Michael McDowell025

Scores run 0–100 on a single axis and say nothing about quality. The top of this list is the most extreme on one axis, not the best film on it.

Close to the top of this list? Books like Between Two Fires

What the numbers say about this list

The list runs from 008 at number one to 025 for the last of the 12. The median of all 36 novels and collections we have scored on this axis is 035, so every entry here is past it — this is a tail rather than the top of a flat curve.

Eight of these 12 also place on another of our ranked lists — At the Mountains of Madness, Between Two Fires, The Fisherman among them. Extremity tends to arrive on more than one axis at a time, which is the most useful thing six numbers tell you that one cannot.

The same axis, over a different shelf

Threat is scored the same way whatever the medium, so these ask the same question of the other media we score.

The most supernatural horror movies ever made · The most supernatural horror albums ever recorded · The most purely supernatural horror television

Questions about the most supernatural horror novels ever written

What is the most purely supernatural horror novel in your index?

The Exorcist (1971), at 008 on threat. Next on the list is At the Mountains of Madness at 010, and the last of the 12 on this list scores 025. The full table is above, with the year and the creator for each.

How is this list of horror novels and collections ranked?

By one measured axis and nothing else. We score all 36 horror novels and collections in the index on six continuous axes against fixed anchor works, then sort by threat and take the 12 lowest. There is no vote, no average of other people's ratings and no overall score — the numbers on this page are the whole ranking, and they run 008 to 025.

What does the threat axis measure?

Where a work sits between a threat that is not human at 0 and human monsters at 100. It is a description rather than a verdict: a work can be at either end and be excellent or worthless. Among the novels and collections in this index the median on this axis is 035, which is the number worth holding in mind while you read the list — 008 means something only against it.

Are these the scariest horror novels and collections?

Not as a claim we would make. Threat measures one thing, and only the bleak end of tone is simply harder to endure — the other five axes describe a kind of fear rather than an amount. The Exorcist tops this list at 008 and scores 014 on tone, which are two separate facts about it. The scariest horror we have scored takes the question apart properly.

Want this ranked against you rather than against the axis?

Build your tape →

Every ranked book list → · All 36 novels and collections → · How the axes relate →

Insert tape · dispatches

Keep this tape

Occasional dispatches from the index. The first is your Halloween programme, before 31 October. No spam.

We keep your address, and your tape if you have built one, to send these emails and nothing else. Privacy